Standardizing Clinical NGS Applications—Based on ACMG Standards

Seunghyun Yoon, C. C. Tchoyoson LimCambridge 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper addresses the growing challenges in standardizing clinical applications of Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) due to diverse platforms, evolving technologies, and inconsistent validation. It summarizes the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) guidelines to provide a framework for molecular diagnostic professionals, particularly in China, to ensure high-quality NGS results and reliable clinical interpretation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) has revolutionized genetic testing, making it more accessible and affordable. However, its rapid advancement has led to a proliferation of sequencing platforms, varying technological approaches, and a lack of consistent clinical validation protocols. This creates confusion for laboratories, leading to variability in sequencing results and their interpretation. The paper aims to bridge this gap by outlining the ACMG's professional standards and guidelines for clinical NGS applications, offering a much-needed roadmap for standardization and quality assurance in this dynamic field.

Methods

The paper doesn't introduce novel methods but rather synthesizes and discusses existing professional standards and guidelines from the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG). It categorizes NGS analysis into three levels: disease-targeted gene panels, exome sequencing (ES), and whole-genome sequencing (GS). The authors then delve into critical factors for conducting NGS work, including:

  • Sequencing Content: Emphasizing the selection of genes with strong scientific evidence for disease association.
  • Sequencing Platforms and Methods: Discussing considerations like coverage, sample volume, run time, and cost, as well as single-end vs. paired-end sequencing.
  • Data Analysis Tools: Highlighting the importance of base-calling algorithms, reference genome alignment, and variant identification/annotation.
  • Variant Filtration: Stressing the need for automated classification tools to distinguish benign from pathogenic variants and balancing over-filtering with under-filtering.
  • Homologous Region Sequencing: Addressing the challenges posed by pseudogenes and repetitive sequences.
  • File Formats: Advocating for standard formats like BAM and VCF.
  • NGS Operation Validation: Detailing the necessity of validating equipment, reagents, and laboratory-developed tests.
  • Quality Control (QC): Outlining pre-analytical, analytical, and post-analytical QC measures, including sample quality, personnel qualifications, and data storage.
  • Reference Materials and Proficiency Testing: Emphasizing their role in ensuring accuracy and compliance.
  • Sequencing Request Forms, Report Formats, and Result Interpretation: Providing guidance on essential information for requests, clear reporting of findings (including VUSs), and accurate interpretation aligned with ACMG guidelines.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on guidelines and standards rather than experimental data or specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Wild West" of NGS Needs Taming: The rapid growth of NGS technology has outpaced standardization, leading to inconsistencies that can impact patient care. ACMG guidelines offer a crucial framework to bring order to this field.
  • Three Tiers of NGS Complexity: Understanding the distinctions between targeted panels, exome sequencing, and whole-genome sequencing is fundamental for selecting the right approach for a given clinical question.
  • Validation is Non-Negotiable: Simply having the technology isn't enough; rigorous validation of every step – from sample prep to data analysis and interpretation – is paramount for clinical utility.
  • The Nuance of Variant Interpretation: Distinguishing benign variants from pathogenic ones is complex. The paper highlights the importance of robust filtration, leveraging reference databases, and the careful handling of Variants of Uncertain Significance (VUSs).
  • Communication is Key: Effective collaboration between laboratories and clinicians is essential for accurate interpretation and to avoid misinterpretations of complex genetic data.

Key Results

This paper does not present experimental results or quantitative findings. Its primary contribution is the synthesis and discussion of existing ACMG standards and guidelines for clinical NGS applications. The "results" are the recommendations and best practices outlined for laboratories.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • The paper acknowledges that the widespread clinical application of whole-genome sequencing is still maturing.
  • It notes the potential decrease in genomic stability over time for certain reference materials.
  • The paper implicitly suggests that the rapid pace of technological advancement means guidelines will need continuous updates.

Future Work:

  • The authors intend this paper to serve as a reference for molecular diagnostic professionals, particularly in China, for formulating domestic industry standards.
  • The paper encourages laboratories to store clinical sequencing data in public databases.
  • It suggests that laboratories should regularly communicate with clinicians about updates regarding VUS knowledge.
  • The conclusion emphasizes that future clinical applications of NGS technology still need to be further perfected, implying ongoing development and refinement are necessary.

Summary updated

Abstract

Next-generation sequencing (NGS)technology has been applied in clinical laboratories. The development of this technology, along with the expansion of testing scale and scope, has significantly reduced the cost of genetic testing. The clinical applications of NGS are continuously expanding, including targeted gene panel testing, individual exome, or whole-genome analysis. Moreover, NGS technology has further improved treatment decision-making and prediction for high-risk populations of certain diseases. However, the development of NGS also poses challenges, including the confusion of choices brought by sequencing platforms and technological updates, and the inconsistency of clinical validation of sequencing results. To help clinical laboratories better understand NGS technology, resolve issues related to clinical validation, and correctly select NGS sequencing platforms and methods, as well as to continuously monitor NGS and ensure high-quality sequencing results and their clinical interpretation, this article summarizes and discusses the professional standards and guidelines of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG)regarding the clinical application of NGS technology. This is intended for reference by molecular diagnostic professionals in China when formulating domestic industry standards.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yoon2025standardizing,
  author = {Seunghyun Yoon and C. C. Tchoyoson Lim},
  title = {{Standardizing Clinical NGS Applications—Based on ACMG Standards}},
  booktitle = {Cambridge},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.62852/csa/2025/155},
}
Figure