Spatio–Temporal Evolutionary Features and Drivers of Green Competitiveness of Cities Surrounding the Yellow River

Jiawen Zhang, Zhenhua Xu, Fuyi CiSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzes the green competitiveness of 78 cities along China's Yellow River from 2006-2020, revealing a steady but low overall improvement. Key drivers identified are infrastructure, urbanization, and S&T innovation, with their interactions being more impactful than individual effects, highlighting the complex nature of sustainable urban development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Yellow River Basin (YRB) is a critical region for China's economic development and ecological security. However, it faces significant challenges including a fragile ecosystem, a traditional development model characterized by high pollution and low resource utilization, and uncoordinated regional development. Improving "green competitiveness" – a city's ability to achieve economic growth while being environmentally friendly and socially beneficial – is crucial for sustainable development in this region. This paper addresses the need to understand how this green competitiveness has evolved over time and across different areas of the YRB, and what factors are driving these changes, to inform targeted policy interventions.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Entropy Weighting Method: This standard technique was used to construct a comprehensive indicator system for green competitiveness, comprising economic, social, and environmental dimensions, each further broken down into "foundation" and "efficiency" sub-components. This allowed for a nuanced measurement of green competitiveness.
  • Kernel Density Estimation (KDE): This non-parametric method was used to visualize and analyze the dynamic evolution of the distribution of green competitiveness across cities over time, revealing trends in the overall level, dispersion, and polarization.
  • Dagum Gini Coefficient: This statistical tool was applied to quantify the spatial differences in green competitiveness, decomposing overall inequality into contributions from within-region and between-region disparities, and identifying the main sources of these differences (e.g., hypervariable density).
  • Spatial Autocorrelation (Global and Local Moran's I, Getis-Ord Gi*): These methods were used to identify spatial clustering patterns, revealing "hot spots" (areas of high green competitiveness) and "cold spots" (areas of low green competitiveness).
  • GeoDetector: This novel approach was used to quantitatively assess the driving forces behind the spatio-temporal patterns of green competitiveness, analyzing both individual factor impacts and the synergistic effects of interacting factors.

Datasets

The study utilized panel data for 78 prefecture-level cities in eight provinces along the Yellow River route (Qinghai, Gansu, Ningxia, Inner Mongolia, Shaanxi, Shanxi, Henan, and Shandong) from 2006 to 2020. Data sources included statistical yearbooks on urban construction, city development, energy, and provincial data. Specific data on air quality were obtained from the China Air Quality Online Inspection and Analysis Platform, and green patent data from the National Intellectual Property Rights Database. Due to the lack of city-scale energy consumption and carbon emission data, the researchers employed a downscaling method using nighttime lighting data (NPP-VIIRS) based on provincial-level data. Missing indicators were supplemented through interpolation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Downstream Advantage": A clear spatial hierarchy emerges, with downstream cities consistently outperforming midstream and upstream cities in green competitiveness. This highlights the significant role of established infrastructure, industrial bases, and policy support in the downstream region.
  • Widening Gaps: While overall green competitiveness is improving, the absolute and relative differences between cities are increasing. This suggests that cities with existing advantages are pulling further ahead, making it harder for lagging regions to catch up.
  • Spatial Stickiness of Hot/Cold Spots: The "hot spot" in the Shandong Peninsula and the "cold spot" in southeastern Gansu show remarkable spatial persistence, indicating deep-rooted factors influencing these patterns. This suggests that regional endowments and historical development trajectories play a significant role.
  • Interaction is Key: The study strongly emphasizes that the combined effect of driving factors (like infrastructure, urbanization, and S&T) is far more powerful than their individual contributions. This underscores the need for integrated policy approaches rather than isolated interventions.

Key Results

  • Overall Improvement, Low Level: Green competitiveness of cities in the YRB increased by 52.63% from 2006 to 2020, but the overall level remains not high.
  • Spatial Hierarchy: Green competitiveness follows a "downstream > midstream > upstream" pattern.
  • Spatial Correlation: A significant positive spatial autocorrelation exists, with hot spots in the Shandong Peninsula and cold spots in southeastern Gansu.
  • Primary Drivers: The most significant individual drivers of green competitiveness are the level of city infrastructure construction (mean q=0.7312), the level of urbanization (mean q=0.5751), and S&T innovation (mean q=0.3649).
  • Interaction Effects: Interactions between drivers, particularly government regulation and city infrastructure, showed strong non-linear enhancement effects (e.g., q=0.9085).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The paper acknowledges the challenge of obtaining city-specific energy consumption and carbon emission data, necessitating a downscaling approach. Future work could benefit from more granular, officially published data.
  • Focus on Specific Drivers: While the study identifies key drivers, the complex interplay of other socio-economic and environmental factors could be further explored.
  • Policy Specificity: While recommendations are provided, future research could delve deeper into the specific policy mechanisms required to address the identified regional disparities and driver interactions effectively. The paper suggests that future work should focus on fostering inter-regional cooperation and tailoring strategies to specific regional conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on the scientific concept of city green competitiveness, an integrated evaluation indicator system was established to use the entropy method in order to measure the green competitiveness index of 78 cities surrounding the Yellow River (YR) from 2006 to 2020. Further, the spatio–temporal features and drivers of city green competitiveness were analyzed using various methods. The research found the following: (1) Although the green competitiveness of cities surrounding the YR has been growing steadily, the overall level is not high. (2) The green competitiveness of cities surrounding the YR can be spatially characterized as “downstream > midstream > upstream”; the absolute and relative differences between cities are both increasing, and overall differences stem mainly from the hypervariable density. (3) The positive spatial correlation between the green competitiveness of cities surrounding the YR is significant, with the “cold spot” in southeastern Gansu and the “hot spot” in the Shandong Peninsular city cluster. (4) The level of city infrastructure construction, the level of urbanization, and science and technology innovation are the main drivers of the green competitiveness of cities surrounding the YR. In addition, the interaction forces of each factor were found to be much stronger than the effects of individual factors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023spatiotemporal,
  author = {Jiawen Zhang and Zhenhua Xu and Fuyi Ci},
  title = {{Spatio–Temporal Evolutionary Features and Drivers of Green Competitiveness of Cities Surrounding the Yellow River}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151914127},
}
Figure