Abstract
Focal visual attention typically produces enhanced perceptual processing at the psychological level and relatively stronger neural responses at the physiological level. A longstanding mechanistic question is whether these attentional effects pertain specifically to the attended (target) object or to the region of space it occupies. We show here that attentional response enhancement in macaque area V4 extends to behaviorally irrelevant objects in the vicinity of the target object, indicating that focal attention has a strong spatial component at the physiological level. In addition, we find that spatial attention effects typically show a striking directional asymmetry. The direction of the asymmetry varies between cells, so that some cells respond best when attention is directed to the left of the stimulus, some when attention is directed to the right, etc. Thus, attention involves not only enhanced responses to behavioral targets but also a complex modulation of responses to other stimuli in the surrounding visual space.
Introduction
Psychologists have long debated whether visual attention is object-based (selecting a specific "thing") or spatial-based (selecting a "place"). While previous physiological studies showed that neurons in area V4 respond more strongly to attended targets, it remained unclear if this enhancement was due to the object's identity or its location. This 1997 study from the Van Essen lab sought to dissociate these factors. If attention is purely object-based, attending to a target should not affect the neural response to a different, irrelevant object nearby. Conversely, if attention is spatial, the "glow" of attention should enhance responses to any stimulus falling within its reach.
Methods
The researchers recorded single-unit activity from 205 neurons in area V4 across two macaque monkeys (Macaca nemestrina and M. mulatta). They employed a "double-stimulus" paradigm designed to separate the focus of attention from the stimulus used to probe the neuron's receptive field (RF).
Experimental Paradigm
The primary task involved two components:
- The Target: A ring-shaped stimulus placed outside the neuron's RF. The monkey was required to monitor this ring for a subtle change (a quadrant deletion) while maintaining fixation.
- The Probe: A behaviorally irrelevant bar flashed inside the neuron's RF. This bar served as the "probe" to measure the neuron's sensitivity while attention was occupied by the ring.
By systematically moving the target ring to different positions around the RF (positions a-d) and the probe bar to different positions within the RF (positions 1-5), the researchers mapped how the focus of attention modulated the neuron's response profile.
To ensure the results were not artifacts of stimulus timing or layout, several variations were tested, including a sustained bar test where the probe remained present throughout the trial.
Results
The Spatial Penumbra
The study found that attention in area V4 is not a surgical strike but rather a spatial gradient. When the monkey attended to a ring near the probe bar, the neuron's response to that bar increased significantly. This demonstrates a strong spatial component to attention: the enhancement "spills over" onto nearby irrelevant stimuli.
Response Profile Shifts
Attention was found to shift the "peak" sensitivity of V4 neurons. Approximately 46% of cells showed a significant shift in their response profile toward the attended target. In these cells, the average "fractional shift" was 0.33, indicating that a third of the total response strength migrated toward the attentional focus.
Directional Asymmetry
The most striking finding was that 85% of V4 cells exhibited "directional asymmetry." These neurons showed a preference for the direction of attention relative to the stimulus. For example, a cell might fire vigorously when attention is directed to the left of the probe bar but remain relatively quiet when attention is directed to the right. The "fractional gain"—the difference between the best and worst attention directions—averaged 0.55, meaning that changing the focus of attention could more than double a neuron's firing rate.
Discussion
The authors propose that these spatial effects suggest an attention-centered reference frame. By encoding the positions of features relative to the focus of attention, the brain may achieve a form of "translation invariance," allowing for the recognition of complex objects regardless of their retinal position. While the study provides strong evidence for spatial attention, the authors acknowledge that object-based mechanisms likely coexist. Future research is needed to determine how these attention-centered frames contribute to parsing complex, multi-part objects like faces in higher-order visual areas.
Reference
Connor, C. E., Preddie, D. C., Gallant, J. L., & Van Essen, D. C. (1997). Spatial Attention Effects in Macaque Area V4. The Journal of Neuroscience, 17(9), 3201–3214.
Summary updated