Stabbing Convex Polygons with a Segment or a Polygon

Pankaj K. Agarwal, Danny Z. Chen, Shashidhara K. Ganjugunte, Ewa Misiolek, Micha Sharir, Kai TangESA 2008 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the problem of finding a minimal set of "stabbing" placements for a given shape (a segment or a polygon) that intersect a collection of obstacles (other polygons). The authors develop efficient algorithms for this task, improving existing bounds on the complexity of critical placements and providing faster methods for computing stabbing sets, particularly for scenarios with many obstacles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Imagine you have a robot arm (represented by a shape, say a segment or a polygon) that needs to navigate a space filled with obstacles (other polygons). A "stabbing set" is a collection of positions and orientations for the robot arm such that every obstacle is "stabbed" by at least one placement of the arm. The core problem is to find such a stabbing set with the minimum possible number of placements. This is crucial for efficient motion planning and geometric algorithms.

The paper focuses on two main aspects:

  1. Understanding Critical Placements: When the robot arm is placed in a "free" position (not intersecting any obstacle's interior), it can still touch the boundaries of obstacles. "Critical placements" are those where the arm makes a certain number of "contacts" (e.g., a vertex touching an edge, or an edge flush with another edge). The number and complexity of these critical placements directly impact how efficiently we can find a stabbing set. The authors aim to refine existing bounds on these critical placements, especially considering the number of obstacles as well as their total vertices.
  2. Efficiently Computing Stabbing Sets: Once we understand the critical placements, we need algorithms to find a small stabbing set. This is framed as a "hitting set" problem on a set of "c-polygons" (regions in the configuration space of the robot arm corresponding to obstacle intersections). The paper proposes new algorithms that are faster than previous methods, particularly when the number of obstacles is large.

Methods

The paper introduces several algorithmic contributions:

  • Refined Complexity Bounds: The authors derive improved upper bounds on the number of "free critical placements" (where the robot arm doesn't intersect obstacle interiors). They analyze these bounds for three cases:
  • B is a line segment, and obstacles may intersect.
  • B is a line segment, and obstacles are disjoint.
  • B is a convex k-gon, and obstacles are disjoint. These new bounds depend not only on the total number of vertices ($n$) but also on the number of obstacles ($m$), which is a significant improvement when $m \ll n$.

  • DEPTH_THRESHOLD Procedure: A key subroutine that determines if the maximum "depth" (number of c-polygons containing a point in the configuration space) exceeds a given threshold. If it does, it returns a critical placement with depth greater than the threshold. This procedure is crucial for the subsequent hitting set algorithms.

  • Monte Carlo and Las Vegas Algorithms for Hitting Sets: The paper presents a combination of Las Vegas (guaranteed correct, probabilistic runtime) and Monte Carlo (probabilistic correctness and runtime) algorithms to compute a hitting set for the c-polygons.
  • A Las Vegas algorithm is described that leverages the geometric structure of the problem and is efficient when the maximum depth of placements is small.
  • A Monte Carlo algorithm is developed, inspired by previous work on approximating depths in arrangements, which is efficient when the size of the optimal hitting set is small.
  • These are combined into a hybrid Monte Carlo algorithm that achieves a better overall expected running time by switching between the two approaches based on problem characteristics.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper deals with abstract geometric configurations rather than specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Importance of Obstacle Count ($m$): A major insight is that the complexity of critical placements and the efficiency of stabbing set algorithms can be significantly improved by explicitly considering the number of obstacles ($m$) in addition to their total number of vertices ($n$). This is particularly relevant in scenarios with many small obstacles.
  • Configuration Space Analysis: The paper heavily relies on analyzing the "configuration space" of the stabbing object (B). This space represents all possible placements of B. Critical placements correspond to specific features (vertices, edges) in the arrangement of "c-polygons" within this configuration space.
  • Bridging Las Vegas and Monte Carlo: The hybrid algorithm that combines Las Vegas and Monte Carlo techniques is a clever way to leverage the strengths of both. It uses a Monte Carlo approach to quickly find a "deep" region in the configuration space and then switches to a Las Vegas approach if that region is too complex or if the optimal solution is small.
  • Refined Bounds for Specific Cases: The paper provides tighter bounds for specific geometric configurations (e.g., line segment stabbing disjoint polygons), which are important for theoretical understanding and practical algorithm design.

Key Results

  • Improved Bounds on Critical Placements:
    • For a line segment B and $m$ potentially intersecting polygons with $n$ vertices, the number of free critical placements is $O(mna(n))$.
  • For a line segment B and $m$ pairwise disjoint polygons with $n$ vertices, the number of nondegenerate free critical placements is $O(m^2 + n)$.
  • For a convex k-gon B and $m$ pairwise disjoint polygons with $n$ vertices, the number of critical placements is $O(k^2mn\beta_6(kn))$, where $\beta_6$ is a very slowly growing function.
  • Efficient Stabbing Set Computation: The paper presents a Monte Carlo algorithm that computes a stabbing set of size $O(h^* \log m)$ with high probability, where $h^*$ is the size of the optimal stabbing set. The expected running time is significantly improved over previous methods, particularly for the case of a line segment stabbing potentially intersecting polygons, achieving $O(mn(\eta + \eta\alpha(n) \log n \log^3 m))$ where $\eta = \min\{m^{1/4}, h^{*1/3}\}$.

Limitations and Future Work

  • General Position Assumption: The paper mentions assuming polygons are in "general position" for some analyses, which is a common simplification in computational geometry but might not hold in all practical scenarios.
  • Expected vs. Worst-Case: The algorithms are primarily analyzed for their expected running time (Monte Carlo). While high probability bounds are given, worst-case guarantees are not the focus.
  • Open Problems: The authors believe that the expected running time for computing a hitting set could potentially be improved to $O(\phi(m, n) \log^c n)$ for some constant $c$, but this remains an open problem.
  • Specific Cases: While improvements are made for various cases (intersecting vs. disjoint polygons, segment vs. k-gon), further research might explore even more specialized scenarios or relax some of the current assumptions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{agarwal2008stabbing,
  author = {Pankaj K. Agarwal and Danny Z. Chen and Shashidhara K. Ganjugunte and Ewa Misiolek and Micha Sharir and Kai Tang},
  title = {{Stabbing Convex Polygons with a Segment or a Polygon}},
  booktitle = {ESA},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-540-87744-8\_5},
}
Figure