Stability of Solitary Waves for a Generalized Derivative Nonlinear Schrödinger Equation

Xiao Liu, Gideon Simpson, Catherine SulemJ. Nonlinear Sci 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the stability of solitary wave solutions for a generalized derivative nonlinear Schrödinger equation (gDNLS). The authors establish criteria for orbital stability and instability based on the nonlinearity parameter $\sigma$ and the soliton's velocity, providing a comprehensive picture of these solutions' behavior. This work is crucial for understanding wave phenomena in various physical systems where such equations arise.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The derivative nonlinear Schrödinger (DNLS) equation and its generalizations appear in diverse physical contexts, such as modeling Alfvén waves in plasmas and ultrashort optical pulses. A key feature of these equations is the existence of solitary wave solutions, which are localized wave packets that maintain their shape over time. However, understanding whether these solitary waves are stable (i.e., small perturbations do not lead to their destruction) or unstable is a fundamental challenge. This paper addresses the problem of determining the orbital stability of solitary waves for a generalized version of the DNLS equation, where the nonlinearity is of the form $|u|^{2\sigma}u_x$. Specifically, they aim to classify these solutions as either orbitally stable or unstable based on the parameters of the equation.

Methods

The authors employ a rigorous mathematical framework based on the spectral analysis of the linearized operator around the solitary wave solution. This approach, rooted in the work of Grillakis, Shatah, and Strauss, involves two main components:

  1. Counting negative eigenvalues of the linearized operator ($H_\psi$): The number of negative eigenvalues of the linearized Hamiltonian operator near the solitary wave solution provides crucial information about its stability.
  2. Counting positive eigenvalues of the Hessian of the action functional ($d''(\omega, c)$): The Hessian of the action functional evaluated at the soliton, denoted $d''(\omega, c)$, is analyzed to determine the number of positive eigenvalues.

The stability criterion is then derived by comparing these two counts. The paper also utilizes numerical computations of a specific function $F(z; \sigma)$ to determine the sign of the determinant of the Hessian, which is essential for classifying stability for certain parameter ranges.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Parameter-dependent stability: The stability of solitary waves is not a universal property but strongly depends on the nonlinearity parameter $\sigma$ and the soliton's velocity $c$.
  • Critical $\sigma$ value: The behavior of solitary waves undergoes significant changes around $\sigma=1$ and $\sigma=2$. For $\sigma \ge 2$, all solitons are found to be unstable. For $\sigma < 1$, all solitons are stable. The intermediate regime $1 < \sigma < 2$ exhibits a mix of stable and unstable solitons, with stability depending on the velocity $c$.
  • Role of velocity: For $1 < \sigma < 2$, there exists a critical velocity $c = 2z_0\sqrt{\omega}$ (where $z_0$ is a specific value dependent on $\sigma$) that separates stable from unstable solitons. Slow solitons ($c < 2z_0\sqrt{\omega}$) are stable, while fast right-moving solitons ($c > 2z_0\sqrt{\omega}$) are unstable.
  • Numerical insights: Numerical calculations of the function $F(z; \sigma)$ are crucial for determining the stability criteria in the $1 < \sigma < 2$ regime, revealing a zero-crossing that defines the stability boundary.
  • Distinction from NLS: Unlike the standard nonlinear Schrödinger (NLS) equation, which typically only has stable solitons in the $L^2$-subcritical regime, the generalized DNLS equation can exhibit stable solitons even in the $L^2$-supercritical regime ($\sigma > 1$).

Key Results

  • For $\sigma \ge 2$: All solitary wave solutions are orbitally unstable.
  • For $0 < \sigma < 1$: All solitary wave solutions are orbitally stable.
  • For $1 < \sigma < 2$:
  • There exists a critical velocity $c = 2z_0\sqrt{\omega}$ (where $z_0$ is a specific value dependent on $\sigma$) that separates stable and unstable solitons.
  • Solitons with $c < 2z_0\sqrt{\omega}$ are orbitally stable.
  • Solitons with $c > 2z_0\sqrt{\omega}$ are orbitally unstable.
  • The paper provides a detailed spectral decomposition of the linearized operator and analyzes the Hessian of the action functional to rigorously prove these results.
  • Numerical simulations illustrate the stability of a perturbed stable soliton and the rapid amplitude increase (indicating instability) of a perturbed unstable soliton, with the latter potentially leading to a finite-time singularity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Well-posedness assumption: The stability results are based on the assumption that a weak solution exists. While this is a standard assumption in this field, a complete local well-posedness theory in $H^1$ for all $\sigma > 0$ is not fully established, particularly for $\sigma \neq 1$. The authors note that for $\sigma \ge 2$, one can obtain local solutions in $H^s$ for $s > 1$ using existing techniques.
  • Numerical dependence: The precise determination of the stability boundary for $1 < \sigma < 2$ relies on the numerical computation of the function $F(z; \sigma)$ and the identification of its root $z_0$. While the paper provides figures and discusses the monotonicity of $F$, a fully analytical determination of $z_0$ for all $\sigma$ in this range is not presented.
  • Singularity formation: The numerical simulations of unstable solitons suggest the possibility of finite-time singularity formation. The authors state that they will explore this potential in future work.
  • Critical solitons: The case where $c = 2z_0\sqrt{\omega}$ represents a critical regime where standard stability results might break down. Further detailed analysis is required for these cases.
  • Two-parameter solitons: The paper focuses on two-parameter solitons. Investigating one-parameter solitons, particularly in the context of critical cases, could be a direction for future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{liu2013stability,
  author = {Xiao Liu and Gideon Simpson and Catherine Sulem},
  title = {{Stability of Solitary Waves for a Generalized Derivative Nonlinear Schrödinger Equation}},
  journal = {J. Nonlinear Sci.},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1007/s00332-012-9161-2},
}
Figure