Stability and Polaronic Motion of Self-Trapped Holes in Silver Halides: Insight through DFT+UCalculations

Simon Loftager, Pablo García‐Fernández, J. A. Aramburu, M. Moreno, J. M. García‐LastraThe Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the behavior of self-trapped holes (STHs) in silver halides (AgCl and AgBr) using first-principles DFT+U calculations. It reveals that STHs are stable in AgCl but not in AgBr, explaining this difference through the role of covalency and lattice distortions. The study also identifies the dominant pathways for STH migration in AgCl, finding that movement to next-nearest neighbors is surprisingly favored with a low energy barrier.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the fundamental question of how charge carriers, specifically holes, behave in ionic crystals like silver halides. These charge carriers can become "self-trapped," meaning they localize and distort the surrounding crystal lattice, forming a polaron. Understanding the stability of these polarons and how they move (hop) is crucial for various applications, including photographic materials and potentially future electronic devices. While experimental data exists for silver halides, a detailed theoretical understanding of the STH's stability, its structural properties, and its migration mechanisms has been lacking, particularly concerning the differences between AgCl and AgBr.

Methods

The researchers employed first-principles Density Functional Theory (DFT) with the Hubbard U correction (DFT+U) to accurately describe the electronic structure and energetics of AgCl and AgBr. This approach is essential for capturing the localized nature of polarons, which standard DFT methods often struggle with due to self-interaction errors. They used the PBEsol and Wu-Cohen (WC) functionals, carefully selecting U parameters to match experimental band gaps. To study polaron motion, they utilized the nudged-elastic-band (NEB) method to calculate the energy barriers for various hopping pathways. Additionally, they developed a simplified theoretical model based on Slater-Koster parameters to gain insight into the origins of these hopping barriers and the influence of lattice distortions, including Jahn-Teller effects.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical calculations rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Covalency is Key to STH Stability: The increased covalency in AgBr compared to AgCl, stemming from the lower electronegativity of bromine, is identified as the primary reason why STHs are stable in AgCl but not in AgBr.
  • Next-Nearest Neighbor Hopping Dominates: Counterintuitively, the study found that STH migration in AgCl is most efficient via hops to next-nearest silver ions, with a remarkably low activation barrier of 37 meV. This is attributed to specific orbital overlaps and the geometry of the hopping path.
  • Jahn-Teller Distortion Plays a Role: The stabilization of the STH in AgCl is influenced by both breathing (a1g) and Jahn-Teller (eg) lattice distortions around the Ag2+ ion.
  • Charge Delocalization Matters: Approximately 10% of the STH's charge in AgCl is found to reside outside the immediate AgCl64- complex. This delocalization is crucial for understanding the differences in optical and magnetic properties compared to STHs in other materials like KCl.

Key Results

  • STH Stability: Self-trapped holes are found to be stable in AgCl with a binding energy of 165 meV, significantly smaller than in KCl. In AgBr, STHs are not stable, relaxing to a delocalized state.
  • Hopping Barriers: Eight inequivalent hopping pathways were analyzed. The lowest energy barriers are found for hops to next-nearest neighbors (Y-x²-y² and X-x²-z²), with a barrier of approximately 37 meV. Hops to nearest neighbors have significantly higher barriers (92-198 meV).
  • Charge Distribution: Calculations show that in AgCl, about 17% of the hole charge is on the central Ag2+ ion, 19% on each equatorial Cl ligand, and ~10% lies outside the AgCl64- complex.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The theoretical models used, while insightful, involve simplifications such as considering only local vibrational modes and neglecting certain interactions.
  • Experimental Comparison: While the calculations are benchmarked against experimental data, further refinement of theoretical models might be needed for perfect quantitative agreement.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest further investigation into the electron self-trapping in other compounds like PbCl2, which is currently underway. They also highlight the need to understand the origin of the 1.2 eV optical absorption band in AgCl. The role of defects in breaking polaron coherence and promoting localization in real crystals is also an area for future exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Polarons and their associated transport properties are a field of great current interest both in chemistry and physics. To further our understanding of these quasi-particles, we have carried out first-principles calculations of self-trapped holes (STHs) in the model compounds AgCl and AgBr, for which extensive experimental information exists. Our calculations confirm that the STH solely stabilizes in AgCl but with a binding energy of only 165 meV, an order of magnitude smaller than that found for the Vk center in KCl. Key contributions to this stabilization energy come from the local relaxation along breathing (a1g) and Jahn–Teller (eg) modes in the AgCl64– unit. To study the transfer of the STH among silver sites, we (i) use first-principles calculations to obtain the hopping barrier of the STH to first and second neighbors, involving eight distinct paths, using first-principles and (ii) construct a simple model, based on Slater–Koster parameters, that highlights the similarity of polaron transfer with magnetic superexchange. This allows one understanding of why the movement of STHs to second neighbors is highly enhanced with respect to closer ones. In agreement with experimental data and the model, the present calculations prove the existence of a dominant mechanism of polaronic motion that corresponds to the displacement of the STHs to the next-nearest sites in the ⟨100⟩ direction and a small barrier of 37 meV. This mechanism is dominated by the covalency inside a AgX64– complex (X:Cl;Br), thus explaining why the STH is not stabilized in AgBr following the increase of covalency due to the Cl → Br substitution. The present calculations confirm that ∼10% of the charge associated with the STH in AgCl is outside the AgCl64– complex. This fact is behind the differences between optical and magnetic properties of the STH in AgCl and those observed in KCl:Ag2+.
BibTeX
@article{loftager2016stability,
  author = {Simon Loftager and Pablo García‐Fernández and J. A. Aramburu and M. Moreno and J. M. García‐Lastra},
  title = {{Stability and Polaronic Motion of Self-Trapped Holes in Silver Halides: Insight through DFT+<i>U</i>Calculations}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry C},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpcc.6b01710},
}
Figure