TL;DR
This paper introduces the first truly spatially continuous model for simulating early Cenozoic climate and carbon cycle evolution. By moving beyond interpolated climate data, their model reveals significant differences compared to previous methods, highlighting the critical role of continental configuration on timescales shorter than 20 million years.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Understanding Earth's past climate and carbon cycle is crucial for predicting future changes. The atmospheric CO2 concentration (pCO2), a key driver of climate, is regulated by a complex carbon cycle involving biological processes, silicate weathering, and geological outgassing. Accurately simulating this cycle over geological timescales requires models that can capture both climate dynamics and the Earth's surface processes in a spatially resolved manner. However, previous models have relied on computationally expensive methods, often using pre-calculated climate datasets and interpolating between them. This interpolation, especially over long time periods and with changing continental configurations, can introduce significant errors. The authors address this by developing and testing a spatially continuous model that avoids such interpolations, aiming for a more accurate representation of past climate and carbon cycle interactions.
Methods
The core of this work is the development and application of a novel, spatially continuous modeling approach. They couple an atmosphere-ocean General Circulation Model (GCM), CESM1.2, with a silicate weathering model. This coupling is performed at a high temporal resolution (every 1 Myr) to capture the nuances of climate and weathering interactions. Unlike previous models like SCION, which relied on interpolating pre-calculated climate data, this new approach simulates climate and weathering fluxes continuously. The silicate weathering model used is similar to existing ones but with a slight adjustment to the erosion rate constant. The model simulates the evolution of pCO2 by considering the imbalance between degassing (driven by a prescribed tectonic history) and silicate weathering.
Datasets
The paper does not explicitly list datasets used for training. However, it references and compares its results to reconstructions of past climate and pCO2, specifically mentioning reconstructions from [8]. Paleogeographic reconstructions for the Cenozoic were performed for specific time intervals (every ~5 Myr) and are referenced from [9].
Key Insights and Ideas
- Interpolation is a significant source of error: The study clearly demonstrates that interpolating climate and weathering data, even over relatively short geological periods (like 20 Myr), can lead to substantial over or underestimations of key variables like global mean surface air temperature (GMAT) and weathering flux.
- Continental configuration matters more than we thought: Even small changes in continental configuration can have a large impact on GMAT and weathering flux, especially under specific climate conditions. This highlights the need for spatially explicit models that can capture these dynamic geographical shifts.
- True spatial continuity is essential for accurate long-term simulations: The authors argue that for accurate simulations of climate and carbon cycle evolution over geological timescales, especially when continental configurations change, a spatially continuous model is not just desirable but necessary.
- Feasibility of long-term, coupled modeling: The paper shows that running such a spatially continuous climate-carbon cycle model for extended periods (like the entire Cenozoic) is computationally feasible, with a full Cenozoic simulation taking approximately one year of wall-clock time.
Key Results
- The spatially continuous model produced significantly different results for early Cenozoic pCO2 and GMAT compared to the SCION model, which relies on interpolation. For instance, at 40 Ma, the SCION model predicted a higher pCO2 (1250 ppmv vs. 970 ppmv) and a consequently underestimated GMAT.
- The model captured a notable decrease in pCO2 and GMAT between 45 Ma and 40 Ma, which was attributed to increased global weathering flux, particularly from tropical regions due to continental configuration changes.
- The simulation results were found to be more comparable to existing reconstructions of early Cenozoic climate and pCO2 than those from the SCION model.
Limitations and Future Work
- Paleogeographic reconstruction density: The authors acknowledge that the "sudden change of continental configuration" at certain time instants (e.g., 57 Ma and 52 Ma) in their simulation results is due to the relatively coarse resolution of paleogeographic reconstructions (performed only every ~5 Myr). They suggest that denser reconstructions, potentially by combining available data with plate tectonic models, are needed.
- Simplified carbon cycle: The current model does not explicitly consider the influence of vegetation on weathering.
- Future work: The authors propose extending this spatially continuous modeling approach to simulate the entire Cenozoic. They also highlight the potential for incorporating a more complete "Supercycle" model, which would include sedimentation rates of carbonate and organic carbon, and a geodynamic model to simulate outgassing. The inclusion of biogeochemical cycles, which CESM1.2 is capable of, is also a promising avenue.
Summary updated