Squark production and decay matched with parton showers at NLO

Ryan Gavin, C. Hangst, Michael Krämer, Margarete Mühlleitner, Mathieu Pellen, E. Popenda, M. SpiraThe European Physical Journal C 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive calculation of squark production and decay at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at next-to-leading order (NLO) in Supersymmetric Quantum Chromodynamics (SUSY-QCD). By combining these precise theoretical predictions with parton shower simulations, the authors provide crucial tools for interpreting experimental searches for supersymmetric particles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The search for physics beyond the Standard Model, particularly supersymmetry (SUSY), is a primary goal of the LHC. Supersymmetric particles, like squarks, are expected to be produced in pairs. To effectively search for these particles and understand their properties, precise theoretical predictions for their production and subsequent decay are essential. Previous calculations often relied on simplifying assumptions about squark masses or treated different production and decay channels independently. This paper aims to provide a more complete and accurate picture by calculating NLO SUSY-QCD corrections to squark-antisquark production and combining it with the NLO decay of these squarks into quarks and neutralinos, without simplifying mass assumptions. This is crucial because experimental searches often rely on detailed differential distributions, which are sensitive to the precise theoretical modeling.

Methods

The core of this work involves several advanced theoretical techniques:

  • NLO SUSY-QCD Calculations: The authors perform fully differential calculations for squark-antisquark production and their subsequent decays at next-to-leading order in SUSY-QCD. This involves calculating both virtual (loop) corrections and real (emission) corrections.
  • Gauge-Invariant Subtraction: A key technical challenge addressed is the handling of potentially on-shell intermediate gluinos in the $qg$-initiated production channels. They employ a gauge-invariant diagram subtraction (DS*) method to consistently remove these unphysical contributions.
  • POWHEG-BOX Framework: The NLO calculations are implemented within the POWHEG-BOX framework. This framework allows for the consistent matching of fixed-order NLO calculations with parton shower simulations, crucial for obtaining realistic predictions for exclusive observables.
  • Parton Shower Matching: The NLO predictions are interfaced with leading parton shower Monte Carlo programs, PYTHIA 6 and HERWIG++, to simulate the showering of the produced particles. This accounts for the effects of multiple parton emissions beyond the NLO calculation.
  • Combination of Production and Decay: The paper details methods for consistently combining the NLO production cross sections with the NLO decay widths, ensuring accuracy at NLO.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical calculations and simulations, not on experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Importance of Individual Subchannels: The study highlights that assuming a single "K-factor" (the ratio of NLO to LO cross-sections) for all production subchannels is not accurate, especially for squark-antisquark production where K-factors can vary significantly. This necessitates treating each subchannel individually for precise predictions.
  • Impact of NLO Corrections: NLO corrections are found to be substantial, increasing cross-sections and significantly reducing theoretical uncertainties related to scale dependence.
  • Parton Shower Effects: While NLO corrections improve the accuracy of fixed-order predictions, parton showers are essential for describing exclusive observables like jet transverse momenta. Different parton shower algorithms show some variations, particularly for higher-order jets, indicating the need for careful comparison.
  • Methodological Comparison: The paper demonstrates that different methods for handling intermediate resonances can lead to noticeable discrepancies, especially in squark-antisquark production due to the larger contribution of $qg$ channels.

Key Results

  • Sizeable NLO Corrections: For squark-antisquark production, NLO corrections lead to K-factors around 1.4, significantly increasing the cross-sections and reducing scale uncertainties.
  • Differential Distributions: The NLO corrections can significantly alter differential distributions, with K-factors varying by up to ±40% for jet transverse momenta, underscoring the inadequacy of simple scaling from LO.
  • Parton Shower Agreement: Parton shower simulations generally agree with NLO predictions within 10-20% for inclusive observables, but differences emerge for more exclusive observables, especially for higher-order jets.
  • Code Availability: The implemented code is publicly available within the POWHEG-BOX framework, allowing other researchers to utilize these calculations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Negative Weights: The authors acknowledge that their chosen combination of subtraction schemes and production-decay combination can lead to events with negative weights, which are kept in the generated files. While this is handled, it's a technical limitation.
  • Truncated Shower: The HERWIG++ implementation, while using a default angular-ordered shower, lacks a "vetoed truncated shower" which might be important for accurately simulating soft wide-angle partons. The effect of this missing part is estimated but not fully resolved.
  • Further Investigations: The authors suggest that further investigations are needed to fully understand the discrepancies observed in the third hardest jet distributions, potentially related to the truncated shower or phase-space population.
  • Beyond NLO: While NLO accuracy is achieved, the paper notes that for precise predictions, especially in scenarios with differing squark decay branching ratios, a consistent treatment of NLO corrections for both production and decay is crucial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Extending previous work on the predictions for the production of supersymmetric (SUSY) particles at the LHC, we present the fully differential calculation of the next-to-leading order (NLO) SUSY-QCD corrections to the production of squark and squark–antisquark pairs of the first two generations. The NLO cross sections are combined with the subsequent decay of the final state (anti)squarks into the lightest neutralino and (anti)quark at NLO SUSY-QCD. No assumptions on the squark masses are made, and the various subchannels are taken into account independently. In order to obtain realistic predictions for differential distributions the fixed-order calculations have to be combined with parton showers. Making use of the Powheg method we have implemented our results in the Powheg-Box framework and interfaced the NLO calculation with the parton shower Monte Carlo programs Pythia6 and Herwig++. The code is publicly available and can be downloaded from the Powheg-Box webpage. The impact of the NLO corrections on the differential distributions is studied and parton shower effects are investigated for different benchmark scenarios.
BibTeX
@article{gavin2015squark,
  author = {Ryan Gavin and C. Hangst and Michael Krämer and Margarete Mühlleitner and Mathieu Pellen and E. Popenda and M. Spira},
  title = {{Squark production and decay matched with parton showers at NLO}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal C},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1140/epjc/s10052-014-3243-2},
}
Figure