Stability of Over-Relaxations for the Forward-Backward Algorithm, Application to FISTA

Jean-François Aujol, Charles DossalSIAM J. Optim 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the stability of over-relaxed Forward-Backward (FB) algorithms, particularly FISTA, when dealing with inexact computations of proximal operators and gradients. The authors show that these algorithms can maintain convergence and even achieve better ergodic convergence rates than standard FISTA under certain perturbation levels, offering a more robust approach to optimization problems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many optimization problems in fields like machine learning and signal processing involve minimizing a sum of two convex functions, where one function is "smooth" (its gradient is Lipschitz continuous) and the other is "simple" (its proximal operator is easy to compute). The Forward-Backward (FB) algorithm and its accelerated version, FISTA, are popular methods for solving these problems. However, in practical applications, the proximal operator and gradient might not be computed exactly due to numerical approximations or noise. This paper addresses the crucial question of how these errors affect the convergence of these algorithms, especially for over-relaxed variants like FISTA, and seeks to understand if there are ways to improve their stability and robustness.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in analyzing the convergence of a generalized class of inertial Forward-Backward (iFB) algorithms, which includes FISTA as a special case. The authors introduce a parameter d that controls the degree of over-relaxation, where d=1 corresponds to FISTA and d=0 to the standard FB algorithm. They consider two types of approximations for the proximal operator (type 1 and type 2) and analyze the algorithm's behavior under these inexact computations. The analysis focuses on deriving convergence rates for both the functional values and the iterates themselves. Key techniques include:

  • Over-relaxation parameter d: This parameter allows for interpolation between FB and FISTA, enabling a study of how the degree of acceleration impacts stability.
  • Inexact Proximal Operators and Gradients: The analysis explicitly incorporates errors (εn and en) in these computations, making the results more relevant to practical scenarios.
  • Ergodic Convergence: Beyond the convergence of the iterates themselves, the paper also examines the convergence of a time-averaged sequence, which can be more stable in the presence of oscillations.
  • Generalization of Existing Results: The work builds upon and extends previous theoretical results on FISTA's convergence and stability, particularly those concerning inexact computations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and uses synthetic examples for numerical experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Over-relaxation as a Stability Lever: While FISTA's acceleration can be beneficial, it can also amplify errors. The paper shows that by slowing down the over-relaxation (i.e., choosing d < 1), one can achieve better stability and robustness against perturbations, even outperforming FISTA in certain scenarios.
  • Ergodic Convergence as a Robustness Measure: The ergodic convergence of the iterates often exhibits better behavior than the direct convergence of iterates when perturbations are significant. This suggests that averaging the iterates can smooth out oscillations caused by noise.
  • Trade-off Between Acceleration and Stability: There's a clear trade-off between how fast an algorithm converges and how sensitive it is to errors. The paper quantifies this trade-off by analyzing the impact of the over-relaxation parameter d and the magnitude of perturbations.
  • New Conditions for Weak Convergence: The paper establishes new conditions under which the iterates of these over-relaxed algorithms weakly converge, even when perturbations are too large to guarantee FISTA's optimal decay rate.

Key Results

  • Convergence Guarantees: The paper provides theoretical guarantees for the convergence of both the functional values and the iterates of the over-relaxed FB algorithms, even in the presence of inexact computations.
  • Improved Ergodic Convergence: For certain perturbation levels, the proposed over-relaxed algorithms (with d < 1) can achieve better ergodic convergence rates than FISTA.
  • Stability Analysis: The work offers a detailed analysis of how different levels of perturbations affect the convergence behavior, providing insights into when FISTA might be unstable and how to mitigate this.
  • Numerical Validation: The theoretical findings are supported by numerical experiments on a simple 1D example and a toy inpainting problem, demonstrating that the choice of d can indeed lead to improved performance depending on the noise level.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Weak Convergence: The paper primarily establishes weak convergence of the iterates. Strong convergence (which implies convergence in norm) is generally not guaranteed for these types of algorithms, except in specific cases like finite-dimensional spaces or when additional assumptions are made.
  • Specific Error Models: The analysis focuses on specific types of perturbations for proximal operators and gradients. Future work could explore more general or adaptive error models.
  • Practical Implementation: While the paper provides theoretical insights, further research could focus on practical strategies for choosing the optimal over-relaxation parameter d in real-world applications.
  • Extension to Other Algorithms: The techniques developed in this paper could potentially be extended to analyze the stability of other optimization algorithms, such as Douglas-Rachford splitting or ADMM.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{aujol2015stability,
  author = {Jean-François Aujol and Charles Dossal},
  title = {{Stability of Over-Relaxations for the Forward-Backward Algorithm, Application to FISTA}},
  journal = {SIAM J. Optim.},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1137/140994964},
}
Figure