TL;DR
This study developed an integrated ecosystem service value (IESV) model for Western Jilin, a fragile ecological region in China, and analyzed its spatial and temporal changes over 23 years. The research reveals a declining trend in IESV, with high-value areas concentrated in protected regions, and identifies key natural (NDVI) and socio-economic (HAI) drivers, highlighting synergistic interactions between them.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Balancing economic development with ecological protection is a critical challenge, especially in ecologically fragile regions. Ecosystem services (ESs) are the invaluable benefits humans derive from functioning ecosystems, underpinning survival and well-being. However, rapid economic transitions and human activities often lead to the degradation of these services, threatening regional ecological security and sustainable development. Understanding the spatial and temporal dynamics of Ecosystem Service Value (ESV) and the underlying mechanisms driving these changes is crucial for effective ecological restoration and management. This paper specifically addresses this by investigating the spatio-temporal variations and driving factors of integrated ecosystem service value (IESV) in Western Jilin, a region facing significant ecological challenges like desertification and grassland degradation.
Methods
The study employed a two-pronged approach:
- Integrated Ecosystem Service Value (IESV) Model: An integrated model was constructed by combining two components:
- ESV based on land resource background: This utilized an equivalent coefficient method, adapted from existing research, to assign economic values to different land use types based on their contribution to ecosystem services.
-
Habitat quality assessment: This leveraged the InVEST model, which assesses habitat quality as a proxy for biodiversity. It incorporates external threat factors (e.g., construction land, cultivated land, saline alkali land) and habitat suitability of different land use categories to derive a habitat quality coefficient. The IESV was then calculated by multiplying the ESV from land resources by the habitat quality coefficient.
-
Geographical Detector Technique: This statistical method was used to analyze the driving factors behind the spatial differentiation of IESV. It identifies the influence of individual factors and the interactions between them without requiring linear assumptions. The technique was applied to analyze the contribution of ten selected natural and socio-economic factors.
Datasets
The study utilized the following datasets:
- Land Use Data: Obtained from the Resource and Environment Science and Data Center (RESCDC) for the years 1995, 2000, 2005, 2010, and 2018. This data was interpreted from remote sensing imagery with a 30m x 30m resolution.
- National Grain Unit Price Data: Sourced from China Rural Statistical Almanacs.
- Climate Data: Annual average temperature and precipitation data for Baicheng and Songyuan cities from Jilin Provincial Statistical Almanacs.
- Inland Wetland Nature Reserves and Wetland Parks Data: From land survey data.
- Driving Factor Data:
- Natural Factors: NDVI, NPP, average annual precipitation, average annual temperature, elevation, soil type, and soil erosion.
- Socio-economic Factors: Population density, land average GDP, and Human Activity Index (HAI).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Protected Areas as IESV Havens: The study strongly suggests that protected areas are crucial for maintaining high ecosystem service values. Areas with high IESV were predominantly located within these designated zones, highlighting their effectiveness in conserving ecological assets.
- Synergistic Interactions Matter: The geographical detector analysis revealed that the interaction between factors, rather than individual factors alone, significantly drives IESV differentiation. This emphasizes the complex interplay of natural and human influences.
- NDVI and HAI as Key Drivers: Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) emerged as the most influential natural factor, while the Human Activity Index (HAI) was the strongest socio-economic driver. This underscores the importance of vegetation health and human pressure in shaping ecosystem services.
- Downward Trend in IESV: A concerning finding is the overall downward trend in IESV over the 23-year study period, indicating a degradation of ecosystem services in this fragile region.
Key Results
- Spatial Distribution: High IESV areas were concentrated in protected regions like Chaganhu, Momoge, Dabusu, Hada Mountain, and Sanjiangkou. Conversely, low IESV values were found in central towns and sandy areas.
- Temporal Trend: The study observed a general downward trend in IESV over the past 23 years. The proportion of high-level IESV areas decreased from 8.17% in 1995 to 4.08% in 2010, with a slight increase by 2018.
- Driving Factor Influence (q-values): The geographical detector analysis showed that NDVI (q=0.1263), soil type (q=0.1240), and HAI (q=0.1139) had the highest explanatory power for IESV spatial differentiation. Soil erosion and elevation had minimal influence (<1%).
- Interaction Effects: Interactions between factors generally showed synergistic enhancement, increasing explanatory power. The interaction between NDVI and soil types had the strongest impact (21.95%). Other significant interactions included land average GDP/soil type and NDVI/soil erosion degree.
- Land Use Changes: Cultivated land area increased significantly, while grassland and wetland areas decreased substantially, contributing to the reduction in IESV.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- The study acknowledges that the IESV calculation is based on an equivalent coefficient method, which provides a general estimation.
- The paper notes that while protected areas play a vital role, areas outside these zones are still vulnerable to human activities and habitat degradation.
- Future Work:
- The authors suggest developing more comprehensive regional ecosystem productivity index models incorporating NDVI, NPP, and soil types.
- Future research should place greater emphasis on potential distribution areas of regional animal species and construct a biodiversity index model.
- Integrating multiple models to create a quantitative model that incorporates diverse elements is recommended.
- The authors call for increased involvement of geographers and sociologists to improve assessment frameworks and for policymakers to utilize these findings for planning and management.
Summary updated