Starving the enemy: how plant and microbe compete for sugar on the border

Jingsheng Chen, Zhen Gao, Guosheng Xiao, Rujie Shi, Chanjuan Zhao, Qianqian Zhang, Shuo Yang, Yuanhu XuanFrontiers in Plant Science 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Plants and microbes are locked in a constant battle for sugar, the primary energy source for both. This paper explores how plants and pathogens manipulate sugar transporters, particularly SWEETs, to gain an advantage. Understanding these intricate molecular interactions is crucial for developing strategies to enhance crop yield and disease resistance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The escalating global demand for food, coupled with the significant threat posed by plant diseases, necessitates a deeper understanding of plant-pathogen interactions. A critical aspect of this interaction is the competition for essential nutrients, with sugars being a prime target. Pathogens exploit plant sugar transport systems to fuel their growth, often at the expense of the host plant's yield. While some key transporters involved in this sugar competition have been identified in plants like Arabidopsis, corn, and rice, the regulatory mechanisms governing these transporters, especially in microbial pathogens, remain largely unexplored. This paper aims to shed light on these mechanisms and the roles of various sugar transporters in this "evolutionary arms race."

Methods

This paper is a review, synthesizing existing research rather than presenting novel experimental data. It draws upon transcriptomic analyses, gene expression studies, and functional characterization of sugar transporters in various plant-pathogen systems. The authors analyze data from studies involving Arabidopsis, corn, rice, and their interacting pathogens, including bacteria and fungi. The review focuses on identifying key sugar transporters (SWEETs, MSTs, SUTs, and invertases) and their roles in sugar efflux, influx, and hydrolysis at the host-pathogen interface.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a review and synthesizes data from previously published studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sugar as a Battleground: Sugar isn't just food; it's a critical resource that dictates the outcome of plant-pathogen interactions. Both hosts and pathogens actively manipulate sugar transport to their advantage.
  • SWEETs: The Pathogen's Gateway: The SWEET family of sugar transporters, primarily responsible for exporting sugars from plant cells to the apoplast, are frequently hijacked by pathogens. Pathogens induce the expression of these SWEET genes, effectively creating a sugar leak that fuels their growth.
  • The "Evolutionary Arms Race": The competition for sugar is a dynamic process. Plants attempt to recover leaked sugars and limit pathogen access, while pathogens evolve strategies to efficiently acquire these sugars, leading to a continuous evolutionary struggle.
  • Invertases: Sugar Scramblers: Invertases (INV) play a crucial role in breaking down sucrose into simpler sugars (fructose and glucose). Both plants and pathogens utilize invertases, influencing the availability and type of sugars at the interaction site.
  • Beyond Simple Transport: Sugar transporters are not just passive conduits. They can act as signaling molecules, influencing plant immunity and defense responses.
  • Microbial Sugar Strategies: Pathogens employ diverse strategies, from directly absorbing sucrose to hydrolyzing it into hexoses, depending on their specific sugar preferences and the host's defenses. Some pathogens even utilize high-affinity sucrose transporters to outcompete plant transporters.

Key Results

The paper highlights the identification of key sugar transporters (SWEETs, MSTs, SUTs, and invertases) in various plant-pathogen interactions. It demonstrates that:

  • SWEETs are consistently upregulated in response to pathogen infection, facilitating sugar efflux into the apoplast. Examples include specific SWEET genes in rice being induced by Rhizoctonia solani, Ustilaginoidea virens, Magnaporthe oryzae, and Xanthomonas oryzae.
  • Pathogens actively target plant SWEETs through various mechanisms, including the secretion of effectors (e.g., TAL effectors) that directly regulate SWEET gene expression.
  • Plant invertases (CWINs) are activated during pathogen invasion, increasing hexose levels in the apoplast, which can then be utilized by both the plant and the pathogen.
  • Plant monosaccharide transporters (MSTs) and sucrose transporters (SUTs) play a role in recovering leaked sugars and limiting pathogen access, contributing to plant defense.
  • Microbial sugar transporters are crucial for pathogen virulence, with examples like Ustilago maydis's Srt1 (sucrose transporter) and Botrytis cinerea's FRT1 (fructose transporter) demonstrating high affinity and specificity for their respective substrates.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Regulatory Mechanisms in Microbes: The paper explicitly states that the regulatory mechanisms of sugar transporters, especially in microbes, require further investigation. This is a significant gap in our understanding.
  • Trade-off between Yield and Immunity: The authors note a potential trade-off between enhancing plant resistance through SWEET manipulation and maintaining crop yield, as some SWEET gene mutations associated with disease resistance also lead to reduced grain weight. Further research is needed to fully understand and potentially decouple these two traits.
  • Broader Spectrum Resistance: The paper suggests that enhancing plant resistance could involve combining multiple genes and developing broad-spectrum disease resistance strategies, moving beyond single-gene resistance.
  • Investigating Pathogen Sugar Transporters: Understanding the functions of sugar transport proteins in pathogens with different sugar preferences is crucial for identifying immune-related regulatory pathways and developing effective disease resistance strategies.
  • Signal Transduction Pathways: Further exploration of plant sugar metabolism, signal transduction, and sugar transport pathways is needed to fully elucidate the complex interplay between plants and pathogens.

Summary updated

Abstract

As the primary energy source for a plant host and microbe to sustain life, sugar is generally exported by Sugars Will Eventually be Exported Transporters (SWEETs) to the host extracellular spaces or the apoplast. There, the host and microbes compete for hexose, sucrose, and other important nutrients. The host and microbial monosaccharide transporters (MSTs) and sucrose transporters (SUTs) play a key role in the "evolutionary arms race". The result of this competition hinges on the proportion of sugar distribution between the host and microbes. In some plants (such as <i>Arabidopsis</i>, corn, and rice) and their interacting pathogens, the key transporters responsible for sugar competition have been identified. However, the regulatory mechanisms of sugar transporters, especially in the microbes require further investigation. Here, the key transporters that are responsible for the sugar competition in the host and pathogen have been identified and the regulatory mechanisms of the sugar transport have been briefly analyzed. These data are of great significance to the increase of the sugar distribution in plants for improvement in the yield.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2023starving,
  author = {Jingsheng Chen and Zhen Gao and Guosheng Xiao and Rujie Shi and Chanjuan Zhao and Qianqian Zhang and Shuo Yang and Yuanhu Xuan},
  title = {{Starving the enemy: how plant and microbe compete for sugar on the border}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2023.1230254},
}
Figure