Spherical distributed dielectric resonators

David J. Brady, J. E. Sipe, George C. PapenJournal of the Optical Society of America B 1993 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces and analyzes spherical dielectric resonators with radially periodic refractive index modulation. These structures exhibit photonic band gaps, inhibiting light propagation over specific frequency ranges, and can support localized photon modes, offering new possibilities for controlling light-matter interactions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of controlling electromagnetic propagation and creating localized light fields within dielectric structures, particularly in three dimensions. While traditional methods like total internal reflection are effective in lower dimensions, they fail to provide true confinement in 3D due to the broadening of the spatial Fourier spectrum. The authors propose spherical, radially periodic dielectric structures as a novel approach to achieve this confinement, drawing an analogy to electronic band structures and photonic band gap materials. They aim to understand how these structures inhibit propagation, how localized photon modes can form within these "gaps," and how finite versions of these resonators behave in terms of field distribution and scattering.

Methods

The authors employ a theoretical and numerical approach. They start by deriving the vector wave equation for a radially symmetric dielectric medium and then separate it into one-dimensional radial wave equations for TE and TM polarizations using vector spherical harmonics. These equations are analogous to the Schrödinger equation in quantum mechanics. For infinite structures, they analyze the asymptotic behavior of these equations, revealing the existence of stop bands (frequency ranges where propagation is inhibited) and relating them to Bloch functions.

To investigate localized modes, they analyze the conditions under which square-integrable solutions can exist, noting that true bound states like those in quantum mechanics are not possible in dielectrics without specific modifications. They explore how a particular form of dielectric modulation can lead to localized modes by canceling out the inverse square potential term.

For finite structures, they use coupled-mode equations and numerical integration to study internal field distributions and scattering characteristics. They also analyze the quality factor (Q) of these resonators, which quantifies their ability to store electromagnetic energy.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The analysis is theoretical and numerical, relying on mathematical models and simulations rather than experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spherical Structures as 3D Photonic Crystals: The paper demonstrates that radially periodic dielectric spheres can act as three-dimensional photonic crystals, creating frequency ranges where light cannot propagate. This is a significant step towards realizing 3D photonic devices.
  • Localized Photon Modes in Dielectrics: A key finding is the possibility of creating "localized photon modes" within the photonic band gap of these dielectric structures. This is achieved by carefully engineering the dielectric modulation, offering a way to trap light in specific regions.
  • Analogy to Electronic Band Structures: The authors effectively leverage the analogy between the wave equation for light in dielectric structures and the Schrödinger equation for electrons, allowing them to apply concepts from solid-state physics to optics.
  • Tunable Stop Bands and Localized Modes: The frequency range of the stop band and the properties of localized modes are shown to be tunable by parameters like the amplitude, phase, and inner boundary of the dielectric modulation. This offers significant design flexibility.
  • High Q Factors: The analysis suggests that these spherical resonators can achieve very high Q factors, making them promising for applications requiring efficient light confinement and interaction.

Key Results

  • The range of inhibited frequencies (stop band) in these structures is directly proportional to the amplitude of the radial dielectric modulation.
  • Localized photon modes can be formed within the stop band, with their existence and properties depending on the specific dielectric modulation profile.
  • Numerical simulations show that finite spherical resonators can exhibit high Q factors, with values reaching nearly $10^{12}$ for moderately sized structures.
  • Scattering analysis indicates that while scattering is strongest within the stop band, fields outside this band are also scattered, suggesting that these resonators can be probed by nonresonant light.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Idealized Structures: The analysis primarily deals with idealized, perfectly spherical, and radially periodic structures. Real-world fabrication will inevitably introduce imperfections (aspherical distortions, layer nonuniformities) that need further investigation.
  • Numerical Algorithm Stability: The authors note that their numerical algorithms become unstable for large values of the angular momentum quantum number ($l$), limiting the exploration of higher-order modes.
  • Experimental Verification: While the theoretical framework is presented, the paper focuses on numerical analysis. Experimental realization and validation of these resonators are crucial next steps.
  • Practical Applications: The paper suggests potential applications in quantum optics and nonlinear studies, but further research is needed to translate these theoretical findings into practical devices. Future work could focus on optimizing resonator design for specific applications, exploring different dielectric materials, and investigating the impact of fabrication tolerances.

Summary updated

Abstract

Spherical radially periodic dielectric structures inhibit electromagnetic propagation over a complete solid angle and a finite frequency range. The range of inhibited frequencies is linear in the amplitude of the radial modulation. Depending on the phase, the amplitude, and the inner boundary of the dielectric modulation, localized photon modes may occur within the gap. The internal field distributions and scattering characteristics of spherical dielectric resonators are analyzed numerically.
BibTeX
@article{brady1993spherical,
  author = {David J. Brady and J. E. Sipe and George C. Papen},
  title = {{Spherical distributed dielectric resonators}},
  journal = {Journal of the Optical Society of America B},
  year = {1993},
  doi = {10.1364/josab.10.000644},
}
Figure