Abstract
Soft gamma repeaters (SGRs) have unique properties that make them intriguing targets for gravitational wave (GW) searches. They are nearby, their burst emission mechanism may involve neutron star crust fractures and excitation of quasinormal modes, and they burst repeatedly and sometimes spectacularly. A recent LIGO search for transient GW from these sources placed upper limits on a set of almost 200 individual SGR bursts. These limits were within the theoretically predicted range of some models. We present a new search strategy which builds upon the method used there by “stacking” potential GW signals from multiple SGR bursts. We assume that variation in the time difference between burst electromagnetic emission and burst GW emission is small relative to the GW signal duration, and we time-align GW excess power time-frequency tilings containing individual burst triggers to their corresponding electromagnetic emissions. Using Monte Carlo simulations, we confirm that gains in GW energy sensitivity of $N^{1/2}$ are possible, where $N$ is the number of stacked SGR bursts. Estimated sensitivities for a mock search for gravitational waves from the 2006 March 29 storm from SGR 1900+14 are also presented, for two GW emission models, “fluence-weighted” and “flat” (unweighted).
Introduction: The Challenge of Faint Signals
Soft Gamma Repeaters (SGRs) are neutron stars—likely magnetars with extreme magnetic fields—that sporadically emit intense bursts of gamma rays. Physicists suspect these bursts are triggered by "starquakes" (crustal fractures) that should also excite non-radial oscillations in the star, emitting transient gravitational waves. However, these GW signals are expected to be incredibly faint. Previous searches by the LIGO Scientific Collaboration analyzed nearly 200 individual SGR bursts but found no detections, setting upper limits constrained by the signal-to-noise ratio of single events. This research addresses the need for a more sensitive search strategy that leverages the repetitive nature of SGRs.
Methodology: Coherent vs. Incoherent Stacking
The proposed "Stack-a-flare" strategy builds upon the existing LIGO "Flare pipeline" by time-aligning GW data from multiple bursts based on their electromagnetic (EM) triggers. Two primary architectures were evaluated:
- T-Stack (Coherent Stacking): This method aligns and adds raw GW time-series data before processing. While theoretically the most sensitive, it is extremely fragile, requiring sub-millisecond timing precision and identical signal phases across all bursts.
- P-Stack (Incoherent Stacking): This method processes each burst into a time-frequency "power tiling" (spectrogram) first, then aligns and adds the resulting significance matrices. This approach is much more robust to timing uncertainties and phase variations between bursts.
Results: Sensitivity Gains and Mock Search
Through Monte Carlo simulations, the authors confirmed that energy sensitivity scales with $\sqrt{N}$, where $N$ is the number of stacked bursts. For a mock search based on the SGR 1900+14 "storm" of March 29, 2006, stacking 18 bursts provided a gain in energy sensitivity of approximately an order of magnitude compared to a single-burst search covering the entire storm period.
While T-Stack is more sensitive under ideal conditions, it fails if timing errors exceed $\sim 100 \mu s$ for a 1 kHz signal. P-Stack remains effective even with timing jitters on the order of the signal duration (tens of milliseconds), making it the practical choice for real-world application.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
The stacking method significantly narrows the gap between experimental upper limits and theoretical predictions. For a 1090 Hz ringdown signal, the P-Stack method reached an isotropic energy sensitivity ($E_{GW}^{90\%}$) of roughly $10^{48}$ erg at a distance of 10 kpc.
The primary limitation remains the assumption of signal consistency across bursts. However, with the advent of Advanced LIGO—offering a 10x improvement in strain sensitivity—stacking searches could potentially reach the energy regimes predicted by theoretical magnetar models, moving from setting upper limits to making the first detections of SGR gravitational waves.
Summary updated