Stability of multifield cosmological solutions in the presence of a fluid

Jonathan Frazer, Andrew R. LiddlePhysical 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In the study of cosmic acceleration, "assisted quintessence" models propose that multiple scalar fields can collectively drive the universe's expansion. A critical requirement for these models is their stability against perturbations. This paper investigates whether the presence of a background perfect fluid—representing matter or radiation—introduces instabilities into these multifield systems. Using a Hamilton-Jacobi formalism, we demonstrate that the stability of the scalar fields remains decoupled from the fluid. The fundamental stability condition, $d^2V_i/d\phi_i^2 > 0$, remains unchanged from the vacuum case. Furthermore, we show that potential instabilities associated with the fluid do not manifest in realistic cosmological scenarios.

Introduction

The discovery of the universe's accelerated expansion has led to the development of various dark energy models, many of which involve scalar fields. In "assisted quintessence," several scalar fields, which might individually be unable to produce acceleration, work in tandem to achieve the required equation of state. While previous work established the stability of these solutions in a vacuum, the physical universe is populated with fluids such as baryonic matter, dark matter, and radiation. This research addresses whether the interaction between these fluids and the scalar fields undermines the stability of the assisted quintessence mechanism.

Methodology: The Hamilton-Jacobi Approach

To analyze the stability of the system, the authors employ the Hamilton-Jacobi formalism, which offers a robust alternative to standard time-dependent equations. A key technique used is the "clock" trick: by treating one of the scalar fields as the temporal coordinate, the researchers can eliminate unphysical coordinate shifts and simplify the Einstein field equations.

The stability analysis is conducted through linear perturbation theory. The authors introduce small perturbations to the scalar fields and the fluid density and then construct a $2n \times 2n$ stability matrix (where $n$ is the number of fields). The stability of the system is determined by the eigenvalues of this matrix; specifically, the real parts of the eigenvalues must be negative for perturbations to decay over time, ensuring a stable solution.

Sector Decoupling and the Convexity Rule

A primary insight of this work is the discovery of "sector decoupling." The stability matrix is found to be block-diagonal, implying that perturbations in the scalar field sector do not couple directly to perturbations in the fluid or the metric.

This decoupling leads to a significant result: the condition for the stability of the scalar fields in the presence of a fluid is identical to the condition in a vacuum. Specifically, for multiple fields $\phi_i$ in identical potentials $V_i$, the system is stable if:

$$\frac{d^2V_i}{d\phi_i^2} > 0$$

This "convexity rule" suggests that as long as the fields are evolving within a convex region of their potential energy surface (a "U-shaped" potential), the collective assisted quintessence behavior remains robust.

Fluid Stability and Cosmological Context

While the scalar fields are stable under the convexity rule, the presence of a fluid introduces a new degree of freedom—a potential instability where the fluid density shifts relative to the scalar field "clock." The authors derived complex inequalities to evaluate the risk of this new instability.

The analysis reveals that this fluid-related instability is suppressed by the ratio of the fields' kinetic energy to the fluid density. In eras of cosmological interest, such as the matter-dominated era or the current dark-energy-dominated era, the kinetic energy of the quintessence fields is typically much smaller than the background density. Consequently, the stability criteria are naturally satisfied, and the "assisted" effect remains a viable explanation for cosmic acceleration.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research confirms that assisted quintessence is a theoretically sound model even in a universe containing matter and radiation. The stability of the scalar fields is remarkably resilient, governed primarily by the local curvature of the potential.

However, the authors note that this stability is local. A solution that is stable in one epoch might become unstable if the fields migrate to a concave region of the potential. Future work may utilize the Hamilton-Jacobi framework to explore "tracking solutions"—where scalar fields mimic the evolution of the background fluid—providing deeper insights into the long-term behavior of dark energy and the ultimate fate of the cosmic expansion.

Summary updated

Abstract

We explore the stability properties of multifield solutions in the presence of a perfect fluid, as appropriate to assisted quintessence scenarios. We show that the stability condition for multiple fields ${\ensuremath{\phi}}_{i}$ in identical potentials ${V}_{i}$ is simply ${d}^{2}{V}_{i}/d{\ensuremath{\phi}}_{i}^{2}>0$, exactly as in the absence of a fluid. A possible new instability associated with the fluid is shown not to arise in situations of cosmological interest.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{frazer2010stability,
  author = {Jonathan Frazer and Andrew R. Liddle},
  title = {{Stability of multifield cosmological solutions in the presence of a fluid}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.82.043516},
}

Loading related content...

Figure