Spinal cord stimulation restores sensation, improves function, and reduces phantom pain after transtibial amputation

Ameya C. Nanivadekar, Rohit Bose, Bailey A. Petersen, Elizaveta V. Okorokova, Devapratim Sarma, Juhi Farooqui, Ashley N Dalrymple, I. Martin Levy, Eric R. Helm, Vincent Mièle, Michael L. Boninger, Marco Capogrosso, Sliman J. Bensmaı̈a, Douglas J. Weber, Lee E. FishermedRxiv 2022 · DOI

This research paper, recently published in medRxiv, presents a significant leap in neuroprosthetics. Researchers from the University of Pittsburgh demonstrate that spinal cord stimulation (SCS)—a technology already widely used to treat chronic back pain—can be repurposed to restore sensation in missing limbs for lower-limb amputees, significantly improving their mobility and quality of life.

TL;DR

Researchers developed a closed-loop system using clinically available spinal cord stimulation to restore "feeling" in the missing feet of transtibial amputees. This somatosensory feedback improved balance, stabilized gait, and provided a clinically meaningful reduction in phantom limb pain.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For the 1.5 million people in the U.S. living with lower-limb amputations, modern prosthetics are a marvel of mechanical engineering but a failure in sensory integration. Because these limbs provide no "feeling" (somatosensory feedback), users struggle with balance and gait, leading to a high risk of falls.

Furthermore, many suffer from debilitating Phantom Limb Pain (PLP), which is thought to arise from a "sensorimotor mismatch"—the brain sends signals to move a limb but receives no sensory confirmation in return. While peripheral nerve stimulation (PNS) has been explored to fix this, it requires complex surgery and often fails in patients with diabetic neuropathy, where the peripheral nerves are too damaged to interface with. This paper explores whether the spinal cord can serve as a more robust, "plug-and-play" interface.

Methods

The study involved three subjects with below-knee (transtibial) amputations. The researchers used a three-pronged approach:

  1. The Interface: They implanted commercially available SCS leads (8 or 16 contacts) into the thoracolumbar epidural space. Unlike previous experimental surgeries, this is a standard, minimally invasive clinical procedure.
  2. The Closed-Loop System: They placed a wireless, pressure-sensitive insole (Moticon) inside the subject's prosthetic shoe. As the subject walked or stood, pressure data was transmitted to an external stimulator, which modulated the SCS amplitude in real-time.
  3. Psychophysical Mapping: Before functional testing, the team mapped which electrode contacts evoked sensations in specific parts of the "missing" foot (toes, heel, etc.) and determined the relationship between stimulation intensity and perceived sensation magnitude.

Datasets

This was a clinical feasibility study involving three human subjects:

  • Subject 1: Male, 56-60, diabetic amputation (3 years post-amputation).
  • Subject 2: Male, 56-60, traumatic amputation (7 years post-amputation).
  • Subject 3: Female, 61-65, diabetic amputation (5 years post-amputation).

The study is notable for including diabetic patients, a demographic often excluded from neural interface studies due to nerve damage.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Emergence" Period: Interestingly, subjects didn't feel sensations in their missing limbs immediately. It took 1–2 weeks of stimulation for the phantom sensations to "emerge," suggesting the spinal circuits or the brain needed time to re-adapt to the incoming signals.
  • Leveraging Existing Infrastructure: By using FDA-cleared SCS leads, the researchers bypassed the "valley of death" between lab prototypes and clinical use. There is already a massive infrastructure of surgeons who know how to implant these devices.
  • Bypassing Neuropathy: The system worked even for patients with diabetic peripheral neuropathy. This suggests that even when peripheral nerves are damaged, the spinal cord remains a viable gateway for sensory restoration.
  • Linear Scaling: Perceived intensity scaled nearly linearly with stimulation amplitude. This makes the engineering of "natural" feedback much simpler, as a linear increase in foot pressure can be mapped directly to a linear increase in stimulation.

Key Results

  • Improved Balance: In the Sensory Organization Test (SOT), both subjects tested showed significant improvements. Subject 2’s sway area decreased by ~19 cm², and Subject 3’s by ~39 cm². Crucially, while both subjects experienced "falls" during testing without stimulation, neither fell when the system was active.
  • Gait Stability: Subject 3 showed a clinically meaningful improvement (>4 points) in the Functional Gait Assessment (FGA), a measure of dynamic balance during walking.
  • Pain Reduction: Subjects 1 and 3 experienced a 50% reduction in Phantom Limb Pain, a "clinically meaningful" threshold. In a telling "aha" moment, Subject 3’s pain scores spiked nearly four-fold during a one-week holiday break when the stimulator was turned off, then dropped again once testing resumed.

Limitations and Future Work

The study’s primary limitation is its small sample size (N=3) and the fact that it was not blinded (though a "sham" stimulation condition for Subject 2 helped validate the results).

The current setup used percutaneous leads (wires exiting the skin) and an external stimulator. Future work will focus on fully implanted systems where the pressure insole communicates wirelessly with an internal pulse generator. The researchers also suggest that "biomimetic" stimulation patterns—mimicking the complex firing patterns of natural nerves—might produce even more natural sensations and better functional outcomes than the constant-frequency pulses used here.

Summary updated

Abstract

SUMMARY In the United States, over 1.5 million people live with lower-limb amputation. Existing prosthetic limbs do not restore somatosensory feedback from the limb, resulting in functional impairments including balance deficits and an increased risk of falls. Further, these prostheses do not alleviate the severe phantom limb pain that often follows amputation. Leveraging clinically available spinal cord stimulation electrodes, we designed a system that restores somatosensation in the missing limb, thereby improving balance and gait and reducing phantom limb pain. We show that spinal cord stimulation can evoke sensations in the missing foot and that we can control the location and intensity of those sensations. Further, by modulating stimulation intensity in real time based on signals from a wireless pressure-sensitive shoe insole, subjects exhibit improvements in functional measures of balance and gait stability. Finally, over the duration of the implant period, subjects experienced a clinically meaningful decrease in phantom limb pain. These combined results demonstrate that, with an electrode technology that is currently in widespread clinical use, our approach has the potential to become an important intervention for lower-limb amputation.
BibTeX
@misc{nanivadekar2022spinal,
  author = {Ameya C. Nanivadekar and Rohit Bose and Bailey A. Petersen and Elizaveta V. Okorokova and Devapratim Sarma and Juhi Farooqui and Ashley N Dalrymple and I. Martin Levy and Eric R. Helm and Vincent Mièle and Michael L. Boninger and Marco Capogrosso and Sliman J. Bensmaı̈a and Douglas J. Weber and Lee E. Fisher},
  title = {{Spinal cord stimulation restores sensation, improves function, and reduces phantom pain after transtibial amputation}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.09.15.22279956},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure