Stability of Phase Difference Trajectories of Networks of Kuramoto Oscillators with Time-Varying Couplings and Intrinsic Frequencies

Wenlian Lu, Fatihcan M. AtaySIAM J. Appl. Dyn. Syst 2018 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper investigates the stability of phase differences in networks of Kuramoto oscillators when both their intrinsic frequencies and the connections between them change over time. The authors develop new mathematical conditions to guarantee that these phase differences will eventually stabilize, even when connections can be negative, and explore how this stability manifests in scenarios with periodic, perturbed, or rapidly switching parameters.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Kuramoto model is a fundamental tool for understanding how many coupled systems, from power grids to neural networks, can synchronize. Traditionally, this model assumes fixed connections and frequencies. However, real-world systems are dynamic; connections can fluctuate (e.g., due to changing communication links or social interactions), and individual components' natural frequencies can drift. This paper tackles the challenge of understanding and ensuring synchronization stability in such time-varying Kuramoto networks, a more realistic but mathematically complex scenario. Specifically, it focuses on the stability of phase differences (the relative timing between oscillators), which are key indicators of synchronization.

Methods

The authors extend existing stability analysis techniques for the Kuramoto model to handle time-varying couplings and frequencies. A core contribution is the development of sufficient conditions for asymptotic stability of phase differences. This involves:

  • Graph Theory: Utilizing concepts like spanning trees of time-varying graphs to establish stability criteria, particularly for non-negative couplings.
  • Lyapunov Stability Theory: Employing matrix measures and Lyapunov functions to derive conditions for stability, especially when couplings can be negative.
  • Perturbation Theory: Analyzing how small, time-varying perturbations affect the stability of phase-locked states.
  • Averaging and Fast Switching Analysis: Investigating scenarios where parameters change rapidly, allowing for analysis based on their average values.
  • Numerical Simulations: Illustrating the theoretical results with examples of networks with varying parameters.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and numerical examples generated by the authors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Time-Varying Dynamics: Synchronization in real-world systems isn't always about reaching a static, locked state. Instead, phase differences can settle into time-varying patterns, which is a generalization of the classic phase-locking phenomenon.
  • Spanning Trees for Stability: For non-negative couplings, the existence of a "spanning tree" in the aggregated time-varying graph over a certain interval is a powerful condition for ensuring phase difference stability.
  • Negative Couplings are Tractable: The paper provides concrete conditions for stability even when some connections are negative, which is relevant for systems with inhibitory interactions.
  • Scenarios of Stability: The authors identify specific conditions under which stability is achieved in common time-varying scenarios:
  • Periodic Parameters: If frequencies and couplings oscillate periodically, the phase differences can become asymptotically periodic.
  • Small Perturbations: Even with small, time-varying fluctuations around a stable state, the system can remain stable.
  • Fast Switching: When parameters switch rapidly between different values, the system can still synchronize, often converging to the behavior of an averaged system.

Key Results

The paper presents several theorems and propositions that provide sufficient conditions for the asymptotic stability of phase differences in time-varying Kuramoto networks. These conditions are demonstrated to hold for:

  • Non-negative couplings, requiring a spanning tree property of the time-varying graph.
  • The presence of negative couplings, using matrix measures.
  • Specific cases of time-varying parameters, including periodic, small perturbation, and fast-switching scenarios, where phase differences are shown to be asymptotically periodic or stable.
  • Numerical examples confirm that phase differences converge to stable, often periodic, trajectories under these conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sufficient Conditions: The paper provides sufficient conditions for stability, meaning that if these conditions are met, the system is stable. However, they may not be necessary, so a system could still be stable even if these specific conditions are not satisfied.
  • Interval of Stability: The analysis often focuses on phase differences remaining within a specific interval (e.g., [-π/2, π/2]). The behavior when phase differences exceed these bounds is not the primary focus.
  • Stochasticity: The paper primarily deals with deterministic time-varying parameters. Future work could explore the impact of stochastic (random) variations in couplings and frequencies.
  • Larger Phase Differences: The authors suggest future work to investigate situations where phase differences might be larger than π/2.
  • Complex Network Structures: While the paper considers general networks, exploring more complex topologies or specific real-world network structures could be a future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study dynamics of phase differences (PDs) of coupled oscillators where both the intrinsic frequencies and the couplings vary in time. In the case the coupling coefficients are all nonnegative, we prove that the PDs are asymptotically stable if there exists $T>0$ such that the aggregation of the time-varying graphs across any time interval of length $T$ has a spanning tree. We also consider the situation that the coupling coefficients may be negative and provide sufficient conditions for the asymptotic stability of the PD dynamics. Due to time variations, the PDs are asymptotic to time-varying patterns rather than constant values. Hence, the PD dynamics can be regarded as a generalization of the well-known phase-locking phenomena. We explicitly investigate several particular cases of time-varying graph structures, including asymptotically periodic PDs due to periodic coupling coefficients and intrinsic frequencies, small perturbations, and fast-switching near constant coupling and frequencies, which lead to PD dynamics close to a phase-locked one. Numerical examples are provided to illustrate the theoretical results.
BibTeX
@article{lu2018stability,
  author = {Wenlian Lu and Fatihcan M. Atay},
  title = {{Stability of Phase Difference Trajectories of Networks of Kuramoto Oscillators with Time-Varying Couplings and Intrinsic Frequencies}},
  journal = {SIAM J. Appl. Dyn. Syst.},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=fj362qeixk8},
}
Figure