Stability of Quantum Systems beyond Canonical Typicality

Yu Su, Zi-Fan Zhu, Yao Wang, Rui–Xue Xu, YiJing YanarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Involvement of the environment is indispensable for establishing the statistical distribution of a system. We analyze the statistical distribution of a quantum system coupled strongly with a heat bath. This distribution is determined by tracing over the bath's degrees of freedom for the equilibrium system-plus-bath composite. The stability of the system distribution is largely affected by the system–bath interaction strength. We propose that the quantum system exhibits a stable distribution only when its system response function in the frequency domain satisfies $\tilde{\chi}(\omega= 0+)>0$. We show our results by investigating the non-interacting bosonic impurity system from both thermodynamic and dynamic perspectives. Our study refines the theoretical framework of canonical statistics, offering insights into thermodynamic phenomena in small-scale systems.

Introduction

Standard statistical mechanics relies heavily on the concept of "canonical typicality." This principle posits that a small quantum system (S) in contact with a large heat bath (B) will eventually reach a thermal equilibrium state described by the Boltzmann distribution. However, this textbook assumption is predicated on the condition that the interaction between the system and the bath is negligible ($|V_{SB}| \ll |H_S|$).

In modern contexts such as nanotechnology and biological physics, systems are often reduced to scales where surface interactions with the environment are comparable to or even dominate the system's internal energy. In these "strong-coupling" regimes, the standard canonical distribution fails to accurately describe the system's state. This paper addresses the fundamental boundaries of stability for such systems and quantifies their deviations from standard thermodynamics.

Theoretical Framework and Stability Criterion

To analyze these systems, the researchers utilized the Hamiltonian of Mean Force ($H_S^*$), an effective Hamiltonian that incorporates the environment's influence on the system's states. They focused on the Brownian Oscillator Model, a canonical model for quantum dissipation involving a non-interacting bosonic impurity.

The central finding is a universal stability criterion linked to the system's response function in the frequency domain, $\tilde{\chi}(\omega)$. The authors propose that a quantum system maintains a stable distribution if and only if: $$\tilde{\chi}(\omega = 0+) > 0$$ If this condition is violated (i.e., $\tilde{\chi}(0+) \leq 0$), the system fails to reach a stable thermal equilibrium; its coordinates and momenta will diverge over time, behaving like a "random walk" at the critical point.

Thermodynamic Stability and the Critical Point

From a thermodynamic perspective, the stability of the system is reflected in the behavior of the hybridization free energy ($A_{hyb}$). The researchers identified a critical threshold in the system-bath interaction strength, denoted by $\eta$. For a system with a natural frequency $\Omega_S$, the system becomes unstable when the environment-induced reorganization energy $\eta$ reaches half of this frequency.

The hybridization free energy $A_{hyb}$ exhibits a non-analytic cusp at the critical coupling strength $\eta = \Omega_S/2$, signaling a phase transition to instability.

As shown in Figure 2, the hybridization free energy is well-behaved for weak coupling but develops a sharp, non-analytic cusp at $\eta = \Omega_S/2$. Beyond this point, the thermodynamic description of the system as an equilibrium state becomes unphysical, as the free energy no longer follows a smooth, analytic path.

Dynamic Perspectives on Instability

The transition to instability is equally evident in the system's dynamics. Using Hierarchical Equations of Motion (HEOM), an exact numerical method, the authors tracked the time evolution of system variables across different coupling regimes.

Comparison of system dynamics across different coupling regimes. At the critical point ($\eta = 0.5\Omega_S$), the variance $\sigma_{qq}$ grows linearly with time, indicating a failure to reach equilibrium.

In the stable regime (e.g., $\eta = 0.2\Omega_S$), system variables like the variance of coordinates ($\sigma_{qq}$) and momenta ($\sigma_{pp}$) exhibit damped oscillations before reaching a steady state. However, as illustrated in Figure 3, at the critical point ($\eta = 0.5\Omega_S$), the variance $\sigma_{qq}$ increases linearly with time, indicating a transition to diffusive behavior. In the strongly unstable regime ($\eta = 0.8\Omega_S$), the system's coordinates and momenta diverge exponentially, precluding any form of thermal equilibrium.

Quantifying Non-Canonical Behavior

The researchers introduced the Subdivision Potential ($\mathcal{E}$) to measure the "non-canonicalness" of the system. This potential represents the energy difference arising from non-local entanglement between the system and its environment. Their analysis shows that this deviation is most significant at low temperatures and high coupling strengths. As temperature increases, thermal fluctuations tend to mask these entanglement effects, causing the system to behave more "canonically" as the subdivision potential approaches zero.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study provides a robust framework for understanding the limits of canonical statistics in strongly coupled quantum systems. By linking thermodynamic non-analyticity with dynamic divergence through the $\tilde{\chi}(0+) > 0$ criterion, the authors offer a powerful tool for predicting system stability.

While the current results are derived from the Brownian oscillator model, the proposed stability condition is expected to be general. Future work may involve extending this framework to more complex, non-linear systems or exploring the stability of systems that exchange particles (the grand canonical ensemble). Experimental verification in platforms like quantum dots or molecular junctions remains a key objective for the field.

Summary updated

Abstract

Involvement of the environment is indispensable for establishing the statistical distribution of system. We analyze the statistical distribution of a quantum system coupled strongly with a heat bath. This distribution is determined by tracing over the bath's degrees of freedom for the equilibrium system-plus-bath composite. The stability of system distribution is largely affected by the system--bath interaction strength. We propose that the quantum system exhibits a stable distribution only when its system response function in the frequency domain satisfies $\tildeχ(ω= 0+)>0$. We show our results by investigating the non-interacting bosonic impurity system from both the thermodynamic and dynamic perspectives. Our study refines the theoretical framework of canonical statistics, offering insights into thermodynamic phenomena in small-scale systems.
BibTeX
@misc{su2024stability,
  author = {Yu Su and Zi-Fan Zhu and Yao Wang and Rui–Xue Xu and YiJing Yan},
  title = {{Stability of Quantum Systems beyond Canonical Typicality}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2407.15345},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.15345},
}
Figure