Stakeholder Analysis for the Food-Energy-Water Nexus in Phoenix, Arizona: Implications for Nexus Governance

Dave D. White, J. Leah Jones-Crank, Ross Maciejewski, Rimjhim Aggarwal, Giuseppe MascaroSustainability 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how stakeholders in Phoenix, Arizona, understand the interconnectedness of food, energy, and water (FEW) systems. It reveals that while the concept of a FEW nexus is recognized, practical implementation faces challenges due to institutional silos and differing perspectives, highlighting the need for improved communication and collaborative governance strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the critical challenge of managing complex, interconnected systems like food, energy, and water (FEW). These systems are increasingly linked through global markets and shared resources, meaning failures in one can cascade to others, creating new societal risks. However, policy and management decisions are often made in isolation, failing to account for these interdependencies. The authors aim to understand how key actors in the Phoenix region perceive these connections and what this means for effective, integrated FEW governance, particularly in a water-scarce, arid environment.

Methods

The study employs a qualitative, case-study design focused on the Phoenix Active Management Area. The core methodology involves:

  • Stakeholder Identification and Analysis: A nonprobability sampling strategy (expertise-based, purposive, stratified, and snowball sampling) was used to identify key informants with significant experience in FEW systems.
  • Data Collection: Qualitative data was gathered through moderated focus groups (five, two-hour sessions) and semi-structured individual interviews (14). These sessions explored participants' understanding of the FEW nexus, identified key stakeholders, and discussed policy recommendations.
  • Data Analysis: Transcribed data was analyzed using content analysis with the MAXQDA software. This involved identifying key concepts from literature and developing inductive codes from the data. The analysis focused on understanding stakeholder perceptions of FEW linkages, identifying influential actors, and gathering policy recommendations.
  • Conceptual Mapping: The analysis resulted in code co-occurrence models (Figures 2-5) that visually represent the identified interactions and their complexity, offering a "stakeholder-derived" view of the FEW nexus.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on qualitative data generated through interviews and focus groups with stakeholders.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Nexus" is a Newer Concept, but Connections are Recognized: While the term "nexus" is relatively new and can be perceived as jargon ("wonky"), stakeholders readily acknowledge the underlying connections between food, energy, and water systems, especially the water-energy link.
  • Practicality vs. Theory: Stakeholders appreciate the rationale behind nexus thinking for managing risks and achieving efficiencies but express significant reservations about its practical understandability and implementability, particularly when communicating with diverse audiences.
  • Water-Energy Dominance: The water-energy nexus is perceived as the most complex and well-understood interaction among the FEW components, likely due to its direct relevance in an arid region like Phoenix and existing policy discussions.
  • Food-Energy Link is Weakest: The food-energy connection was identified as the least understood and least complex, suggesting a potential blind spot or fewer direct linkages in the local context.
  • Economics as a Central Driver: Economic considerations, including costs, pricing, and resource allocation, are central to stakeholders' understanding of the FEW nexus.
  • Institutional Silos Persist: Despite recognizing the need for integration, stakeholders operate within distinct institutional frameworks (e.g., water agencies, energy providers, agricultural groups), which can hinder holistic decision-making.
  • Key Influencers Identified: The Arizona Department of Water Resources (ADWR), Central Arizona Project (CAP), and Salt River Project (SRP) are consistently identified as the most powerful and influential actors in the Phoenix FEW nexus.
  • Policy Recommendations Focus on Incrementalism: Stakeholders advocate for improvements through awareness and education, consensus and collaboration, transparency, economic incentives, working across scales, and incremental reforms, rather than radical policy overhauls.

Key Results

  • Salience and Utility: Participants generally found the FEW nexus concept meaningful but expressed concerns about its clarity and ease of communication. Some felt their organizations were too sector-focused to fully engage with the nexus.
  • Interaction Complexity: Conceptual maps revealed varying levels of perceived complexity: water-energy interactions were seen as highly complex, water-food as moderately complex with a strong emphasis on groundwater pumping and irrigation, and food-energy as the least complex.
  • Stakeholder Landscape: A broad range of stakeholders were identified, with ADWR, CAP, and SRP being consistently mentioned as most powerful. Irrigation districts were highlighted as having "fingers in all three" sectors.
  • Policy Insights: Participants identified numerous federal and state policies affecting the FEW nexus, with the 1980 Arizona Groundwater Management Act being particularly significant. Recommendations for improving nexus governance centered on collaboration, transparency, and education.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that while stakeholders appreciate the rationale for nexus thinking, they recognize practical limitations to implementation.
  • The paper notes that participants did not suggest the need for new significant federal or state laws, and in some cases, recommended easing existing regulations, which contrasts with scholarly calls for transformational change.
  • The focus on a single geographic region (Phoenix AMA) limits generalizability.
  • Future Work:
    • Future research could focus more directly on the effects of increased risks, shocks, and cascading failures on stakeholders' perceptions of the need for and types of policies and reforms to improve nexus governance.
  • The study's conceptual maps can complement other visualization methods like physical infrastructure diagrams or actor-networks for a more comprehensive understanding.
  • The research provides a foundation for developing more sophisticated computer models, simulations, and decision support systems for FEW nexus management.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding the food-energy-water nexus is necessary to identify risks and inform strategies for nexus governance to support resilient, secure, and sustainable societies. To manage risks and realize efficiencies, we must understand not only how these systems are physically connected but also how they are institutionally linked. It is important to understand how actors who make planning, management, and policy decisions understand the relationships among components of the systems. Our question is: How do stakeholders involved in food, energy, and water governance in Phoenix, Arizona understand the nexus and what are the implications for integrated nexus governance? We employ a case study design, generate qualitative data through focus groups and interviews, and conduct a content analysis. While stakeholders in the Phoenix area who are actively engaged in food, energy, and water systems governance appreciate the rationale for nexus thinking, they recognize practical limitations to implementing these concepts. Concept maps of nexus interactions provide one view of system interconnections that be used to complement other ways of knowing the nexus, such as physical infrastructure system diagrams or actor-networks. Stakeholders believe nexus governance could be improved through awareness and education, consensus and collaboration, transparency, economic incentives, working across scales, and incremental reforms.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{white2017stakeholder,
  author = {Dave D. White and J. Leah Jones-Crank and Ross Maciejewski and Rimjhim Aggarwal and Giuseppe Mascaro},
  title = {{Stakeholder Analysis for the Food-Energy-Water Nexus in Phoenix, Arizona: Implications for Nexus Governance}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/su9122204},
}
Figure