Spatially Covarying Patterns of Gray Matter Volume and Concentration Highlight Distinct Regions in Schizophrenia

Kelly Rootes-Murdy, Elaheh Zendehrouh, Vince D. Calhoun, Jessica A. TurnerFrontiers in Neuroscience 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Introduction: Individuals with schizophrenia have consistent gray matter reduction throughout the cortex when compared to healthy individuals. However, the reduction patterns vary based on the quantity (concentration or volume) utilized by study. The objective of this study was to identify commonalities between gray matter concentration and gray matter volume effects in schizophrenia. Methods: We performed both univariate and multivariate analyses of case/control effects on 145 gray matter images from 66 participants with schizophrenia and 79 healthy controls, and processed to compare the concentration and volume estimates. Results: Diagnosis effects in the univariate analysis showed similar areas of volume and concentration reductions in the insula, occipitotemporal gyrus, temporopolar area, and fusiform gyrus. In the multivariate analysis, healthy controls had greater gray matter volume and concentration additionally in the superior temporal gyrus, prefrontal cortex, cerebellum, calcarine, and thalamus. In the univariate analyses there was moderate overlap between gray matter concentration and volume across the entire cortex ($r = 0.56, p = 0.02$). The multivariate analyses revealed only low overlap across most brain patterns, with the largest correlation ($r = 0.37$) found in the cerebellum and vermis. Conclusions: Individuals with schizophrenia showed reduced gray matter volume and concentration in previously identified areas of the prefrontal cortex, cerebellum, and thalamus. However, there were only moderate correlations across the cortex when examining the different gray matter quantities. Although these two quantities are related, concentration and volume do not show identical results, and therefore, should not be used interchangeably in the literature.

Introduction

Schizophrenia is widely associated with reductions in gray matter across the brain. To measure these changes, researchers typically use Voxel-Based Morphometry (VBM) to extract two primary quantities: Gray Matter Concentration (GMC) and Gray Matter Volume (GMV). GMC represents the proportion of gray matter relative to other tissue types within a single voxel. GMV represents the absolute amount of gray matter, calculated by adjusting the concentration based on how much a brain region had to be "warped" (stretched or shrunk) to fit a standard template—a process called Jacobian modulation.

Despite their mathematical differences, many studies treat GMC and GMV as proxies for one another. This study sought to determine if this assumption is valid: Do these two metrics actually point to the same biological abnormalities in schizophrenia, or do they highlight distinct neuroanatomical signatures?

Methods

The researchers analyzed T1-weighted MRI scans from the Center for Biomedical Research Excellence (COBRE) dataset, including 66 individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia and 79 healthy controls. The groups were matched for age and gender, with smoking status included as a covariate.

Two distinct analytical frameworks were employed:

  1. Univariate Analysis (VBM): A voxel-by-voxel comparison to identify specific points of difference between healthy controls and individuals with schizophrenia.
  2. Multivariate Analysis (Source-Based Morphometry - SBM): This approach uses Independent Component Analysis (ICA) to identify broad, spatially covarying patterns (networks) of gray matter rather than looking at voxels in isolation.

To compare the two metrics, the team calculated Pearson correlations and the Jaccard Index (a measure of spatial overlap) between the resulting GMC and GMV maps.

Results

The "Interchangeability" Myth

The most significant finding is that GMC and GMV are not interchangeable, especially in multivariate contexts. While univariate results showed a moderate correlation ($r = 0.56$), the multivariate patterns were almost entirely distinct, with a median correlation of just $r = 0.01$.

Spatial correlation maps illustrating the degree of overlap between gray matter concentration and volume across the brain.

Univariate vs. Multivariate Findings

In the univariate analysis, both metrics identified gray matter reductions in the insula, occipitotemporal gyrus, and fusiform gyrus in individuals with schizophrenia. However, the multivariate analysis revealed a much wider gap. While healthy controls showed greater GMV and GMC in the superior temporal gyrus, prefrontal cortex, thalamus, and cerebellum, the spatial patterns for GMC and GMV were largely non-overlapping. The Jaccard Index for multivariate spatial patterns showed a median similarity of only 2.73%.

Multivariate spatial patterns (SBM) identifying distinct networks of gray matter volume and concentration differences between healthy controls (HC) and schizophrenia (SZ) patients.

Regional Divergence

The highest overlap between volume and concentration was found in the cerebellum and vermis ($r = 0.37$). Conversely, areas like the superior temporal gyrus and prefrontal cortex showed significant diagnostic effects in one metric but not necessarily the other, highlighting that the "networks" of gray matter loss identified by volume are spatially different from those identified by concentration.

Discussion and Conclusion

The difference between the two metrics stems from Jacobian modulation. GMV captures macroscopic regional differences (the "warping" information), whereas GMC captures the local probability of tissue type. Volume likely reflects changes in the "shape" and "size" of brain regions, while concentration may reflect "density" or "neural packing."

Because these two quantities do not show identical results, they should not be used interchangeably in the literature. The authors recommend that future studies report both GMC and GMV results to provide a more complete picture of structural brain changes in schizophrenia. Furthermore, the use of higher-resolution imaging, such as 7T MRI, may help delineate these cortical boundaries and tissue differences with even greater precision.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Introduction:</b> Individuals with schizophrenia have consistent gray matter reduction throughout the cortex when compared to healthy individuals. However, the reduction patterns vary based on the quantity (concentration or volume) utilized by study. The objective of this study was to identify commonalities between gray matter concentration and gray matter volume effects in schizophrenia. <b>Methods:</b> We performed both univariate and multivariate analyses of case/control effects on 145 gray matter images from 66 participants with schizophrenia and 79 healthy controls, and processed to compare the concentration and volume estimates. <b>Results:</b> Diagnosis effects in the univariate analysis showed similar areas of volume and concentration reductions in the insula, occipitotemporal gyrus, temporopolar area, and fusiform gyrus. In the multivariate analysis, healthy controls had greater gray matter volume and concentration additionally in the superior temporal gyrus, prefrontal cortex, cerebellum, calcarine, and thalamus. In the univariate analyses there was moderate overlap between gray matter concentration and volume across the entire cortex (<i>r</i> = 0.56, <i>p</i> = 0.02). The multivariate analyses revealed only low overlap across most brain patterns, with the largest correlation (<i>r</i> = 0.37) found in the cerebellum and vermis. <b>Conclusions:</b> Individuals with schizophrenia showed reduced gray matter volume and concentration in previously identified areas of the prefrontal cortex, cerebellum, and thalamus. However, there were only moderate correlations across the cortex when examining the different gray matter quantities. Although these two quantities are related, concentration and volume do not show identical results, and therefore, should not be used interchangeably in the literature.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rootesmurdy2021spatially,
  author = {Kelly Rootes-Murdy and Elaheh Zendehrouh and Vince D. Calhoun and Jessica A. Turner},
  title = {{Spatially Covarying Patterns of Gray Matter Volume and Concentration Highlight Distinct Regions in Schizophrenia}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroscience},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fnins.2021.708387},
}
Figure