Spike-timing-dependent ensemble encoding by non-classically responsive cortical neurons

Michele N. Insanally, Ioana Carcea, Rachel E. Field, Chris C. Rodgers, Brian DePasquale, Kanaka Rajan, Michael R. DeWeese, Badr F. Albanna, Robert C. FroemkeeLife 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel spike-timing-based algorithm to decode neural activity from "non-classically responsive" neurons, which typically show no obvious task-related firing rate modulation. They demonstrate that these often-overlooked neurons, particularly in ensembles, carry significant information about sensory stimuli and behavioral decisions, challenging the traditional view of neural coding.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

A significant portion of neurons in the brain don't exhibit clear, trial-averaged firing rate changes in response to stimuli or during task performance. These "non-classically responsive" neurons are often excluded from analyses, leading to an incomplete understanding of how neural activity relates to behavior. The authors aim to develop a method to interpret the coding capabilities of these neurons, bridging the gap between neural activity and perception/behavior, especially when traditional rate-based analyses fail.

Methods

The core of the paper is a novel single-trial, Inter-Spike Interval (ISI)-based Bayesian decoding algorithm. Instead of relying on firing rates, it analyzes the distribution of time intervals between spikes. This approach is motivated by the idea that spike timing can carry information even when firing rates are constant. The algorithm uses Kernel Density Estimation to build probability distributions of ISIs for different task conditions (e.g., target vs. non-target tones) from training data. Then, for new trials, it uses Bayes' rule to update the probability of a given condition based on observed ISIs. This method is designed to be general and applicable to any brain region and task variable. They also extend this to ensemble decoding, where the likelihood functions from multiple neurons are combined to update beliefs simultaneously. To assess the significance of their findings, they employ synthetic spike trains and condition permutation tests.

Datasets

The study utilized datasets from two brain regions in behaving rats:

  • Auditory Cortex (AC)
  • Frontal Cortex (FR2)

These datasets were collected during a go/no-go audiomotor frequency recognition task. Additionally, they re-analyzed data from a previously published study (Rodgers and DeWeese, 2014) involving a novel auditory stimulus selection task in AC and prefrontal cortex (PFC) to demonstrate the generalizability of their decoding algorithm.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hidden Information in Spike Timing: The most significant insight is that non-classically responsive neurons, which appear silent or unmodulated at the firing rate level, contain rich information encoded in the precise timing of their spikes.
  • Ensembles as Consensus Builders: Decoding performance significantly improves with ensemble size. Crucially, they found evidence of "consensus building" within ensembles, where neurons coordinate their ISI representations to create a shared, unambiguous code for task variables, especially on correct trials.
  • Error Prediction: Ensembles, particularly those with a higher proportion of non-classically responsive cells, can predict behavioral errors on a trial-by-trial basis, suggesting these neurons play a role in error detection or correction.
  • Distributed Coding: Information about sensory stimuli and behavioral choices is distributed across both AC and FR2, with evidence of multiplexing (neurons encoding multiple variables simultaneously). FR2 appears to be more critical for stimulus representation than AC, especially when stimuli have behavioral significance.
  • ISI vs. Rate: The ISI-based decoder consistently outperformed a conventional rate-modulated decoder, confirming that spike timing captures information distinct from firing rate.

Key Results

  • Decoding Performance: Non-classically responsive cells in both AC and FR2 provided significant spike-timing-based information about stimulus category and behavioral choice.
  • Regional Differences: FR2 neurons were more informative about stimulus category than AC neurons, while AC neurons were more informative about choice than stimulus category.
  • Ensemble Gains: Ensemble decoding significantly improved performance compared to single units, especially in FR2. For example, stimulus decoding performance increased from ~65% to ~75% with ensemble size in FR2.
  • Error Prediction: Ensembles could predict errors with accuracy significantly above chance (e.g., ~60% for 3-member ensembles in AC).
  • Consensus Dynamics: On correct trials, ensembles showed increasing consensus (shared ISI representation) before behavioral responses, while this consensus building was absent or reduced on error trials.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions: The ISI-based decoding method assumes ISIs are independent, which is a simplification. Future work could explore how to incorporate ISI correlations.
  • Generalizability: While demonstrated across AC and FR2, and in a second task, further validation in other brain areas and tasks would be beneficial.
  • Biological Plausibility: The authors hypothesize that short-term synaptic plasticity and network resonance could support ISI-based coding, but direct experimental verification of these mechanisms in their context is future work.
  • Timescales: The relevant timescales for ISI-based coding in relation to membrane time constants and oscillatory activity remain an open question.
  • Hybrid Approaches: The authors suggest that future approaches might hybridize rate-based and temporal-based decoding methods to capture information across multiple timescales.

Summary updated

Abstract

Neurons recorded in behaving animals often do not discernibly respond to sensory input and are not overtly task-modulated. These non-classically responsive neurons are difficult to interpret and are typically neglected from analysis, confounding attempts to connect neural activity to perception and behavior. Here, we describe a trial-by-trial, spike-timing-based algorithm to reveal the coding capacities of these neurons in auditory and frontal cortex of behaving rats. Classically responsive and non-classically responsive cells contained significant information about sensory stimuli and behavioral decisions. Stimulus category was more accurately represented in frontal cortex than auditory cortex, via ensembles of non-classically responsive cells coordinating the behavioral meaning of spike timings on correct but not error trials. This unbiased approach allows the contribution of all recorded neurons - particularly those without obvious task-related, trial-averaged firing rate modulation - to be assessed for behavioral relevance on single trials.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{insanally2019spike,
  author = {Michele N. Insanally and Ioana Carcea and Rachel E. Field and Chris C. Rodgers and Brian DePasquale and Kanaka Rajan and Michael R. DeWeese and Badr F. Albanna and Robert C. Froemke},
  title = {{Spike-timing-dependent ensemble encoding by non-classically responsive cortical neurons}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.42409},
}
Figure