Spatial distribution characteristics and influencing factors of traditional villages in Henan Province based on geographical detectors

Wenjing Gao, Wei Zhao, Yingkui Sun, Fuqiang Wan, Yibo YangResearch Square 2026 · DOI

Abstract

Henan Province, located in the transitional zone between the second and third topographic steps of China, represents a typical mountain–plain transitional area and harbors a large number of traditional villages with distinct characteristics and rich cultural connotations. Taking 1,032 traditional villages in Henan as research objects, this study systematically examines their spatial differentiation patterns and driving mechanisms through integrated applications of ArcGIS spatial analysis, geostatistical methods, and the GeoDetector model. The results show that: (1) The spatial distribution of traditional villages in Henan is uneven and highly clustered, exhibiting a “three cores–one belt–multiple points” structure and a “more in the west, fewer in the east” distribution pattern; (2) At the natural geographic level, traditional villages predominantly occur in plains and low-relief mountainous areas with abundant water resources and suitable elevations, reflecting a site-selection preference for “proximity to mountains and water and residence in warmer areas”; (3) At the socio-cultural level, factors such as locational conditions, transportation accessibility, urbanization rate, and population distribution collectively shape the spatial pattern, leading traditional villages to be concentrated in areas with moderate road network density, an appropriate distance from central cities, medium levels of economic development, and relatively high population agglomeration—demonstrating a socio-environmental orientation of “economy as the foundation and cultural continuity as the core”; (4) Overall, the cultural environment exerts the strongest influence on the spatial distribution of traditional villages, followed by economic development, while the natural environment plays a comparatively weaker role. In addition, significant synergistic enhancement effects exist among the influencing factors. During the formation of traditional villages, natural conditions mainly governed the early site-selection process, whereas socio-economic and cultural factors have been crucial in shaping their persistence and development. This study provides data support and theoretical references for the scientific conservation and sustainable development of traditional villages, and offers valuable insights for advancing research on human–land relationships in China’s mountain–plain transitional zones.

Introduction

As rapid urbanization accelerates across China, traditional villages—often described as "living fossils" of rural heritage—face significant threats of "hollowing out" and physical disappearance. Understanding the spatial logic of these villages is essential for their preservation. Henan Province, situated in the transitional zone between China’s western mountains and eastern plains, serves as a critical study area for exploring how natural, economic, and cultural factors synergistically influence village persistence.

Methods and Data

The study analyzes 1,032 national and provincial-level traditional villages in Henan. The methodology integrates several geospatial tools:

  • ArcGIS Spatial Analysis: Employed for Kernel Density Estimation, Nearest Neighbor Index, and Moran’s I to quantify spatial clustering and autocorrelation.
  • Geographical Detector (GeoDetector): Used to identify the primary drivers and their interactions. This tool is particularly effective at detecting how combined factors (e.g., road density and cultural heritage) exert a greater influence than individual factors alone.
  • Datasets: The research utilizes high-resolution environmental data (90m DEM), river network vectors, socio-economic statistics from the Henan Statistical Yearbook 2024, and cultural data from the China Intangible Cultural Heritage Digital Museum.

Spatial Distribution Patterns

The analysis confirms that the distribution of traditional villages in Henan is significantly non-random. The Average Nearest Neighbor (ANN) index of 0.55 and a Z-score of -27.64 indicate a high degree of clustering, with a less than 1% likelihood that this pattern resulted from random chance.

Nearest Neighbor Analysis results confirming significant spatial clustering of traditional villages.

The spatial pattern follows a "three cores–one belt" structure, with a primary cluster at the junction of Pingdingshan and Xuchang. A distinct "West-Hot, East-Cold" pattern is evident: the mountainous western regions are hotspots for traditional villages, while the eastern plains, historically prone to flooding and intensive agricultural modernization, are coldspots.

Spatial distribution of traditional villages in Henan Province showing the "three cores–one belt" structure and topographic preferences.

Influencing Factors and Synergistic Effects

The study identifies a "Goldilocks" zone for village survival. Villages are most frequent at a distance of 47–58 km from central cities—far enough to avoid urban sprawl but close enough to access resources.

While natural factors like elevation and water proximity (51.65% of villages are within 1 km of a river) dictated early site selection, socio-cultural factors now dominate village persistence:

  1. Intangible Cultural Heritage (ICH) Density (q = 0.683): The strongest predictor, indicating that cultural roots are vital for village status.
  2. Road Network Density (q = 0.636): Moderate accessibility supports resilience.
  3. Population Density (q = 0.462): Human agglomeration provides the necessary social foundation.

Crucially, the interaction between road density and ICH density yielded a q-value of 0.826, demonstrating that accessibility combined with strong cultural heritage significantly enhances the likelihood of village preservation.

Conclusion

The spatial distribution of Henan's traditional villages is a product of historical natural selection and modern socio-cultural resilience. While topography provided the initial framework, cultural heritage and moderate economic connectivity are the primary drivers of their continued existence. Future conservation strategies should focus on these synergistic relationships, moving from simple physical preservation to fostering the socio-cultural environments that allow these "living fossils" to thrive in a modernizing landscape.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Henan Province, located in the transitional zone between the second and third topographic steps of China, represents a typical mountain–plain transitional area and harbors a large number of traditional villages with distinct characteristics and rich cultural connotations. Taking 1,032 traditional villages in Henan as research objects, this study systematically examines their spatial differentiation patterns and driving mechanisms through integrated applications of ArcGIS spatial analysis, geostatistical methods, and the GeoDetector model. The results show that: (1) The spatial distribution of traditional villages in Henan is uneven and highly clustered, exhibiting a “three cores–one belt–multiple points” structure and a “more in the west, fewer in the east” distribution pattern; (2) At the natural geographic level, traditional villages predominantly occur in plains and low-relief mountainous areas with abundant water resources and suitable elevations, reflecting a site-selection preference for “proximity to mountains and water and residence in warmer areas”; (3) At the socio-cultural level, factors such as locational conditions, transportation accessibility, urbanization rate, and population distribution collectively shape the spatial pattern, leading traditional villages to be concentrated in areas with moderate road network density, an appropriate distance from central cities, medium levels of economic development, and relatively high population agglomeration—demonstrating a socio-environmental orientation of “economy as the foundation and cultural continuity as the core”; (4) Overall, the cultural environment exerts the strongest influence on the spatial distribution of traditional villages, followed by economic development, while the natural environment plays a comparatively weaker role. In addition, significant synergistic enhancement effects exist among the influencing factors. During the formation of traditional villages, natural conditions mainly governed the early site-selection process, whereas socio-economic and cultural factors have been crucial in shaping their persistence and development. This study provides data support and theoretical references for the scientific conservation and sustainable development of traditional villages, and offers valuable insights for advancing research on human–land relationships in China’s mountain–plain transitional zones.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2026spatial,
  author = {Wenjing Gao and Wei Zhao and Yingkui Sun and Fuqiang Wan and Yibo Yang},
  title = {{Spatial distribution characteristics and influencing factors of traditional villages in Henan Province based on geographical detectors}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-8375046/v1},
}
Figure