Abstract
A coupled Sun-to-Earth model is the goal for accurate forecasting of space weather. A key component of such a model is a whole atmosphere model – a general circulation model extending from the ground into the upper atmosphere – since it is now known that the lower atmosphere also drives variability and space weather in the upper atmosphere, in addition to solar variability. This objective motivates the stable extension of The Met Office’s Unified Model (UM) into the Mesosphere and Lower Thermosphere (MLT), acting as a first step towards a whole atmosphere model. At the time of performing this research, radiation and chemistry schemes that are appropriate for use in the MLT had not yet been implemented. Furthermore, attempts to run the model with existing parameterizations and a raised upper boundary led to an unstable model with inaccurate solutions. Here, this instability is examined and narrowed down to the model’s radiation scheme – its assumption of Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (LTE) is broken in the MLT. We subsequently address this issue by relaxation to a climatological temperature profile in this region. This provides a stable extended UM which can be used as a developmental tool for further examination of the model performance. The standard vertical resolution used in the UM above 70 km is too coarse (approx. 5 km) to represent waves that are important for MLT circulation. We build on the success of the nudging implementation by testing the model at an improved vertical resolution. Initial attempts to address this problem with a 3 km vertical resolution and a 100 km lid were successful, but on increasing the resolution to 1.5 km the model becomes unstable due to large horizontal and vertical wind velocities. Increasing the vertical damping coefficient, which damps vertical velocities near the upper boundary, allows a successful year long climatology to be produced with these model settings. With the goal of a whole atmosphere model we also experiment with an increased upper boundary height. Increasing the upper model boundary to 120 and 135 km also leads to stable simulations. However, a 3 km resolution must be used and it is necessary to further increase the vertical damping coefficient. This is highly promising initial work to raise the UM into the MLT, and paves the way for the development of a whole atmosphere model.
Introduction
Space weather—which can disrupt satellites, GPS, and power grids—isn't just a product of solar activity. We now know that waves and tides propagating upward from the lower atmosphere significantly drive variability at the edge of space. To forecast this accurately, scientists need a "whole atmosphere model" that simulates everything from the ground to the exobase (~600 km).
The challenge is that most weather models, like the Met Office’s Unified Model (UM), have a "lid" at around 85 km. Simply raising this lid causes the model to crash. The physics that works at sea level often breaks down in the thin air of the upper atmosphere. Specifically, standard radiation schemes assume Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (LTE)—the idea that molecules collide frequently enough to maintain a consistent local temperature. Above 65 km, this assumption fails, leading to unrealistic heating, extreme wind speeds (up to 600 m/s), and mathematical instability.
Methodology for Model Stabilization
To extend the UM into the Mesosphere and Lower Thermosphere (MLT), researchers employed several strategies to stabilize the model as they pushed its boundary upward.
Temperature Nudging (Relaxation)
Since a full Non-LTE radiation scheme was not yet implemented, the authors bypassed the broken LTE calculations above 70 km. Instead, they "nudged" the model toward a prescribed climatological temperature profile based on established satellite and atmospheric data (USSA, CIRA, and COSPAR). This "nudged" model acts as a stable developmental laboratory, allowing researchers to test dynamics and resolutions while more complex Non-LTE radiation and chemistry modules are being built.
Vertical Resolution and Grid Tuning
The model was tested at 3 km and 1.5 km vertical resolutions. While 1.5 km is better for capturing the gravity waves that drive upper-atmosphere circulation, it is more prone to instability. The vertical grid must be carefully constructed to handle the transition into the MLT.
Enhanced Damping: The Sponge Layer
To prevent waves from reflecting off the top of the model and causing numerical "noise," the authors increased the vertical damping coefficient ($\mu$). This "sponge layer" is critical for maintaining stability at higher altitudes and finer resolutions.
Halo Extension
In parallel computing, a "halo" is a buffer of data shared between processors. Because horizontal winds are much faster in the MLT, the authors had to enlarge these halos to prevent data-access errors during advection.
Key Results and Insights
The primary cause of model instability was identified as the physical misapplication of the LTE assumption, which led to "runaway" heating at the summer poles and impossible wind speeds. By addressing this through nudging and damping, the following results were achieved:
- Stability Achieved: Successful, year-long stable simulations were produced with model lids at 100 km, 120 km, and 135 km.
- Realistic Winds: Wind speeds were brought down from an unphysical 600 m/s to a realistic ~100 m/s, matching observational data from the UARS Reference Atmosphere Project (URAP).
- Resolution Success: At 100 km altitude, a 1.5 km vertical resolution was achieved using a damping coefficient of $\mu = 0.3 \text{ s}^{-1}$. For higher lids (120–135 km), a 3 km resolution was found to be the most stable configuration for current testing.
Future Work
The current "nudging" approach is a temporary fix that limits the model's ability to simulate day-to-day variability. Future steps include:
- Implementing Non-LTE Physics: Replacing relaxation with physically consistent Non-LTE radiation code.
- Chemistry Integration: Adding the UKCA (UK Chemistry and Aerosols) scheme to account for chemical heating.
- Molecular Physics: Adding molecular viscosity and diffusion to replace empirical damping above 130 km.
- Tidal Analysis: Investigating how well the extended model captures atmospheric tides crucial for ionospheric coupling.
Summary updated