Spatial and temporal evaluations of the liquid argon purity in ProtoDUNE-SP

Adam Abed Abud, R. Acciarri, Luiz Paulo Accorsi, M. A. Acero, M. R. Adames, G. Adamov, M. Adamowski, C. Adriano, F. Akbar, F. Alemanno, Nimmy Sarah Alex, K. K. Allison, M. Alrashed, T. Alexander, R. Alvarez, Tiago Alves, Adil Aman, Hamza Amar, P. Amedo, J. Anderson, D. A. Andrade, C Andreopoulos, M. Andreotti, M.p. Andrews, F. Andrianala, S. Andringa, Fleuri Anjarazafy, S. Ansarifard, Dragan Antić, M. Antoniassi, Alfredo Aranda, L. Arellano, E. Arrieta Díaz, M. A. Arroyave, Maria Arteropons, J. Asaadi, M. V. Ascencio, A. Ashkenazi, D. Asner, L. Asquith, E. T. Atkin, D. Auguste, A. Aurisano, V. Aushev, D. Autiero, Daniel Ávila Gómez, M. Azam, F. Azfar, H.o. Back, J.j. Back, Y. Bae, I. Bagaturia, L. Bagby, D. Baigarashev, S. Balasubramanian, Anna Balboni, Pierre Baldi, W. Baldini, Jacobo Baldonedo, B. Baller, Bindu A. Bambah, F. Barão, Daniel Barbu, Gabriela Barenboim, Pablo Barham Alzás, Gareth J. Barker, W. Barkhouse, G. Barr, A. Barros, N. Barros, D. Barrow, J. Barrow, A. Basharina-Freshville, A. Bashyal, V. Basque, Marco Bassani, D. N. Basu, C. Batchelor, L. Bathe-Peters, James Battat, Federico Battisti, J. J. Bautista, F. Bay, J. L. L. Bazo Alba, J. F. Beacom, E. Bechetoille, B. Behera, E. Belchior Batista Das Chagas, Ben Bell, G. Bell, L. Bellantoni, G. Bellettini, V. Bellini, O. Beltramello, A. Belyaev, C. Benitez Montiel, Doug Benjamin, F. Neves, J. BergerJournal of Instrumentation 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive study of liquid argon purity in the ProtoDUNE-SP detector, a crucial prototype for the DUNE experiment. By comparing measurements from dedicated purity monitors with those derived from cosmic-ray muons traversing the detector, the authors demonstrate excellent agreement and validate the purity monitors as reliable tools for ensuring the high-purity argon required for future neutrino experiments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Liquid argon time projection chambers (LArTPCs), like those planned for the Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE), rely on extremely pure liquid argon to detect faint signals from rare particle interactions. Impurities in the argon, primarily oxygen and water, can "capture" ionization electrons as they drift towards the readout sensors, significantly attenuating the signal and compromising the detector's performance. Ensuring and monitoring this purity is paramount, especially for DUNE's large, multi-meter drift volumes. This paper addresses the challenge of accurately measuring and understanding liquid argon purity within the ProtoDUNE-SP detector, a scaled-down prototype of DUNE's horizontal drift module. Specifically, it investigates the spatial and temporal variations of purity and validates the use of dedicated purity monitors against in-situ measurements using muons.

Methods

The study employs two primary methods for measuring the drift electron lifetime, a proxy for argon purity:

  • TPC-based measurements:
    • CRT-TPC Matched Tracks: This method utilizes signals from external Cosmic-Ray Trigger (CRT) detectors to identify muons that pass through the TPC. By matching CRT tracks with reconstructed TPC tracks, researchers can precisely determine the muon's path and timing. The attenuation of ionization charge along this path is then analyzed to infer the drift electron lifetime.
  • Cathode-Crossing Tracks: This technique leverages muons that pass directly through the detector's cathode plane. This provides an independent timing reference and allows for the measurement of charge attenuation across the drift volume.
  • Both TPC methods involve sophisticated signal processing, including hit finding, cluster grouping, track reconstruction (using the Pandora package), and corrections for space charge effects (SCE) which distort the electric field within the detector. The drift electron lifetime is extracted by fitting the most probable value (MPV) of the charge deposition per unit length (dQ/dx) as a function of drift time to an exponential decay model.
  • Purity Monitor measurements:
    • Three dedicated purity monitors, based on designs used in the ICARUS experiment, were installed within the ProtoDUNE-SP cryostat. These monitors are miniature LArTPCs that use UV-illuminated photocathodes to generate photoelectrons. The fraction of these photoelectrons that reach the anode after drifting through the liquid argon is measured. This fraction, Qa/Qc, is directly related to the drift electron lifetime via an exponential relationship.

