TL;DR
This study analyzes the spatial and temporal evolution of A-level scenic spots in Guizhou Province, China, from 2005 to 2019. It reveals a shift from concentrated distribution to a more balanced, albeit recently re-concentrated, pattern, driven by factors like road network density and tourism income. The findings inform strategies for optimizing tourism development in the region.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
China has a hierarchical system for evaluating tourist attractions, with "A-level scenic spots" being a key designation. Guizhou Province, known for its unique karst landscapes and growing tourism sector, has seen a rapid increase in these A-level spots. However, understanding how these spots have developed spatially and what factors are driving this evolution is crucial for effective tourism planning, resource allocation, and sustainable development. This paper addresses the lack of comprehensive spatiotemporal analysis of A-level scenic spots in Guizhou, aiming to reveal their distribution patterns, identify key influencing factors, and provide actionable recommendations.
Methods
The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to analyze the spatiotemporal dynamics of A-level scenic spots:
- Average Nearest Neighbor Index: Used to quantify the degree of clustering or dispersion of scenic spots over time.
- Gini Coefficient: Applied to measure the spatial distribution equilibrium (or inequality) of scenic spots across different administrative regions.
- Kernel Density Analysis: Visualized and quantified the spatial concentration and agglomeration of scenic spots, revealing high-density "hotspots."
- Directional Distribution Analysis (Standard Deviation Ellipse): Characterized the overall spatial distribution trend, including its center, orientation, and spread, over the study period.
- Trend Surface Analysis: Provided a visual representation of the general trend in the number of scenic spots across counties, highlighting spatial differentiation.
- Geodetector: A powerful tool used to quantitatively assess the influence of various natural and socioeconomic factors on the spatial distribution of scenic spots, allowing for coupling and attribution analysis.
Datasets
The study utilized several datasets:
- A-level Scenic Spots Data: Information on the distribution, grade, coordinates, and evaluation year of A-level scenic spots in Guizhou Province from 2005 to 2019. This data was sourced from official government websites and municipal tourism administrations.
- Geographic and Socioeconomic Data:
- Administrative boundaries, digital elevation models (DEM), and normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) from the Chinese Academy of Sciences.
- River and road network data from OpenStreetMap.
- Tourism income data from macroeconomic databases.
- Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and population density data for 88 counties and districts in Guizhou.
Key Insights and Ideas
- From Concentration to Balance, then Re-concentration: The study reveals a fascinating evolution: initially, scenic spots were highly concentrated. Over time, they became more evenly distributed, but more recently (2017-2019), there's a trend towards small-scale re-concentration.
- "Two Axes, Multi-Core" Emergence: The spatial distribution pattern has evolved from simple high-density areas to a more complex "two-axis, multi-core" structure, indicating a more sophisticated tourism development landscape.
- Roads and Revenue Rule: Road network density and tourism income emerged as the most significant drivers of scenic spot distribution, highlighting the critical role of accessibility and economic viability.
- Altitude's Diminishing Dominance: While altitude was a stronger factor in earlier years, its influence has lessened, suggesting technological advancements have made higher-altitude development more feasible.
- Southern Guizhou's Lag: A persistent challenge is the lagging development of scenic spots in southern Guizhou, despite its rich natural resources.
Key Results
- The number of A-level scenic spots in Guizhou increased dramatically from 6 in 2005 to 406 in 2019, with a "blowout" growth observed from 2016 onwards.
- The average nearest neighbor index consistently indicated an agglomerated distribution throughout the study period, though the degree of clustering varied.
- The Gini coefficient showed a general downward trend from 2005 to 2017, indicating increasing spatial equilibrium, but rose slightly from 2017-2019.
- Kernel density analysis revealed the formation of a "two-axis, multi-core" pattern by 2019, with axes in the north-central and central parts of the province.
- The standard deviation ellipse showed an expansion in area and a shift in orientation, generally moving towards a southwest-northeast trend after 2007.
- Geodetector analysis identified road network density (average explanatory power of 0.234) and tourism income (0.230) as the most influential factors, followed by GDP (0.114) and altitude (0.079). Population density and river density had less impact.
Limitations and Future Work
- Southern Guizhou Development: The paper highlights the underdevelopment of tourism in southern Guizhou as a key limitation and suggests strengthening traffic infrastructure and developing hydrological scenic spots as potential solutions.
- "Point-Axis Network Surface" to "Two-Axis Multi-Core": The authors propose upgrading the development model to align with the observed "two-axis, multi-core" pattern, emphasizing regional cooperation and leveraging big data.
- Data Lag: The Geodetector analysis used a one-lag period for dependent variables due to the long construction cycle of scenic spots, which is a methodological consideration.
- Future Research: While not explicitly detailed, the study's findings provide a strong foundation for future research into specific regional development strategies, the impact of policy changes, and the integration of new tourism models.
Summary updated