SPECTROSCOPIC CONFIRMATION OF TWO MASSIVE RED-SEQUENCE-SELECTED GALAXY CLUSTERS ATz∼ 1.2 IN THE SpARCS-NORTH CLUSTER SURVEY

Adam Muzzin, Gillian Wilson, H. K. C. Yee, Henk Hoekstra, David Gilbank, J. Surace, Mark Lacy, Kris Blindert, Subhabrata Majumdar, R. Demarco, Jonathan P. Gardner, M. D. Gladders, C. J. LonsdaleThe Astrophysical Journal 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the spectroscopic confirmation of two massive galaxy clusters at a redshift of approximately 1.2, identified using the Spitzer Adaptation of the Red-sequence Cluster Survey (SPARCS). The findings validate the effectiveness of infrared-based red-sequence imaging for efficiently selecting these rare, high-redshift structures, crucial for understanding galaxy evolution in dense environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how galaxies evolve is a fundamental question in astrophysics. It's widely accepted that a galaxy's environment plays a significant role in shaping its properties, such as star formation rate, morphology, and color. However, studying these environmental effects at high redshifts (further back in cosmic time) is challenging due to sparser data and the need to observe galaxies in their younger, less evolved states. Galaxy clusters represent the most extreme density environments, making them ideal laboratories for studying these evolutionary processes. Despite the importance of high-redshift clusters, confirmed samples of massive clusters at $z > 1$ are still relatively scarce. This scarcity is due to the inherent difficulty in detecting these distant, massive structures, which requires surveys that are both deep enough to detect faint galaxies or X-ray emission and wide enough to account for their rarity. This paper addresses this gap by presenting a method for efficiently identifying and confirming these elusive high-redshift clusters.

Methods

The core of this paper's methodology lies in the Spitzer Adaptation of the Red-sequence Cluster Survey (SPARCS). This survey utilizes an infrared adaptation of the "red-sequence" method, a well-established technique for finding galaxy clusters.

  • Red-Sequence Method: In the local universe, galaxies within clusters tend to fall onto a specific color-magnitude relationship, known as the red sequence, indicating they have ceased significant star formation. At higher redshifts, the 4000 Å break in a galaxy's spectrum shifts into the infrared. SPARCS leverages this by using a $z' - 3.6 \mu m$ color to identify galaxies that are likely on the red sequence at $z \sim 1.2$.
  • Infrared Data: The survey uses Spitzer Space Telescope's infrared data (specifically the IRAC bands) to probe this red sequence at high redshifts.
  • Optical Imaging: Complementary deep $z'$-band imaging from the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope (CFHT) provides the necessary optical depth.
  • Cluster Finding Algorithm: A modified version of the algorithm developed by Gladders & Yee (2000, 2005) and Muzzin et al. (2008) is used to identify overdensities of red-sequence galaxies in the combined infrared and optical data.
  • Spectroscopic Follow-up: To confirm the cluster candidates, the researchers used Nod-and-Shuffle (N&S) spectroscopy with the GMOS-N instrument on the Gemini telescope. This technique is efficient for obtaining spectra of multiple faint objects simultaneously, crucial for confirming cluster membership and measuring velocity dispersions.

Datasets

  • Spitzer Wide-Area Infrared Extragalactic Survey (SWIRE) Legacy fields: This survey provides the infrared (IRAC and MIPS) imaging data for the SPARCS project.
  • CFHT/MegaCam $z'$-band imaging: This provides the optical imaging data for the northern component of the SPARCS survey.
  • Gemini/GMOS-N spectroscopic data: This dataset was used for spectroscopic confirmation of cluster candidates and measurement of galaxy redshifts and velocities.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Infrared Red-Sequence is Effective at High Redshift: The confirmation of these two massive clusters at $z \sim 1.2$ strongly supports the idea that using infrared colors ($z' - 3.6 \mu m$) is an efficient and reliable method for selecting galaxy clusters at these high redshifts.
  • Two-Filter Imaging Sufficiency: The success demonstrates that a combination of just two filters (one optical, one infrared) can be observationally efficient for identifying potential high-redshift clusters, paving the way for larger, more homogeneous samples.
  • Galaxy Evolution in Extreme Environments: These confirmed clusters provide valuable targets for future studies into how galaxy properties are shaped by the densest environments in the universe at early cosmic times.

