Stable acyclic aliphatic solid enols: synthesis, characterization, X-ray structure analysis and calculations

Yuqiang Zhou, Nai‐Xing Wang, Yalan Xing, Yanjing Wang, Xiaowei Hong, Jiaxiang Zhang, Dongdong Chen, Jing-Bo Geng, Yanfeng Dang, Zhixiang WangScientific 2013 · DOI

Introduction

In organic chemistry, keto-enol tautomerism is a fundamental concept describing the equilibrium between a carbonyl compound (keto) and its isomer, an alcohol with a double bond (enol). For simple aliphatic molecules like acetone, the keto form is overwhelmingly favored due to the strength of the C=O bond. Consequently, simple enols are typically transient intermediates, existing in concentrations too low for isolation under standard conditions. While stabilization has been achieved using bulky aryl groups or cyclic structures, creating stable, acyclic, aliphatic solid enols remains a challenge. This research presents a reliable synthetic route to these elusive molecules and explores the structural features that allow them to resist "flipping" back to their keto forms.

Synthetic Methodology

The researchers developed a catalytic approach to synthesize stable enols by reacting $\beta$-carbonyl esters (e.g., ethyl acetoacetate) with azodicarboxylates (e.g., diethyl azodicarboxylate, DEAD).

Synthesis of stable enol 3a from ethyl acetoacetate (1a) and DEAD (2a).

After screening various organic bases, the team identified a combination of quinine (a chiral alkaloid) and $Cs_2CO_3$ in dichloromethane (DCM) as the optimal catalytic system. This method yielded products with up to 99% efficiency without requiring complex purification steps.

Characterization and Structural Analysis

The synthesized compounds were rigorously confirmed using $^1H$ and $^{13}C$ NMR, Mass Spectrometry, and IR spectroscopy. Proton exchange experiments with $D_2O$ verified the presence of the hydroxyl group, as the characteristic enol signal disappeared upon deuteration. Single-crystal X-ray diffraction provided definitive proof of the enol structure, mapping the atomic arrangement and bond lengths.

Key Insights: Why are these Enols Stable?

The study reveals that these molecules are not merely stable; they are the thermodynamically preferred state. Several factors contribute to this "inverted" stability:

  • Intramolecular Hydrogen Bonding: X-ray analysis showed a short distance (1.789 Å in compound 3a) between the hydroxyl hydrogen and a nearby carbonyl oxygen. This strong O–H···O hydrogen bond forms a stable six-membered ring-like structure.
  • Electronic Conjugation: The hydrazine substituent facilitates extensive $p-\pi$ and $\pi-\pi$ conjugation, delocalizing electrons and stabilizing the double-bond system.
  • Thermodynamic Preference: Computational modeling using Gaussian 09 (M05-2X/6-31G**) indicated that the enol form is approximately 9.6 kcal/mol lower in energy than the keto isomer for these specific hydrazine-substituted structures. In most organic molecules, the keto form is 10–14 kcal/mol lower; here, the authors have effectively flipped the energy landscape.

Results and Discussion

The optimized reaction conditions consistently produced high yields (89%–99%) across various substrates, including $\beta$-carbonyl esters and ketones.

Optimized reaction conditions using Quinine and Cs2CO3 to produce stable enol series 3.

Notably, these enols are stable as solids under normal atmospheric conditions, unlike previous examples that required inert environments. The method's robustness was tested across a variety of R-groups, though bulky substituents like tert-butyl slightly reduced yields due to steric hindrance. However, the stabilization effect is highly dependent on the electronic environment; substrates lacking the specific $\beta$-substituent stabilization, such as propiophenone, yielded only trace amounts of product.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that acyclic aliphatic enols can be synthesized efficiently and remain stable as solids. By leveraging hydrazine substituents to flip the thermodynamic landscape, the researchers have turned transient intermediates into isolable building blocks. This discovery opens new avenues for using stable enols in organic synthesis and challenges traditional assumptions about tautomeric equilibria.

Summary updated

Abstract

A synthetic approach to stable enols was introduced and series of acyclic aliphatic solid enols were obtained and characterized. Relationship between the structure and the stability of these enols was discussed. Gaussian 09 calculations had been carried out to rationalize the stability of the enols. These enol structures were confirmed by (1)H NMR, (13)C NMR, MS, IR, partly by single crystal X-ray structure analysis and the protons exchange experiments. This work showed that very stable acyclic aliphatic enols can be synthesized efficiently without any purification.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2013stable,
  author = {Yuqiang Zhou and Nai‐Xing Wang and Yalan Xing and Yanjing Wang and Xiaowei Hong and Jiaxiang Zhang and Dongdong Chen and Jing-Bo Geng and Yanfeng Dang and Zhixiang Wang},
  title = {{Stable acyclic aliphatic solid enols: synthesis, characterization, X-ray structure analysis and calculations}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1038/srep01058},
}
Figure