Spatially explicit analysis identifies significant potential for bioenergy with carbon capture and storage in China

Xiaofan Xing, Rong Wang, Nico Bauer, Philippe Ciais, Junji Cao, Jianmin Chen, Xu Tang, Lin Wang, Xin Yang, Oliviér Boucher, Daniel S. Goll, Josep Peñuelas, Ivan A. Janssens, Yves Balkanski, James H. Clark, Jianmin Ma, Bo Pan, Shicheng Zhang, Xingnan Ye, Yutao Wang, Qing Li, Gang Luo, Guofeng Shen, Wei Li, Yechen Yang, Siqing XuNature Communications 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a detailed, spatially explicit analysis of Bioenergy with Carbon Capture and Storage (BECCS) potential in China's power sector. It finds that retrofitting existing coal plants with BECCS could significantly contribute to China's carbon neutrality goals, offering a cost-effective pathway to deep decarbonization, but highlights the critical importance of addressing logistical challenges.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China's rapid industrialization has led to a massive reliance on coal-fired power plants, contributing significantly to global CO2 emissions. While China has ambitious climate targets, including carbon neutrality by 2060, the existing coal infrastructure presents a challenge. Simply retiring these plants is economically difficult, and their continued operation exacerbates climate change. BECCS, which involves co-firing biomass with coal and capturing the resulting CO2 for storage, is proposed as a solution. However, the feasibility of large-scale BECCS deployment is debated, particularly concerning its economic viability, sustainability impacts, and the complex logistical requirements of sourcing biomass and transporting CO2 across a vast country like China. This paper aims to address these uncertainties by providing a spatially explicit assessment of BECCS potential and costs in China.

Methods

The authors employ a spatially explicit, county-level optimization model to estimate the marginal cost curve for decarbonizing China's power sector using BECCS. This approach integrates several key components:

  • Biomass Supply Modeling: They estimate the potential of various ligno-cellulosic biomass feedstocks (agricultural residues, forestry residues, and dedicated energy crops) across China's 2836 counties.
  • Power Plant Retrofitting: The model considers the retrofitting of existing pulverized coal (PC) power plants for 90% biomass co-firing and Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS).
  • Logistical Optimization: A novel aspect is the explicit consideration of biomass transportation routes (within county, within province, between provinces) and CO2 transport via pipelines to geological storage sites. This is crucial for a country as large as China.
  • Cost-Benefit Analysis: The model minimizes the total economic cost of achieving a target level of CO2 emission reduction, considering costs associated with biomass acquisition, pretreatment, transport, CCS, retrofitting, and the revenue from coal substitution.
  • Life-Cycle Emissions Assessment: The analysis incorporates life-cycle emissions from various stages of BECCS, including land-use change, fertilizer production, and biomass processing.
  • Monte Carlo Simulations: To account for uncertainties in various parameters (costs, emissions, yields), Monte Carlo simulations are used to estimate the range of marginal costs.

Datasets

The study utilizes a comprehensive set of datasets, including:

  • Biomass Feedstock Data: Data on agricultural residues (from 11 crop types) and forestry residues, as well as potential energy crops grown on marginal lands and grasslands. This data is compiled from Chinese statistical yearbooks, FAO, and remote sensing monitoring data.
  • Power Plant Data: Information on existing coal-fired power plants, including their capacities, allocated to 2836 counties.
  • CO2 Storage Capacity Data: A compilation of geological storage potential in China, including deep saline aquifer basins, depleted oil and gas basins, and deep coal reserves.
  • Geographical and Socioeconomic Data: Data on land use, precipitation, temperature, and Gross Domestic Product (GDP) at the county level.
  • Infrastructure Data: Information on existing natural gas pipelines, which can potentially be adapted for CO2 transport.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather integrates and analyzes existing data with a novel spatial modeling framework.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Significant BECCS Potential: China possesses substantial potential for BECCS, with an estimated 222 GW of existing power plant capacity that could be retrofitted to co-fire biomass and capture CO2.
  • Logistics are Paramount: The spatial mismatch between biomass sources, power plants, and storage sites is a critical challenge. The study highlights that efficient transportation networks for both biomass and CO2 are essential for cost-effective BECCS deployment.
  • Cost-Competitiveness: BECCS can be a cost-competitive option for deep decarbonization in China, especially when considering the value of avoided coal emissions. The marginal cost of emission reduction through BECCS is comparable to renewable energy sources like wind and solar.
  • Stranded Asset Solution: Retrofitting existing coal plants offers a dual benefit: it addresses the issue of stranded assets while simultaneously contributing to climate mitigation.
  • County-Level Specificity Matters: A spatially explicit approach is crucial. Simply aggregating national potentials can mask significant regional variations in biomass availability, logistical challenges, and economic feasibility.

