Square patterns and quasipatterns in weakly damped Faraday waves

Wenbin Zhang, Jorge ViñalsPhysical 1996 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Pattern formation in parametric surface waves is studied in the limit of weak viscous dissipation. A set of quasipotential equations (QPEs) is introduced that admits a closed representation in terms of surface variables alone. A multiscale expansion of the QPEs reveals the importance of triad resonant interactions, and the saturating effect of the driving force leading to a gradient amplitude equation. Minimization of the associated Lyapunov function yields standing wave patterns of square symmetry for capillary waves, and hexagonal patterns and a sequence of quasipatterns for mixed capillary-gravity waves. Numerical integration of the QPEs reveals a quasipattern of eightfold symmetry in the range of parameters predicted by the multiscale expansion.

Introduction

Faraday waves—patterns that emerge on the surface of a vertically vibrated fluid—have long fascinated physicists. While these structures, ranging from simple squares to complex hexagons, are readily observable, their theoretical description has remained elusive, particularly in "weakly damped" (low viscosity) regimes.

Historically, it was believed that linear dissipation was insufficient to saturate the growth of these waves, necessitating the inclusion of poorly understood nonlinear damping terms. Furthermore, while experiments have shown exotic "quasipatterns"—structures with long-range order but no spatial periodicity—a clear theoretical path from fluid dynamics equations to these stable, non-periodic states was missing.

Methodology

To bridge this gap, the authors introduced Quasi-Potential Equations (QPEs). This approach simplifies the 3D Navier-Stokes equations into a 2D nonlocal form restricted to the fluid surface. By accounting for the thin viscous boundary layer at the surface, the QPEs avoid the need to solve for the entire bulk flow.

The researchers then applied a multiscale expansion to derive amplitude equations that describe the evolution of wave modes. Pattern selection was treated as an optimization problem: the system "chooses" the configuration that minimizes a specific energy-like functional, known as a Lyapunov function. To verify these theoretical predictions, high-resolution numerical simulations were performed using a Fourier-Galerkin spectral method.

Mechanism of Pattern Selection

A key insight of this work is that pattern selection is primarily driven by triad resonant interactions—nonlinear interactions between three wave modes. The system tends to favor patterns that avoid modes participating in these resonances, as they would otherwise drain energy from the primary structure.

Interaction coefficients $g(c_{jl})$ as a function of the cosine of the angle between wave vectors ($c_{jl}$) for various damping ($\gamma$) and surface tension ($\Gamma_0$) parameters. These functions characterize the nonlinear interactions that drive pattern selection.

Contrary to previous assumptions, the authors demonstrate that linear viscous effects contribute significantly to nonlinear damping. The interaction between primary waves and the external driving force provides a natural amplitude-limiting effect, allowing for saturation without invoking complex nonlinear dissipation terms.

Results

The model's predictions align well with experimental observations and offer new insights:

  • Square Patterns: The framework successfully explains why square symmetries are favored in capillary-dominated regimes (high surface tension).
  • Eight-fold Quasipatterns: For mixed capillary-gravity waves with very low damping ($\gamma = 0.02$), numerical integration revealed a stable eight-fold symmetry quasipattern. This was confirmed by the presence of eight distinct peaks in the calculated structure factor.
  • Lyapunov Hierarchy: The study maps out the energetic favorability of various symmetries (from $N=1$ to $8$) across different damping ranges, providing a predictive roadmap for future experimental verification.

Conclusion

While the QPE approach successfully predicts complex patterns, some challenges remain. At extremely low damping, patterns become sensitive to the container's size, suggesting that simulating even lower-symmetry states will require larger computational domains. Additionally, while this study focused on single-frequency driving, many experimental quasipatterns involve multi-frequency forcing. Extending the QPE framework to these more complex driving conditions is a promising next step for the field.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pattern formation in parametric surface waves is studied in the limit of weak viscous dissipation. A set of quasipotential equations (QPEs) is introduced that admits a closed representation in terms of surface variables alone. A multiscale expansion of the QPEs reveals the importance of triad resonant interactions, and the saturating effect of the driving force leading to a gradient amplitude equation. Minimization of the associated Lyapunov function yields standing wave patterns of square symmetry for capillary waves, and hexagonal patterns and a sequence of quasipatterns for mixed capillary-gravity waves. Numerical integration of the QPEs reveals a quasipattern of eightfold symmetry in the range of parameters predicted by the multiscale expansion.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang1996square,
  author = {Wenbin Zhang and Jorge Viñals},
  title = {{Square patterns and quasipatterns in weakly damped Faraday waves}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1996},
  doi = {10.1103/physreve.53.r4283},
}
Figure