Stability and composition of functional synergies for speech movements in children and adults

Hayo Terband, Frits van Brenk, Pascal van Lieshout, Lian Nijland, Ben MaassenInterspeech 2009

TL;DR

This study investigates how children and adults coordinate their speech movements, finding that while 7-year-olds show adult-like stability in lower lip movements, they still rely more on jaw movements for oral closures. This highlights that speech motor development isn't a simple linear progression, with different articulators maturing at different rates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Speaking is an incredibly complex motor skill. Researchers often study its development by looking at how different parts of the mouth (like the tongue, lips, and jaw) work together – these coordinated movements are called "functional synergies." The idea is that as we develop, these synergies become more stable and efficient, reducing the number of independent movements the brain needs to control. However, it's unclear if this development is a smooth, linear process across all articulators or if some parts mature faster than others. Previous studies have shown mixed results regarding the stability of lower lip movements in children compared to adults, and how the contributions of different articulators change. This paper aims to clarify these developmental trajectories by examining both the consistency (stability) and composition (relative contributions) of speech movement synergies in 7-year-old children and adults.

Methods

The researchers used electromagnetic articulography (EMA) to track the precise movements of the tongue tip, lower lip, and jaw during speech. Participants were asked to repeat specific words (/spa:/ and /pa:s/) at a comfortable pace.

  • Consistency (Stability): They calculated the cyclic spatiotemporal variability index (cSTI). This metric measures how much the movement trajectories of an articulator vary over repeated cycles of the same speech sound. A lower cSTI indicates more consistent, stable movements.
  • Composition: They measured the amplitude of movement for the tongue tip and lower lip during specific constrictions (for /s/ and /p/ respectively) and the amplitude of jaw opening during the vowel /a:/. This helps understand how much each articulator contributes to forming these speech sounds.

To account for potential differences in how the jaw moves, the lower lip and tongue tip data were corrected to reflect their unique contributions, independent of jaw motion.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved data collected from child and adult participants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Articulator-Specific Development: Speech motor development isn't a one-size-fits-all process. Different parts of the speech apparatus mature at different rates and in different ways.
  • Lower Lip Stability Reached Early: By age 7, children's lower lip movements are as stable as adults' during repetitive speech tasks, suggesting this aspect of the lip-jaw synergy is well-developed.
  • Jaw Still Dominant in Children: Despite stable lower lip movements, children at this age still rely more heavily on their jaw for creating oral closures (like for the /p/ sound) compared to adults, who use their lower lip more significantly.
  • Tongue Tip Variability: Children showed higher variability in tongue tip movements compared to adults, indicating this area might still be developing its consistency.
  • Non-Linear Progression: The findings challenge a simple, linear model of speech motor development, suggesting a more complex, non-linear progression where different aspects of motor control mature at different times.

Key Results

  • Variability:
    • Children showed significantly higher variability in tongue tip movement trajectories compared to adults (p < .05).
  • Children also showed significantly higher variability in jaw movement trajectories compared to adults (p < .01).
  • No significant difference in variability was found for lower lip movement trajectories between children and adults.
  • Composition:
    • The relative contribution of the lower lip to oral closure for the /p/ sound was significantly smaller in children than in adults (p < .01).
  • The amplitude of jaw opening during the /a:/ vowel was significantly larger in children than in adults (p < .05).
  • No significant difference was observed for the tongue tip's contribution to the /s/ constriction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lower Lip-Jaw Synergy Nuance: While lower lip movement stability appears adult-like by age 7, the composition (how the lip and jaw work together) still shows differences, suggesting the synergy is still being refined.
  • Tongue Tip-Jaw Synergy: The study found higher variability in tongue tip movements in children but no difference in their contribution to /s/ constrictions. The authors note that without understanding tongue tip-jaw coordination in younger children, it's hard to fully interpret this finding and determine if the developmental trajectory differs from the lower lip-jaw synergy.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest that obtaining data on tongue tip movements in younger children is crucial for a more complete understanding of tongue tip-jaw synergy development. They also emphasize the need for a multi-variable approach to truly understand the non-linear nature of speech motor development.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{terband2009stability,
  author = {Hayo Terband and Frits van Brenk and Pascal van Lieshout and Lian Nijland and Ben Maassen},
  title = {{Stability and composition of functional synergies for speech movements in children and adults}},
  booktitle = {Interspeech},
  year = {2009},
}
Figure