TL;DR
This study analyzes the ecosystem service value (ESV) in Yancheng, a coastal zone in Eastern China, from 2000 to 2020. It reveals that while construction land expanded significantly, leading to a decrease in farmland and water bodies, the overall ESV initially increased then decreased. Land use intensity, topography, and socio-economic factors were identified as the primary drivers of these changes, with interactions between these factors playing a crucial role.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Coastal zones are vital ecosystems supporting a large portion of the global population, yet they face significant threats from anthropogenic activities and environmental changes. Understanding how the value of ecosystem services (ESV) changes over time and what drives these changes is crucial for effective conservation and sustainable development. Previous studies often focused on single land use types or lacked a comprehensive analysis of the complex interactions between multiple driving factors. This paper addresses this by investigating the spatiotemporal dynamics of ESV in a typical coastal zone and employing a robust method to disentangle the influence of various drivers and their interactions.
Methods
The study employed a multi-faceted approach:
- Equivalence Factor Method: This standard method was adapted for the Yancheng region to estimate ESV based on land use types and their corresponding service values. A dynamic adjustment factor was introduced to account for regional variations.
- Spatial Statistical Analysis: Global and Local Moran's I were used to assess the spatial autocorrelation and clustering of ESV, revealing patterns of spatial dependence.
- Standard Deviation Ellipse: This technique was used to visualize the spatial distribution trend and identify the center of gravity and orientation of ESV over time.
- GeoDetector: This novel approach was utilized to identify the driving forces behind ESV spatial differentiation. It includes:
- Factor Detection: Quantifies the explanatory power of individual factors (e.g., land use, topography, socio-economics, climate) on ESV variation.
- Interaction Detection: Assesses how the combined effect of two factors influences ESV, highlighting synergistic or antagonistic relationships.
Datasets
- Land Use Data: Remote sensing monitoring data from Landsat TM images for five periods (2000, 2005, 2010, 2015, 2020) at a 30m resolution. Land use types included farmland, forest land, grassland, construction land, water body, and unused land.
- Socio-economic Data: Data on grain yield, unit price, and sown area were sourced from the Jiangsu Statistical Yearbook and the China Agricultural Price Survey Yearbook.
- Driving Factor Data:
- Climate: Average annual temperature (TEM) and average annual rainfall (RAI).
- Topography: Average elevation (DEM).
- Socio-economics: Population density (POP) and economic density (GDP).
- Land Use: Land development intensity (LDI).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Construction Land Expansion is a Major Disruptor: The dramatic increase in construction land, at the expense of farmland and water bodies, is a primary driver of land use change and has significant implications for ESV. This highlights the direct trade-off between economic development and ecological preservation in coastal areas.
- ESV Dynamics are Complex: The initial increase and subsequent decrease in ESV suggest a non-linear response to land use changes and development pressures. This underscores the need for long-term monitoring and adaptive management strategies.
- Interactions Matter Most: The study strongly emphasizes that the combined effects of driving factors are far more influential than individual factors. This challenges a reductionist view and calls for integrated approaches to environmental management.
- Land Use Intensity is King (but not alone): While land use intensity (LDI) consistently shows the highest explanatory power for ESV variation, its interaction with topography (DEM) and socio-economic factors (POP, GDP) significantly amplifies its impact. This suggests that how land is used, in conjunction with its physical characteristics and human pressures, dictates ESV.
Key Results
- Land Use Change: Construction land increased by 962.69 km² (from 9.38% to 13.70%), while cultivated land decreased by 784.1 km² (from 82.92% to 79.4%). Water bodies also decreased by 163.34 km².
- ESV Trend: Total ESV increased from 547.84 × 10⁸ yuan in 2000 to 570.86 × 10⁸ yuan in 2005, then decreased to 507.62 × 10⁸ yuan in 2020, a net decrease of 40.22 × 10⁸ yuan (-7.34%).
- Dominant ESV Contributors: Farmland ecosystems accounted for over 60% of the total ESV, and regulatory services were the core function, also exceeding 60%.
- Spatial Distribution: ESV showed significant spatial autocorrelation and local clustering. Extremely low ESV areas expanded in urbanized regions, while high ESV areas were concentrated along the eastern coast. The ESV gravity center shifted from north to southwest.
- Driving Factor Importance (ranked): LDI > DEM > POP > GDP > RAI > TEM.
- Interaction Effects: Any two-factor interaction had higher explanatory power than a single factor. For example, LDI and DEM interactions explained over 80% of ESV variation.
Limitations and Future Work
- Land Use Classification Dependency: The equivalence factor method's accuracy is tied to the land use classification system. The authors suggest refining this by including specific coastal ecosystems like mangrove forests, sandy beaches, and salt marshes.
- Methodological Variety: While the equivalence factor method is efficient, the authors propose exploring other ESV evaluation methods and conducting comparative analyses in the future.
- Factor Selection: Only seven factors were included due to data availability. Future research should incorporate more factors to provide a more comprehensive understanding of coastal zone driving mechanisms.
- Grading Methods: The study used the natural interruption point grading method for drivers. The authors suggest exploring different grading methods and their impact on results.
- Scale Considerations: While the study used a 3km x 3km grid, future work could explore finer scales to capture more detailed spatial differentiation.
Summary updated