Spatial Optimization and Allocation of Primary Healthcare Facility Resources in Townships and Villages under Different Terrain Conditions of Sichuan Province, China

Li Yan-ju, Qianqian Wang, Abdul Munif, Yuyi WangResearch Square 2026 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages GIS network analysis and spatial modeling to optimize the layout of primary healthcare facilities across the diverse terrains of Sichuan Province, China. By accounting for topographical barriers and "golden rescue time" thresholds, the researchers propose a tailored strategy: consolidating redundant clinics in densely populated plains while strategically adding facilities and upgrading resources in the sparsely populated western plateaus.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China’s healthcare strategy emphasizes a "hierarchical treatment system," where the first point of contact should occur at the grassroots level (township and village clinics). However, Sichuan Province presents a massive geographical challenge. It spans from the flat Chengdu Plain to the rugged Western Sichuan Plateau, creating a "topographic lottery" for healthcare access.

The authors identify a critical gap in existing research: most accessibility studies use simple distance-based models that ignore the reality of mountain travel, such as altitude changes and varying road qualities. This paper seeks to determine how terrain influences the "golden rescue time" (the critical 6–15 minute window for emergency care) and how to reallocate resources to ensure equitable health coverage regardless of a resident's elevation.

Methods

The researchers selected six towns representing distinct topographical zones (from alpine valleys to basin hills). They employed a multi-step spatial analysis workflow:

  • Network Analysis: Instead of "as the crow flies" distance, they built an Origin-Destination (OD) cost matrix using actual road networks. They assigned different travel speeds based on road grade and terrain (e.g., 20 km/h on a mountain village road vs. 25 km/h in the plains).
  • ANUSPLIN Interpolation: This is a sophisticated spatial interpolation technique. Unlike standard methods, it allows for "covariates"—meaning the model accounts for how altitude and population density influence healthcare accessibility.
  • Location-Allocation Modeling: The team used two specific models to optimize the layout:
  • Minimum Impedance Model: To identify which existing clinics are overloaded and need internal upgrades (more beds or staff).
  • Minimum Facility Model: To determine the fewest number of new clinics needed to cover the maximum number of residents within a 15-minute travel window.

Datasets

The study integrated several high-resolution datasets:

  • Healthcare Infrastructure: Official lists of clinics, bed counts, and staff numbers from local health and family planning commissions.
  • Residential Data: Location data for natural villages and "village groups" (the smallest administrative units) obtained via Baidu Maps and secondary development scripts.
  • Geospatial Data: Elevation and satellite imagery from the National Earth System Science Data Center.
  • Socio-economic Indicators: Regional GDP, population density from the 7th National Census (2020), and road network vectors extracted from high-definition imagery.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Redundancy vs. Scarcity" Paradox: In the eastern basin plains, the problem isn't a lack of clinics, but "redundant layout." Too many small facilities compete for the same population, leading to inefficiency. Conversely, the western plateau suffers from "blind spots" where vast areas have no coverage at all.
  • Terrain-Specific Speed Limits: The study highlights that a "one size fits all" speed limit for accessibility modeling is a mistake. The "cost" of a kilometer in the mountains is significantly higher in terms of time and risk than in the plains.
  • The 15-Minute Threshold: The researchers found that while plain areas (like Qinglong Street) achieved nearly 97.5% accessibility within 15 minutes, some plateau areas (like Heihe Town) initially had 0% accessibility within that same critical window.
  • Internal Upgrades over New Construction: A key "aha" moment was realizing that 13 specific village clinics were "overloaded" (serving >3,500 people). In these cases, the solution wasn't necessarily a new building, but increasing the ratio of health technicians to meet the provincial standard of 8.04 per 1,000 people.

Key Results

  • Optimization Success: In Tangke Town (plateau), the proposed optimization increased the 15-minute healthcare coverage rate from 54.55% to 87.27%.
  • Resource Rebalancing: The study identified that in the eastern basin, medical points should actually be reduced or consolidated to enhance internal service capabilities and avoid resource waste.
  • Quantitative Disparity: Before optimization, accessibility in the eastern basin was consistently above 60% within a 6-minute window, while western study areas were all below 44%. After applying the "Minimum Facility Model," the researchers were able to bring all settlements in Erliping Town within a 15-minute radius of care.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several constraints:

  • Scope of Facilities: The study focused only on public primary healthcare. It did not account for private clinics or pharmacies, which often supplement rural care.
  • Static Traffic Data: The model uses design speeds for roads but does not account for real-time traffic, seasonal weather (like snow blocking mountain passes), or natural disasters (landslides).
  • Future Directions: The researchers suggest that future models should incorporate "real-time traffic" data and look more closely at "urban-rural planning" integration to ensure that as populations shift, healthcare resources follow.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> The first diagnosis at the grassroots level in villages and towns is important in diseases’ prevention and control. Town and village clinics within "three-level rural medical network" are the central bodies to realize the "first diagnosed at grassroots level" of Chinese hierarchical treatment system. Sichuan Province, with rich geomorphological units and varied rural settlement forms, presents significant regional differences in applying the combined configuration standards of “National Medical Institution Setting Plan”. Sichuan’s primary medical facilities with different topography represents the whole country. An important aspect in achieving effective grassroots diagnosis and ensuring the “golden rescue time” is the availability of medical facilities in relation to accessible transportation distance. This paper selects typical towns having different topographical features from the six sub-functional divisions in "Sichuan Ecological Protection and Construction Plan" as research cases. GIS network analysis, neighborhood analysis, ANUSPLIN interpolation, and other research methods were used to examine the accessibility and spatial service patterns of primary medical resources and proposes layout optimization strategies. The results show that: (1) Western Sichuan plateau is characterized by vast area and sparse population with uneven distribution, lacking medical centers. In densely populated eastern basin having smaller area, medical points should be reduced to avoid redundancy, and enhance the internal service capabilities. (2) Significant unbalanced allocation of medical resources exists between the six functional partitions and within partitions. (3) Accessibility of medical facilities in Qiping Town, Luxi Town, and Qinglong Street (eastern basin) is higher than Tangke Town, Heihe Town, and Erliping Town (western plateau area).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yanju2026spatial,
  author = {LI Yan-ju and Qianqian Wang and Abdul Munif and Yuyi Wang},
  title = {{Spatial Optimization and Allocation of Primary Healthcare Facility Resources in Townships and Villages under Different Terrain Conditions of Sichuan Province, China}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-8862839/v1},
}
Figure