Spatiotemporal Variability in the Water Quality of Poyang Lake and Its Associated Responses to Hydrological Conditions

Bing Li, Guishan Yang, Rongrong Wan, Yanhui Zhang, Xue Dai, Yuwei ChenWater 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the complex interplay between water quality and hydrological conditions in Poyang Lake, China, a crucial freshwater ecosystem. By analyzing six years of data, the researchers found that water level is a key driver of water quality, with lower levels (river phase) leading to significantly higher pollutant concentrations. This work highlights dilution as the primary factor controlling seasonal water quality variations and suggests targeted management strategies for improving the lake's health.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Natural lakes are vital for human societies, providing essential resources and ecosystem services. However, increasing urbanization and population growth lead to nutrient loading, deteriorating water quality. Understanding the patterns of water quality and the factors influencing them is critical for effective lake management. Poyang Lake, China's largest freshwater lake, faces unique challenges due to its status as a flood-plain lake with significant intra- and inter-annual water level fluctuations (WLFs). These WLFs influence pollutant transport and degradation, but the specific relationships between water quality parameters and these fluctuations, especially in a lake with seasonal variable velocities, remain underexplored. Furthermore, climate change and the impoundment of the Three Gorges Reservoir have altered water exchange between Poyang Lake and the Yangtze River, impacting WLFs and potentially the lake's ecological functions. This paper aims to elucidate the spatiotemporal variability of water quality in Poyang Lake and its driving factors, particularly hydrological conditions.

Methods

The study employed a comprehensive approach to analyze water quality and hydrological data.

  • Data Collection: Water samples were collected from 15 sites across Poyang Lake and its tributaries over a six-year period (2009-2014). Samples were taken seasonally (four times a year) to capture temporal variations.
  • Parameter Measurement: Eleven water quality parameters were measured, including physical parameters (temperature, pH, dissolved oxygen, electrical conductivity, Secchi depth) and chemical parameters (suspended solids, chemical oxygen demand, total nitrogen, total phosphorus, ammonia nitrogen, chlorophyll-a). In-situ measurements were taken for some parameters, while others were analyzed in the laboratory following standard methods.
  • Statistical Analysis:
    • Relative Seasonal Average (RMse,s,p): Used to compare seasonal variations at each site relative to the overall annual average for that site.
  • Pearson's Correlation Analysis: To assess the relationships between water level and various water quality parameters.
  • K-S Test: To examine differences in water quality parameters between distinct hydrological phases (river vs. lake).
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): A multivariate statistical technique used to identify key water quality parameters and their potential sources under different water regimes (river and lake phases). PCA was performed on normalized data to account for different measurement units.
  • Probability Density Lines: Used to visualize the distribution of nutrient indicators in the river and lake phases.

Datasets

  • Water Quality Data: Concentrations of 11 water quality parameters (T, pH, DO, EC, SD, SS, CODMn, TN, TP, NH4-N, Chl-a) collected from 15 sampling sites in Poyang Lake between 2009 and 2014.
  • Hydrological Data: Monthly water level data for site 4 (Duchang) from the Hydrological Bureau of Jiangxi Province.
  • Tributary Data: Monthly discharge and pollutant concentrations (TP and NH4–N) from five main tributaries (2009-2011).
  • Sewage Data: Inter-annual sewage discharge data for Jiangxi Province (used as a proxy for sewage flow into the lake).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Water Level as a Dominant Factor: The study strongly emphasizes that water level is a primary driver of water quality in Poyang Lake. The distinction between "river phase" (low water level, <14m) and "lake phase" (high water level, >14m) is crucial, with the river phase exhibiting significantly poorer water quality.
  • Dilution is Key for Seasonal Variability: While various factors influence water quality, dilution emerges as the most significant factor controlling seasonal variations. This suggests that the influx of freshwater during certain periods plays a major role in moderating pollutant concentrations.
  • Spatial Heterogeneity Exists, But Temporal is Stronger: While some spatial variations were observed, particularly near polluted tributaries, the temporal variations (seasonal and inter-annual) were more pronounced and impactful across the lake.
  • PCA Reveals Distinct Water Regimes: Principal Component Analysis effectively separated the "river phase" and "lake phase" samples, highlighting different environmental influences. The river phase is characterized by higher nutrient loads and organic pollution, while the lake phase shows better overall quality.
  • Eutrophication and Organic Pollution are Major Concerns: PCA identified eutrophication and organic pollution as key contributors to water quality issues, aligning with the general challenges faced by many freshwater lakes.

Key Results

  • Pollutant Levels Higher in River Phase: All pollutant parameters were significantly higher in the river phase (water level <14 m) compared to the lake phase (water level >14 m) (p < 0.05). For instance, TN concentration was 1.87 mg/L in the river phase versus 1.34 mg/L in the lake phase.
  • PCA Explains Significant Variance: Three principal components explained over 79% of the dataset variance, with PC1 (nutrient and natural input pollution) and PC2 (eutrophication) being particularly important.
  • 2011 as a Worst-Case Year: 2011 was identified as a typically dry year with a low average water level (10.96 m), which coincided with the worst water quality observed across several parameters (TN, SS, CODMn, TP, Chl-a).
  • Seasonal Nutrient Patterns: TN and NH4-N peaked in winter, while Chl-a showed an opposite pattern, peaking in spring, summer, and autumn, likely due to lower water temperatures and light conditions in winter.
  • Site-Specific Issues: Site 1, near the outlet of the heavily polluted Rao River, showed the highest RSs,p for TN, TP, and NH4-N, indicating localized pollution hotspots.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that estimating sewage from tributaries was challenging, and inter-annual sewage discharge data was used as a proxy.
  • While PCA identified key factors, the exact quantitative effect of tributary discharge on water quality requires further investigation.
  • The study noted that Chl-a concentration did not always follow the trend of other nutrient indices, suggesting that its variations might not be solely explained by nutrient availability in Poyang Lake.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that future research should focus on ascertaining the quantitative effect of discharge from tributaries to provide more reliable recommendations for lake improvement and maintenance.
  • They also propose that management strategies like setting total maximum daily loads (TMDL) and regulating water levels within the lake could be beneficial.
  • Further investigation into the specific drivers of Chl-a variations is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Determining the spatiotemporal water quality patterns and their corresponding driving factors is crucial for lake water quality managements. This study analyzed hydrological data and concentrations of 11 water quality parameters, including total nitrogen, total phosphorus, ammonia nitrogen and chlorophyll–a (Chl–a), for water samples collected from 15 sampling sites between 2009 and 2014. The water quality of sites in the northern Poyang Lake–Yangtze River waterway was influenced by different environmental parameters compared to sites in central lake, especially for Chl–a concentration. All pollutant parameters were significantly higher in the river phase (water level &lt;14 m) than in the lake phase (water level &gt;14 m) (p &lt; 0.05). These results were confirmed via principal component analysis, which identified three principal components that explained over 79% of the dataset variance. Among all the parameters related to climatic factors, eutrophication and organic pollution were the most important contributors in water quality. Dilution was the controlling factor that drove the seasonal variability in the water quality of the Poyang Lake, China. This work further indicated that regulating pollutant effluents in tributaries and water level within the lake could improve the water quality in Poyang Lake, which may give some impetus for water quality management.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2016spatiotemporal,
  author = {Bing Li and Guishan Yang and Rongrong Wan and Yanhui Zhang and Xue Dai and Yuwei Chen},
  title = {{Spatiotemporal Variability in the Water Quality of Poyang Lake and Its Associated Responses to Hydrological Conditions}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3390/w8070296},
}
Figure