Key Results

  • Spectroscopic Confirmation: Two rich cluster candidates, SPARCS J163435+402151 and SPARCS J163852+403843, were spectroscopically confirmed at redshifts of $z = 1.1798$ and $z = 1.1963$, respectively.
  • Cluster Membership: 17 confirmed cluster members were identified for SPARCS J163435+402151 and 28 for SPARCS J163852+403843.
  • Velocity Dispersions: The velocity dispersions were measured as $490 \pm 140$ km/s and $650 \pm 160$ km/s, respectively.
  • Dynamical Masses: These velocity dispersions imply dynamical masses ($M_{200}$) of $(1.0 \pm 0.9) \times 10^{14} M_\odot$ and $(2.4 \pm 1.8) \times 10^{14} M_\odot$.
  • Photometric Redshift Agreement: The red-sequence photometric redshifts derived from the $z' - 3.6 \mu m$ color show excellent agreement with the spectroscopic redshifts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mass-Richness Discrepancy: The paper notes that both confirmed clusters have lower dynamical masses ($M_{200}$) than predicted by their richness (a measure of the number of galaxies) using scaling relations calibrated at lower redshifts ($z \sim 0.3$). This discrepancy is significant at about the 1-2$\sigma$ level for the two clusters.
  • Need for Larger Samples: The authors acknowledge that it is impossible to definitively determine if this mass-richness discrepancy represents an evolution in cluster scaling relations at $z > 1$ or is simply due to "Eddington bias" (a selection effect where less massive clusters with unusually high richnesses are more likely to be detected in richness-selected samples) with only two clusters.
  • Future Work: The SPARCS survey is designed to build a large, homogeneously selected sample of massive clusters at $z > 1$. This larger sample will be crucial for testing cluster scaling relations at high redshift and for studying the evolution of galaxy properties in these extreme environments. The paper also mentions that the full SPARCS catalog, containing hundreds of cluster candidates, will be presented in a future publication.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Spitzer Adaptation of the Red-sequence Cluster Survey (SpARCS) is a deep z'-band imaging survey covering the Spitzer Wide-Area Infrared Extragalactic Survey (SWIRE) Legacy fields designed to create the first large homogeneously selected sample of massive clusters at z > 1 using an infrared adaptation of the cluster red-sequence method. We present an overview of the northern component of the survey which has been observed with Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope (CFHT)/MegaCam and covers 28.3 deg^2. The southern component of the survey was observed with Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory (CTIO)/MOSAICII, covers 13.6 deg^2, and is summarized in a companion paper by Wilson et al. We also present spectroscopic confirmation of two rich cluster candidates at z ~ 1.2. Based on Nod-and-Shuffle spectroscopy from GMOS-N on Gemini, there are 17 and 28 confirmed cluster members in SpARCS J163435+402151 and SpARCS J163852+403843 which have spectroscopic redshifts of 1.1798 and 1.1963, respectively. The clusters have velocity dispersions of 490 ± 140 km s^(–1) and 650 ± 160 km s^(–1), respectively, which imply masses (M_(200)) of (1.0 ± 0.9) × 10^(14) M_⊙ and (2.4 ± 1.8) × 10^(14) M_⊙. Confirmation of these candidates as bonafide massive clusters demonstrates that two-filter imaging is an effective, yet observationally efficient, method for selecting clusters at z > 1.
\n
BibTeX
@article{muzzin2009spectroscopic,
  author = {Adam Muzzin and Gillian Wilson and H. K. C. Yee and Henk Hoekstra and David Gilbank and J. Surace and Mark Lacy and Kris Blindert and Subhabrata Majumdar and R. Demarco and Jonathan P. Gardner and M. D. Gladders and C. J. Lonsdale},
  title = {{SPECTROSCOPIC CONFIRMATION OF TWO MASSIVE RED-SEQUENCE-SELECTED GALAXY CLUSTERS AT<i>z</i>∼ 1.2 IN THE SpARCS-NORTH CLUSTER SURVEY}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1088/0004-637x/698/2/1934},
}
Figure