Key Results

  • Biomass Availability: China could theoretically harvest 3.04 Gt of dry matter per year from ligno-cellulosic biomass, including agricultural residues (0.79 Gt/yr), forestry residues (0.31 Gt/yr), and energy crops (0.32 Gt/yr on marginal lands and 1.62 Gt/yr on grasslands).
  • Power Generation Capacity: Approximately 222 GW of power capacity across 2836 counties can be retrofitted for BECCS, utilizing 0.9 Gt of biomass annually.
  • Emission Reduction: BECCS deployment could lead to a reduction of 1.0 ± 0.1 Gt CO2 per year from coal combustion and remove 1.4 ± 0.1 Gt CO2 per year from the atmosphere.
  • Marginal Costs: The marginal cost of abating 1 Gt CO2-eq per year through BECCS in China is estimated at $69±33 per ton, increasing to $103±33 for 2 Gt CO2-eq per year.
  • Economic Impact: Abating 2 Gt CO2 per year would require an investment of approximately $64 billion per year, representing about 0.6% of China's GDP in 2015.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Logistical Challenges: The paper acknowledges that while the model accounts for transportation, the actual implementation of these complex logistical networks (biomass sourcing, CO2 pipelines) presents significant challenges that require further investigation.
  • Sustainability of Biomass: The study briefly touches upon the potential adverse impacts of biomass removal on soil erosion and carbon content, suggesting that more research is needed to monitor these effects and explore soil remediation technologies.
  • Technological Advancements: The efficiency of biomass co-firing and CCS technologies, particularly at high biomass co-firing ratios (90%), could be further improved.
  • Policy and Regulatory Frameworks: The paper implies that supportive policies and regulatory frameworks will be essential for enabling large-scale BECCS deployment.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further studies are needed to monitor the impacts of biomass removal on soil degradation and the effectiveness of soil remediation technologies. They also highlight the need for more flexible and efficient matching of biomass availability, electricity demand, and geological storage potential in space and time.

Summary updated

Abstract

As China ramped-up coal power capacities rapidly while CO<sub>2</sub> emissions need to decline, these capacities would turn into stranded assets. To deal with this risk, a promising option is to retrofit these capacities to co-fire with biomass and eventually upgrade to CCS operation (BECCS), but the feasibility is debated with respect to negative impacts on broader sustainability issues. Here we present a data-rich spatially explicit approach to estimate the marginal cost curve for decarbonizing the power sector in China with BECCS. We identify a potential of 222 GW of power capacities in 2836 counties generated by co-firing 0.9 Gt of biomass from the same county, with half being agricultural residues. Our spatially explicit method helps to reduce uncertainty in the economic costs and emissions of BECCS, identify the best opportunities for bioenergy and show the limitations by logistical challenges to achieve carbon neutrality in the power sector with large-scale BECCS in China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xing2021spatially,
  author = {Xiaofan Xing and Rong Wang and Nico Bauer and Philippe Ciais and Junji Cao and Jianmin Chen and Xu Tang and Lin Wang and Xin Yang and Oliviér Boucher and Daniel S. Goll and Josep Peñuelas and Ivan A. Janssens and Yves Balkanski and James H. Clark and Jianmin Ma and Bo Pan and Shicheng Zhang and Xingnan Ye and Yutao Wang and Qing Li and Gang Luo and Guofeng Shen and Wei Li and Yechen Yang and Siqing Xu},
  title = {{Spatially explicit analysis identifies significant potential for bioenergy with carbon capture and storage in China}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-021-23282-x},
}
Figure