Spatial patterns of transportation choice in Niterói

Sandro Martinelli Reia, Taylor Anderson, Dieter PfoserarXiv 2026 · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a computational framework that transforms static, aggregate urban data—like census records and building footprints—into a dynamic, microscopic simulation of how people move through a city. By applying this to Niterói, Brazil, they demonstrated that reducing "first-and-last-mile" walking times to bus stops by 30% could boost the public-transit-to-car ratio by over 11%, particularly in underserved peripheral neighborhoods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding urban mobility is a "holy grail" for city planners, yet the data required to do it well is notoriously difficult to get. Traditional travel surveys are expensive and quickly become outdated, while high-resolution GPS traces from mobile phones raise significant privacy concerns and often lack context regarding why someone is traveling.

This paper tackles the data scarcity gap. The authors ask: Can we build a high-fidelity model of a city’s movement patterns using only widely available, "static" datasets like census statistics, OpenStreetMap (OSM) networks, and building locations? Their goal is to create a "what-if" tool for planners to test how infrastructure changes—like adding a new bus line or improving sidewalks—might shift people from cars to public transit.

Methods

The authors introduce an integrated modeling workflow that bridges the gap between aggregate data and individual behavior:

  1. Synthetic Population Generation: Using 2022 Brazilian Census data, they created 475,446 "synthetic agents," matching the age, sex, and employment distributions of Niterói’s actual census tracts.
  2. Building Infrastructure Layer: They combined building footprints (from Google/Microsoft/OSM) with municipal Points of Interest (POIs) to classify over 100,000 locations into five activity classes: residential, workplace, food, education, and recreation.
  3. Activity-Based Modeling (ABM): Instead of just modeling "trips," they modeled "lives." Agents follow schedules based on their roles (worker, student, homemaker). Mandatory activities (work/school) are fixed, while "needs-driven" activities (errands/dining) are triggered when internal thresholds are met.
  4. Probabilistic Mode Assignment: For every generated trip, the model calculates travel times for walking, driving, and public transit. It uses a multinomial logit model to assign a mode. Crucially, this isn't a "fastest-path-wins" model; it accounts for the "disutility" of travel time and the relative attractiveness of different modes.
Overview of the modeling framework, showing the flow from open data inputs to activity simulation and final evaluation.

Datasets

The study relies heavily on open and municipal data:

  • Population: IBGE 2022 Brazilian Census.
  • Buildings: Google-Microsoft-OpenStreetMap Open Buildings collection.
  • Infrastructure: Niterói HUB SIGeo (for POIs and bus network details).
  • Networks: OpenStreetMap for the road and pedestrian network.
  • Validation: An empirical activity proxy derived from image-based transit activity shares across 52 neighborhoods.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "First/Last Mile" is the Bottleneck: The model reveals that in peripheral areas, the time spent walking to and from bus stops contributes more to the "travel burden" than the actual time spent on the bus. In the city center, access times are negligible, but they skyrocket to ~30 minutes in the outermost zones.
  • Homemakers Drive Discretionary Mobility: While workers account for 20% of trips, "homemakers" (a model label for adults without fixed workplaces, including retirees) represent nearly 35% of the population. Their flexibility leads to a high volume of recreation and errand-based trips, which are often overlooked in peak-hour-focused transit models.
  • Infrastructure Shapes Choice More Than Distance: While car use generally increases toward the periphery, the model identified "transit-oriented" tracts far from the center that follow the spine of the bus network, proving that good service can overcome the "distance-from-center" penalty.
Activity patterns showing that 'Home' is the central hub of all trip chains, with work and recreation following as top destinations.

Key Results

  • High Validation Accuracy: The simulated neighborhood-level transit patterns showed a remarkably strong association with empirical data, achieving a Pearson correlation of r = 0.885.
  • Trip Volume: The simulation generated 8.35 million trips over a seven-day period, averaging 2.51 trips per agent per day.
  • The 30% Experiment: In a counterfactual scenario where walking times to/from bus stops were reduced by 30% (simulating better sidewalks or feeder services), the public-transit-to-car ratio increased by 11.3%.
  • Spatial Heterogeneity: The gains from improved transit access were not uniform. The largest shifts from cars to transit occurred in peripheral, car-oriented neighborhoods, identifying exactly where infrastructure investment might yield the highest ROI.
Map showing how daily activities redistribute the population from residential areas to commercial centers during the day.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors are transparent about several modeling simplifications:

  • Household Constraints: The current model assigns modes to individuals without considering household-level constraints, such as car sharing between family members or the specific costs of vehicle ownership.
  • Simplified Routing: Transit travel times assume constant bus speeds and do not yet account for real-time traffic congestion or bus capacity limits (overcrowding).
  • Calibration: The model was calibrated against regional modal split targets rather than locally observed neighborhood-level choices, which might mask some hyper-local nuances.

Future work aims to incorporate more granular data on monetary costs and vehicle ownership to refine the mode-choice probabilities and explore more complex "what-if" urban design scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

Characterizing how people move through a city requires spatially and temporally fine-grained data that are often costly and difficult to obtain. Here, we introduce a computational framework that uses macroscopic, aggregated, and static urban data to construct a microscopic, dynamic, and spatially detailed representation of urban mobility. Building on an existing activity simulator, the framework combines a synthetic population, the built environment, and transport networks to generate daily trips and assign walking, car, or public transit. Applied to approximately 475,000 synthetic residents of Niterói, Brazil, simulated neighborhood-level transit patterns show a strong association with an empirical activity proxy (Pearson r=0.885). Walking is more prevalent in compact central areas, car use increases toward the periphery, and public-transit use remains comparatively high along bus corridors. Reducing walking times to and from bus stops by 30% increases the modeled public-transit-to-car ratio by 11.3%, with larger transit-share gains in several peripheral areas. These results reveal spatial differences in transportation choice and identify where improved transit access may have the greatest modeled effect.
BibTeX
@misc{reia2026spatial,
  author = {Sandro Martinelli Reia and Taylor Anderson and Dieter Pfoser},
  title = {{Spatial patterns of transportation choice in Niterói}},
  year = {2026},
  eprint = {2611.14499},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.14499},
}
Figure