Spatial modulation of visual responses arises in cortex with active navigation

E. Mika Diamanti, Charu Bai Reddy, Sylvia Schröder, Tomaso Muzzu, Kenneth D. Harris, Aman B. Saleem, Matteo CarandinieLife 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that spatial position significantly modulates visual responses in the mouse cortex, a phenomenon that strengthens with experience and active navigation. This spatial modulation is largely absent in the thalamus, suggesting it originates and is amplified within the visual cortex itself, rather than being inherited from earlier sensory processing stages.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The brain needs to integrate sensory information with the animal's current location to navigate effectively. While it's known that the hippocampus plays a crucial role in spatial navigation, the extent to which sensory areas, particularly the visual cortex, are influenced by spatial information during active movement has been less clear. Specifically, researchers wanted to understand:

  • Where does spatial modulation of visual responses originate? Does it start in early visual processing areas like the Lateral Geniculate Nucleus (LGN) or is it a cortical phenomenon?
  • How does this spatial modulation evolve? Does it change with experience in an environment or with active versus passive movement?
  • Does this modulation differ across visual processing areas? Is it confined to primary visual cortex (V1) or present in higher visual areas (HVAs) as well?

Understanding these questions is key to deciphering how the brain constructs a coherent representation of the world that integrates sensory input with spatial context.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of cutting-edge techniques to investigate neuronal activity in mice navigating a virtual reality (VR) environment:

  • Two-photon calcium imaging: This allowed them to record the activity of large populations of neurons in different visual areas (V1 and HVAs) and LGN boutons with high spatial and temporal resolution.
  • Virtual Reality (VR) Corridor: Mice ran on a treadmill in a VR environment designed with visually matching segments. This setup allowed researchers to present the same visual stimuli at different spatial locations within the corridor, enabling them to distinguish between purely visual responses and those modulated by spatial position.
  • Electrophysiology: Used to record the activity of individual LGN neurons.
  • Behavioral Tracking: Mice's running speed and other behavioral parameters were monitored to correlate neural activity with movement.
  • Data Analysis:
    • Spatial Modulation Index (SMI): A quantitative measure was developed to assess how strongly a neuron's response varied with spatial position.
  • Cross-validation: Used to ensure the reliability of response profiles and SMI measurements.
  • General Linear Models: Employed to disentangle the contributions of visual, behavioral, and spatial factors to neuronal responses.

Datasets

The study utilized data from mice navigating a virtual reality corridor. The key datasets generated and analyzed were:

  • Two-photon imaging data: Recordings from V1 and higher visual areas (LM, AL, RL, A, AM, PM) and LGN boutons in mice.
  • Electrophysiology data: Recordings from LGN units.
  • Behavioral data: Running speed, pupil size, pupil position, and reward events.

The full imaging dataset, including deconvolved traces and behavioral variables, has been uploaded to the Dryad Digital Repository.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cortical Origin of Spatial Modulation: The most striking finding is that spatial modulation of visual responses is largely absent in the LGN, the primary thalamic input to V1. This strongly suggests that this spatial coding is generated within the visual cortex itself, rather than being a pre-processed signal from the thalamus.
  • Experience and Active Navigation are Crucial: Spatial modulation in the visual cortex isn't static. It significantly strengthens with repeated exposure to the environment (experience) and is much more pronounced during active navigation compared to passive viewing (even when the animal is running but not receiving visual feedback). This highlights the dynamic interplay between sensory processing and motor engagement.
  • Ubiquitous in Higher Visual Areas: This spatial modulation isn't limited to V1. It's present and similarly strong across multiple higher visual areas, indicating a widespread cortical mechanism for integrating spatial context into visual processing.

Key Results

  • LGN vs. Cortex: Median SMI for LGN boutons was very low (0.07 ± 0.05), while for V1 neurons it was significantly higher (0.39 ± 0.19). In HVAs, the median SMI was also substantial (0.40 ± 0.12), comparable to V1.
  • Strengthening with Experience: In V1, median SMI increased from 0.24 on day 1 to 0.45 by day 5 of exposure to the VR corridor.
  • Active Navigation Advantage: During "running replay" (passive viewing while running), V1 neurons showed a ~10% decrease in median SMI compared to active VR navigation. This decrease was much more pronounced (~68%) during "stationary replay" (passive viewing while stationary).
  • Widespread Cortical Modulation: Spatial modulation was observed across six different higher visual areas, with SMIs not significantly different from V1.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Head-Fixed Mice: The study was conducted in head-fixed mice, which limits the direct translation of findings to freely moving animals. The authors acknowledge that vestibular inputs, absent in this setup, might play a role in LGN spatial modulation in freely moving animals.
  • Route of Cortical Input: While the study shows spatial modulation originates in the cortex, the specific cortical pathways through which navigational signals reach V1 (e.g., retrosplenial cortex, anterior cingulate cortex) are still to be fully charted.
  • Mechanisms of Amplification: The paper suggests nonlinear mechanisms might amplify LGN inputs in V1, but the precise cellular and circuit-level mechanisms remain an area for future investigation.
  • Role of Reward: While the study found spatial modulation was not affected by reward protocols, further exploration of how reward influences this process could be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

During navigation, the visual responses of neurons in mouse primary visual cortex (V1) are modulated by the animal's spatial position. Here we show that this spatial modulation is similarly present across multiple higher visual areas but negligible in the main thalamic pathway into V1. Similar to hippocampus, spatial modulation in visual cortex strengthens with experience and with active behavior. Active navigation in a familiar environment, therefore, enhances the spatial modulation of visual signals starting in the cortex.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{diamanti2021spatial,
  author = {E. Mika Diamanti and Charu Bai Reddy and Sylvia Schröder and Tomaso Muzzu and Kenneth D. Harris and Aman B. Saleem and Matteo Carandini},
  title = {{Spatial modulation of visual responses arises in cortex with active navigation}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.63705},
}

Loading related content...

Figure