Spatial Heterogeneity and Influencing Factors of High-Grade Tourist Attractions in the Tibetan Plateau

Shanshan Shi, Mi Li, Ziqiang Li, Jianchao XiInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzes the spatial distribution and influencing factors of high-grade tourist attractions in the Tibetan Plateau, revealing a distinct northeast-southwest orientation and a clustered pattern in the southeast. The findings highlight the critical roles of natural environment, tourism resources, socio-economic development, transportation, and tourism linkages in shaping this distribution, offering insights for sustainable tourism development in this unique region.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Tibetan Plateau, a region of immense natural beauty and cultural significance, is increasingly being developed as a global tourism destination. However, its unique geographical characteristics, fragile ecosystem, and underdeveloped economy present challenges for strategic tourism planning. Specifically, there's a need to understand how high-grade tourist attractions (those with 3A ratings or higher) are spatially distributed and what factors drive this distribution. This knowledge is crucial for optimizing regional tourism layouts, minimizing ineffective investments, and promoting sustainable, high-quality tourism development that balances economic growth with ecological preservation. Previous research has explored tourism in China, but a comprehensive analysis of the entire Tibetan Plateau's high-grade tourist attractions and their influencing factors has been lacking.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining several geostatistical methods:

  • Standard Deviation Ellipse (SDE): Used to reveal the directional characteristics, center of gravity, and spread of high-grade tourist attractions across the plateau. This helps understand the overall orientation and concentration.
  • Kernel Density Estimation (KDE): Applied to visualize and analyze the spatial density of tourist attractions, identifying "hotspots" and areas of high concentration. This method highlights the clustering patterns.
  • Spatial Autocorrelation (SA) (Moran's I): Utilized to assess the degree of spatial dependence and identify whether high-grade tourist attractions are clustered, dispersed, or randomly distributed. Both global and local autocorrelation were examined.
  • Modified Tourism Gravity Model: This model was adapted to measure the intensity and structure of tourism economic linkages between cities within the Tibetan Plateau, providing insights into how different urban centers interact in terms of tourism.

These methods were integrated to provide a comprehensive understanding of both the spatial patterns and the underlying mechanisms influencing them.

Datasets

The study utilized data on high-grade tourist attractions (5A, 4A, and 3A) in the Tibetan Plateau for the year 2021. The primary sources for this data were the official websites of the Departments of Culture and Tourism of Qinghai Province and the Tibet Autonomous Region.

Additional data used included:

  • Spatial coordinate data and shortest road distance data between cities, obtained from the Baidu Map platform.
  • Geographic vector data from the geospatial data cloud.
  • Socio-economic statistics from provincial and municipal statistical yearbooks and bulletins.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing datasets were compiled and analyzed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Roof of the World" has a distinct tourism geography: The Tibetan Plateau isn't uniformly attractive for tourism. Its high-grade attractions exhibit a clear directional bias and clustering, suggesting that not all areas are equally developed or appealing.
  • Southeast is the tourism hotspot: The southeastern part of the plateau is significantly denser in high-grade tourist attractions, forming a "double nucleus-driven and strip-connected" pattern, with Xining and Lhasa acting as key hubs. This highlights the importance of regional economic and infrastructural development in driving tourism.
  • Spatial dependence is complex: While there's a positive spatial correlation indicating clustering, the study also notes characteristics of "large dispersion and small clustering" and a predominantly negative spatial association type. This suggests a nuanced relationship where attractions might be close but not necessarily mutually reinforcing in all cases.
  • A multi-factor approach is essential: The study strongly emphasizes that no single factor dictates the location of tourist attractions. A combination of natural endowments, resource availability, socio-economic conditions, transportation networks, and inter-city tourism linkages collectively shapes the spatial distribution.

Key Results

  • Directional Distribution: High-grade tourist attractions are oriented along a northeast-southwest axis, with a strong centripetal force. The center of gravity for these attractions is located in Yushu City.
  • Density Patterns: The southeastern half of the plateau shows remarkable spatial heterogeneity in density, with a "double nucleus-driven and strip-connected" pattern. Xining and Lhasa are identified as crucial hierarchical centers.
  • Spatial Association: High-grade tourist attractions exhibit spatial dependence with characteristics of "large dispersion and small clustering." The spatial association type is mainly negative.
  • Influencing Factors: The study confirms that natural environment base, tourism resource endowment, socio-economic development, transportation location constraints, and spatial tourism linkages are significant single-factor mechanisms influencing the spatial distribution and agglomeration of high-grade tourist attractions.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a key limitation: the study's reliance on 2021 data means it primarily reveals spatial layout characteristics and influencing factors but fails to conduct a dynamic evolution analysis over time.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Updating long-time series data to deepen the exploration of spatiotemporal patterns and their evolution.
  • Investigating the interaction effects between factors rather than just single-factor mechanisms, potentially using geographic probes.
  • Further exploring the "point-axis" advantage and the role of tourism in guiding the development of neighboring towns to create new town development structures.
  • Promoting the optimal combination of different tourist attractions and developing a more diverse tourism product portfolio.

Summary updated

Abstract

The construction of the world tourism destination on the Tibetan Plateau is inseparable from the traditional tourist attractions, which are significant landscape ecological units. Based on the data of high-grade tourist attractions on the Tibetan Plateau, the spatial heterogeneity and influence factors are studied employing the Standard Deviation Ellipse (SDE), Kernel Density Estimation (KDE), spatial autocorrelation (SA), and modified tourism gravity model methods. The results show that: (1) the overall spatial distribution characteristic of high-grade tourist attractions is in the direction of northeast-southwest, with solid centripetal force, and the center of gravity of the ellipse is in Yushu City. (2) The spatial heterogeneity of the kernel density distribution is remarkable, clustered in the southeastern half of the plateau, showing a double nucleus-driven and strip-connected pattern. The distribution among cities has a hierarchical heterogeneity, and the two capital cities of Xining and Lhasa play a crucial role. (3) The high-grade tourist attractions are spatially dependent, with evident characteristics of large dispersion and small clustering, and the spatial association type is mainly negative. (4) This paper verifies the significant single-factor mechanism affecting the spatial distribution from supportive and intrinsic dimensions with natural environmental base, tourism resource endowment, socio-economic development, transportation location constraints, and spatial tourism linkages. Finally, the article provides suggestions for the high-quality development of high-grade tourist attractions on the Tibetan Plateau.
BibTeX
@article{shi2023spatial,
  author = {Shanshan Shi and Mi Li and Ziqiang Li and Jianchao Xi},
  title = {{Spatial Heterogeneity and Influencing Factors of High-Grade Tourist Attractions in the Tibetan Plateau}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph20054650},
}
Figure