Stable breast cancer prognosis

Xiaomei Li, Lin Liu, Jiuyong Li, Thuc Duy LebioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces DGBCox, a novel method for predicting breast cancer prognosis that remains stable even when the data distribution shifts between training and testing. By combining deep learning for feature extraction with causal inference techniques for robust feature selection, DGBCox offers improved accuracy and stability compared to existing methods, paving the way for more reliable clinical decision-making.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Predicting breast cancer prognosis is crucial for effective treatment and management. Many existing models rely on transcriptomic data and assume that the data used for training and testing come from the same distribution. However, in real-world scenarios, this assumption often breaks down due to the inherent heterogeneity of breast cancer and variations in data collection environments (e.g., different hospitals or labs). This "data distribution shift" can lead to a significant drop in prediction accuracy and stability, potentially impacting patient care. The paper addresses this critical challenge by developing a method that can maintain reliable prognostic predictions despite these shifts.

Methods

The core of the proposed DGBCox method lies in its innovative approach to feature extraction and selection:

  • Deep Auto-Encoder (DAE): High-dimensional gene expression data is first fed into a DAE. This neural network learns to compress the data into lower-dimensional "latent representations," effectively capturing the most important underlying patterns without being overly sensitive to noise or minor variations.
  • Survival Global Balancing (SGB): This component draws from causal inference theory. It re-weights the training data to identify features (genes) that have a causal relationship with survival outcomes, rather than just correlational ones. This is crucial because causal relationships are expected to be more stable across different environments. The SGB component specifically extends existing covariate balancing methods to handle censored survival data.
  • Regularized Cox Regression (Cox): The causally identified latent features are then used in a regularized Cox regression model. This model is trained to predict the hazard risk, which indicates the likelihood of a patient experiencing an event (like relapse or death) over time. Regularization (L1 and L2) is employed to prevent overfitting.

These three components are jointly optimized to balance prediction accuracy, reconstruction error, and the stability of the learned features.

Datasets

The study utilizes a comprehensive set of 13 genome-wide expression datasets, totaling 5668 breast cancer patients from various repositories. These include:

  • TCGA (TCGA753, TCGA500, TCGA1093)
  • METABRIC
  • European Genome-phenome Archive (EGA)
  • Bioconductor datasets (MAINZ, TRANSBIG, UPP, UNT, NKI)
  • Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) datasets (GSE6532, GEO736)
  • UK dataset
  • HEL dataset

The paper highlights that these datasets were collected using different platforms, pipelines, and from diverse patient populations, inherently representing the data distribution shifts the DGBCox method aims to address.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Causality for Stability: The fundamental insight is that focusing on causal relationships between genes and survival outcomes, rather than mere correlations, is key to achieving stable predictions across different data distributions.
  • Deep Learning for Robust Features: Using a DAE to extract latent representations is crucial for handling the high dimensionality of gene expression data and creating features that are less susceptible to noise and environmental variations.
  • Bridging Causal Inference and Survival Analysis: The paper successfully extends causal inference techniques (specifically covariate balancing) to the domain of censored survival data, a significant methodological contribution.
  • Interpretable Prognostic Markers: The identification of top-ranked genes through permutation importance provides biologically meaningful insights into the mechanisms driving stable breast cancer prognosis, linking them to known pathways like cell cycle and organelle organization.

Key Results

  • Superior Stability and Accuracy: DGBCox consistently outperformed baseline methods (Coxnet, DAECox) and state-of-the-art methods across 12 independent test datasets in terms of both prediction accuracy (C-index) and stability (Stability metrics).
  • Improved Risk Stratification: DGBCox demonstrated a superior ability to stratify patients into distinct risk groups, as evidenced by Log-rank tests showing statistically significant survival differences between groups across a higher number of datasets compared to other methods.
  • Identification of Key Genes: The top 50 ranked genes identified by DGBCox showed significant overlap with previously validated breast cancer signatures and were enriched in biologically relevant pathways like the cell cycle and organelle organization, suggesting their importance for stable prognosis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While the DAE reduces dimensionality, optimizing the SGB component for very high-dimensional gene expression data can still be computationally intensive. The paper addresses this by using latent features from the DAE as input for SGB.
  • Biological Validation: While the identified genes and pathways are biologically plausible and supported by existing literature, the authors note that further laboratory and clinical research is needed to fully verify the underlying biological mechanisms.
  • Generalizability: The study focuses on breast cancer. The authors suggest that the DGBCox method could potentially be adapted for prognosis prediction in other cancer types, which would be a valuable future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Predicting breast cancer prognosis helps improve the treatment and management of the disease. In the last decades, many prediction models have been developed for breast cancer prognosis based on transcriptomic data. A common assumption made by these models is that the test and training data follow the same distribution. However, in practice, due to the heterogeneity of breast cancer and the different environments (e.g. hospitals) where data are collected, the distribution of the test data may shift from that of the training data. For example, new patients likely have different breast cancer stage distribution from those in the training dataset. Thus these existing methods may not provide stable prediction performance for breast cancer prognosis in situations with the shift of data distribution. In this paper, we present a novel stable prediction method for reliable breast cancer prognosis under data distribution shift. Our model, known as Deep Global Balancing Cox regression (DGBCox), is based on the causal inference theory. In DGBCox, firstly high-dimensional gene expression data is transferred to latent network-based representations by a deep auto-encoder neural network. Then after balancing the latent representations using a proposed causality-based approach, causal latent features are selected for breast cancer prognosis. Causal features have persistent relationships with survival outcomes even under distribution shift across different environments according to the causal inference theory. Therefore, the proposed DGBCox method is robust and stable for breast cancer prognosis. We apply DGBCox to 12 test datasets from different breast cancer studies. The results show that DGBCox outperforms benchmark methods in terms of both prediction accuracy and stability. We also propose a permutation importance algorithm to rank the genes in the DGBCox model. The top 50 ranked genes suggest that the cell cycle and the organelle organisation could be the most relevant biological processes for stable breast cancer prognosis. Author summary Various prediction models have been proposed for breast cancer prognosis. The prediction models usually train on a dataset and predict the survival outcomes of patients in new test datasets. The majority of these models share a common assumption that the test and training data follow the same distribution. However, as breast cancer is a heterogeneous disease, the assumption may be violated in practice. In this study, we propose a novel method for reliable breast cancer prognosis when the test data distribution shifts from that of the training data. The proposed model has been trained on one dataset and applied to twelve test datasets from different breast cancer studies. In comparison with the benchmark methods in breast cancer prognosis, our model shows better prediction accuracy and stability. The top 50 important genes in our model provide clues to the relationship between several biological mechanisms and clinical outcomes of breast cancer. Our proposed method in breast cancer can potentially be adapted to apply to other cancer types.
BibTeX
@misc{li2021stable,
  author = {Xiaomei Li and Lin Liu and Jiuyong Li and Thuc Duy Le},
  title = {{Stable breast cancer prognosis}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.09.13.460002},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure