Spatial-Planning-Based Ecosystem Adaptation (SPBEA): A Concept and Modeling of Prone Shoreline Retreat Areas

Dewayany Sutrisno, Mulyanto Darmawan, Ati Rahadiati, Muhammad Helmi, Armaiki Yusmur, Mazlan Hashim, Peter Tian-Yuan Shih, Rongjun Qin, Li ZhangISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces the Spatial-Planning-Based Ecosystem Adaptation (SPBEA) model, a novel approach to address shoreline retreat in coastal areas. By integrating land system analysis, AHP-based suitability, and spatial planning, SPBEA offers a framework for sustainable coastal management and adaptation to climate change impacts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coastal areas worldwide are increasingly vulnerable to shoreline retreat due to climate change impacts like rising sea levels, storm surges, and land subsidence. While ecosystem-based adaptation (EbA) is recognized as a crucial strategy, its practical implementation in spatial planning remains a challenge, with varied opinions on how to integrate ecological factors, human well-being, and sustainable development. This paper specifically addresses the need for a structured, spatially explicit approach to develop EbA strategies for areas prone to shoreline retreat, focusing on the Sayung subdistrict in Central Java, Indonesia, a region severely affected by this issue.

Methods

The study developed a Spatial-Planning-Based Ecosystem Adaptation (SPBEA) model using a three-step hierarchical approach within a Geographic Information System (GIS) environment:

  1. Fishpond Zone Determination: This involved a multicriteria analysis (MCA) combining:
  2. Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP): Used to determine the suitability for fishpond culture based on expert opinions and pairwise comparisons of parameters like distance to coastline, distance to rivers, land use, soil, slope, and salinity. A consistency ratio (CR) less than 0.1 was used to ensure the reliability of expert judgments.
  3. Land System Analysis: Categorized the landscape into distinct land units (e.g., intertidal swamp, estuarine plains) based on geomorphological and geographical characteristics.
  4. Integration: The AHP suitability and land system analyses were integrated to derive a more precise land suitability map for fishpond culture.
  5. Fishpond Spatial Site Determination: This step assessed land availability and allocation for fishpond culture.
  6. Land Potential Analysis: Combined land suitability classes with existing fishpond conditions to identify potential areas.
  7. Land Availability Analysis: Excluded areas designated for conservation or other protected zones, and considered land ownership and compliance with regional spatial planning regulations.
  8. Land Allocation: Determined the final spatial allocation for fishponds based on regional spatial planning, considering fishery culture zones and rural settlement zones.
  9. Fishpond Spatial Site Management (SPBEA Development): This involved detailed site management planning using high-resolution remote-sensing imagery and field data.
  10. Visual Interpretation: Classified land cover into categories like mangrove, net ponds, fishponds, settlements, etc.
  11. Site-Planning Analysis: Applied principles for fishpond design, including incorporating mangrove belts for coastal protection and considering silvofishery approaches.
  12. NDWI Model: Used to assess tidal flooding.

Datasets

The study utilized a comprehensive set of datasets:

  • Land System Digital Map: Demak district, scale 1:50,000 (Badan Informasi Geospasial - BIG).
  • Land-Use/Land-Cover Data: Sayung subdistrict, scales 1:5000 and 1:25,000 (BIG Rupabumi map).
  • Spatial Plan: Demak District, year 2020.
  • High-Resolution Orthorectified Image: Timbulskolo village (BIG).
  • Landsat 8 Oli Imagery: Acquired on 29 July 2020.
  • Soil Map: Demak District, scale 1:50,000 (Balai Besar Sumberdaya Lahan Pertanian - BBSDLP).
  • Digital Elevation Model (DEM) and National Bathymetry Data: Obtained from BIG.
  • Field Data: pH, salinity, social, and environmental information collected in February and December 2020.
  • Flood-Prone Area Data: Derived from Normalized Difference Water Index (NDWI) of Landsat 8 Oli.
  • Green Belt and Protection Zone Data: Derived from spatial analysis of Rupabumi map, Landsat 8 Oli, and orthorectified imagery.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study focused on applying existing data and methods to a specific problem.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Power of Integrated Data: The study highlights that combining land system analysis with AHP-based suitability provides a more robust assessment of land suitability for fishpond culture than either method alone. Land systems offer crucial ecological context that traditional suitability analyses might miss.
  • SPBEA as a Structured Adaptation Framework: The hierarchical, three-step approach of SPBEA (zone determination, site determination, site management) provides a clear and actionable framework for developing ecosystem-based adaptation strategies, moving beyond general recommendations.
  • Silvofishery as a Promising Management Practice: The research identifies silvofishery as a key management strategy for fishpond culture in vulnerable coastal areas, emphasizing its dual benefits for economic value and environmental sustainability.
  • Importance of Regional Spatial Planning Integration: The study underscores that successful spatial planning for adaptation must be tightly integrated with existing regional and national regulations and policies.
  • Coastal Protection Zones are Crucial: The concept of a "coastal belt protection zone," informed by previous coastlines and incorporating hybrid engineering and mangrove belts, is presented as vital for mitigating erosion and tidal wave impacts.

Key Results

  • The AHP analysis classified fishpond culture zones into highly suitable (S1), moderately suitable (S2), marginally suitable (S3), and unsuitable (N).
  • Integration of land system analysis revealed that the KJP (intertidal swamp) land system is the most suitable for fishpond culture in the Sayung subdistrict.
  • The land potential analysis identified specific areas with high potential for fishpond culture.
  • Spatial allocation results showed that while some areas were designated for fishery culture zones, others were planned for rural settlements, industrial zones, or coastal greenbelts, influencing the available land for fishponds.
  • In Timbulsloko village, a focus area for severe abrasion, the SPBEA model proposed site management strategies including protection zones, mangrove belts, and silvofishery practices for fishponds.
  • Some pond farmers in Timbulsloko have already begun implementing silvofishery practices.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that more advanced techniques like Spatial Decision Support System (SDSS) tools were not implemented, suggesting a potential for future enhancements.
  • The availability status of land remains unclear without considering regional spatial regulation and policy, indicating a need for further integration with governance aspects.
  • The study focused on a specific subdistrict, and its direct applicability to other regions might require adaptation.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that future work should focus on integrating the SPBEA process, data, and algorithms into a comprehensive system that can serve as a guideline for implementing SPBEA.
  • A community-based SPBEA approach is recommended, especially for developing countries, to ensure that local communities are directly involved in spatial planning.
  • Further research could explore the economic feasibility and long-term effectiveness of the proposed silvofishery practices and hybrid engineering techniques.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{sutrisno2021spatial,
  author = {Dewayany Sutrisno and Mulyanto Darmawan and Ati Rahadiati and Muhammad Helmi and Armaiki Yusmur and Mazlan Hashim and Peter Tian-Yuan Shih and Rongjun Qin and Li Zhang},
  title = {{Spatial-Planning-Based Ecosystem Adaptation (SPBEA): A Concept and Modeling of Prone Shoreline Retreat Areas}},
  journal = {ISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf.},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijgi10030176},
}
Figure