Spring temperature change and its implication in the change of vegetation growth in North America from 1982 to 2006

Xuhui Wang, Shilong Piao, Philippe Ciais, Junsheng Li, Pierre Friedlingstein, Charles D. Koven, Anping ChenProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that North American vegetation growth, particularly in spring, is highly sensitive to regional temperature shifts, not just overall warming trends. By analyzing decades of satellite and climate data, the researchers found that a "turning point" in spring temperatures, where warming stalled or reversed in some areas, directly corresponded to changes in vegetation greenness, suggesting a complex interplay beyond simple warming.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the critical question of how vegetation growth in North America responds to climate change, a crucial factor for projecting future ecosystem dynamics and carbon cycles. While global warming is a well-established trend, the authors highlight that regional climate patterns can be more nuanced. Specifically, they note that parts of North America have experienced a cooling trend in spring temperatures over the last few decades, a phenomenon that has received less attention than overall warming. The core problem is understanding the impact of these localized, non-uniform temperature changes on vegetation health and growth, especially given vegetation's significant role in regulating climate and absorbing atmospheric CO2.

Methods

The researchers employed a piecewise linear regression approach to analyze trends in spring temperature and vegetation growth (measured by NDVI). This method is key because it allows for the detection of a "turning point" (TP) where the trend in temperature significantly changes within the study period (1982-2006). By identifying these TPs for each location, they could then analyze temperature and NDVI trends before and after these turning points. This allowed them to disentangle the effects of different trend periods, rather than just looking at the overall trend across the entire 25 years. They also used multiple climate datasets to ensure the robustness of their findings.

Datasets

  • Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI): Biweekly data with an 8-km spatial resolution from the Global Inventory Monitoring and Modeling Studies (GIMMS) group, covering 1982-2006. This dataset is derived from NOAA AVHRR imagery and has been corrected for various atmospheric and sensor-related issues.
  • Climate Data:
    • Temperature and Precipitation: Monthly data from the Climatic Research Unit (CRU) TS 3.0 dataset (0.5° x 0.5° resolution), covering the study period.
  • Additional Temperature Datasets: Goddard Institute for Space Science (GISS) dataset, North America Regional Reanalysis (NARR) dataset, and NCEP/DOE Reanalysis 2 (NCEP-DOE) dataset were used for cross-validation.
  • Palmer Drought Severity Index (PDSI): Used to assess drought conditions, with data from Dai et al. (2.5° x 2.5° resolution), updated to 2005.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Regional Heterogeneity Matters: The study strongly emphasizes that vegetation response is not uniform across North America. While some regions experienced consistent warming, others saw a stall or even a reversal in spring warming trends.
  • The "Turning Point" is Crucial: The identification of a turning point in spring temperature trends is a critical finding. It suggests that the change in temperature trends, not just the direction, has a significant impact on vegetation.
  • Spring Temperature Dictates Spring Growth: The paper provides compelling evidence that changes in spring temperature directly influence spring vegetation greenness (NDVI). A warming trend before the TP led to greening, while a cooling trend after the TP led to stalling or browning.
  • Summer Growth is Also Affected: The study found that summer vegetation growth trends also varied before and after the spring temperature TP, indicating a cascading effect from spring conditions to the broader growing season. This effect couldn't be solely explained by summer drought.
  • Water Availability is Less Dominant for Spring Growth: Correlations between spring NDVI and precipitation were weaker than those with temperature, suggesting that spring temperature is a more dominant driver of early-season vegetation growth in these latitudes, rather than water availability.

Key Results

  • Spring Temperature Trends: While most of North America showed a warming trend in spring (April-May) from 1982-2006, about 16% of the continent experienced cooling, primarily in a west-to-east band around 50°N and southeastern Canada.
  • Turning Points: Over 40% of the study region showed a significant change in spring temperature trends, with the TP year varying across the continent.
  • Vegetation Response:
    • In the northwestern US and Canada, spring temperatures increased until the early 1990s, followed by a stall or decrease. Correspondingly, spring vegetation greening in the 1980s stalled or reversed.
  • In the northeastern US and Canada, an opposite pattern was observed: cooling or small changes before the TP, followed by greening after the TP, mirroring the temperature trends.
  • Summer NDVI: While previous studies indicated overall greening, this study found a decrease in summer NDVI in many regions after the spring temperature TP, suggesting that recent spring cooling might contribute to summer browning.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Spring Frost Uncertainty: The authors acknowledge that while spring frost can severely damage vegetation, especially after budburst, their analysis of monthly temperature data has limited ability to capture the impact of high-frequency, low-temperature extremes. Further studies are needed to assess the contribution of historical spring frost changes.
  • Net Carbon Balance Unknown: The implications of the observed temperature changes for North America's net carbon balance remain unknown. The paper suggests that while warming might increase productivity, it can also enhance carbon release from organic matter decomposition, making the net effect uncertain. Future research should investigate this linkage.
  • Drought vs. Temperature: While drought stress is a known factor, the study suggests that spring and summer cooling might also contribute to recent summer browning trends, indicating a need for more nuanced understanding of multiple climate drivers.
  • Data Limitations: The PDSI dataset had some missing data for 2006 and gaps in high-latitude regions for certain years.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding how vegetation growth responds to climate change is a critical requirement for projecting future ecosystem dynamics. Parts of North America (NA) have experienced a spring cooling trend over the last three decades, but little is known about the response of vegetation growth to this change. Using observed climate data and satellite-derived Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) data from 1982 to 2006, we investigated changes in spring (April-May) temperature trends and their impact on vegetation growth in NA. A piecewise linear regression approach shows that the trend in spring temperature is not continuous through the 25-year period. In the northwestern region of NA, spring temperature increased until the late 1980s or early 1990s, and stalled or decreased afterwards. In response, a spring vegetation greening trend, which was evident in this region during the 1980s, stalled or reversed recently. Conversely, an opposite phenomenon occurred in the northeastern region of NA due to different spring temperature trends. Additionally, the trends of summer vegetation growth vary between the periods before and after the turning point (TP) of spring temperature trends. This change cannot be fully explained by summer drought stress change alone and is partly explained by changes in the trends of spring temperature as well as those of summer temperature. As reported in previous studies, summer vegetation browning trends have occurred in the northwestern region of NA since the early 1990s, which is consistent with the spring and summer cooling trends in this region during this period.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2011spring,
  author = {Xuhui Wang and Shilong Piao and Philippe Ciais and Junsheng Li and Pierre Friedlingstein and Charles D. Koven and Anping Chen},
  title = {{Spring temperature change and its implication in the change of vegetation growth in North America from 1982 to 2006}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1014425108},
}
Figure