The paper also details extensive calibration procedures for both TPC and purity monitor data, including corrections for electric field distortions, recombination effects, and detector electronics.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study comes from the ProtoDUNE-SP detector, specifically data collected from October to November 2018. This period was chosen for its stable operating conditions and the full integration of the CRT system. The data includes:

  • Cosmic-ray muon tracks identified by the CRT system and reconstructed in the TPC.
  • Measurements from the three installed purity monitors.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study focuses on analyzing existing data from the ProtoDUNE-SP experiment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Purity Monitors as Reliable Tools: The study strongly validates the use of purity monitors for measuring liquid argon purity. Their measurements show excellent agreement with the more complex TPC-based methods, especially for longer drift distances and in regions with sufficient statistics.
  • Spatial Purity Variations: The data reveals that the liquid argon purity is not uniform throughout the detector. Specifically, the side with the liquid argon inlet (BR) generally exhibits higher purity than the side with the outlet (BL), as expected. Purity also shows some dependence on height.
  • High Purity Achieved: ProtoDUNE-SP consistently achieved high liquid argon purity, with drift electron lifetimes frequently exceeding 30 ms and occasionally reaching over 100 ms, well above the DUNE Far Detector's technical specification of 10 ms.
  • Impact of Recirculation: The data highlights the effectiveness of the argon recirculation and filtration system, with dips in purity observed during periods when the recirculation pump was stopped.
  • SCE Impact on TPC Measurements: The study acknowledges and quantifies the impact of space charge effects on TPC measurements, particularly near detector faces, and details methods to correct for these distortions.

Key Results

  • Drift Electron Lifetimes: For extended periods (weeks) in October-November 2018, drift electron lifetimes measured by both TPC methods and purity monitors were consistently above 30 ms.
  • Agreement Between Methods: The cathode-crossing selection and CRT-TPC matched track selection showed good agreement, with chi-square per degrees of freedom values around 1 for the BL APAs. Purity monitor data also showed good agreement with TPC measurements, particularly in the second APA.
  • Purity Monitor Uncertainty: The purity monitors provided measurements with uncertainties at the 1-3% level for Qa/Qc, translating to sub-percent uncertainties on charge calibration due to impurities.
  • Spatial Purity Trends: The BR drift volume (argon inlet) consistently showed higher charge remaining (indicating higher purity) than the BL drift volume (argon outlet).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Statistics in Certain Regions: Due to the low flux of cosmic-ray muons and the geometry of the CRT system, statistics were limited in certain areas of the detector, particularly the top and bottom faces and the upstream/downstream ends. This restricted the spatial mapping of purity to specific regions.
  • SCE Distortions: While corrections were applied, significant space charge effects near detector faces still limited the usable volume for analysis in some cases.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the analyses developed in this publication will form the basis for future studies on the ProtoDUNE Horizontal Drift and Vertical Drift modules. They highlight the need to further constrain the drift electron diffusion systematic uncertainty and to increase the duration of steady-state operation for future measurements. The validated purity monitors will be crucial for future DUNE modules with much larger drift distances.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Liquid argon time projection chambers (LArTPCs) rely on highly pure argon to ensure that ionization electrons produced by charged particles reach readout arrays. ProtoDUNE Single-Phase (ProtoDUNE-SP) was an approximately 700-ton liquid argon detector intended to prototype the Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE) Far Detector Horizontal Drift module. It contains two drift volumes bisected by the cathode plane assembly, which is biased to create an almost uniform electric field in both volumes. The DUNE Far Detector modules must have robust cryogenic systems capable of filtering argon and supplying the TPC with clean liquid. This paper will explore comparisons of the argon purity measured by the purity monitors with those measured using muons in the TPC from October 2018 to November 2018. A new method is introduced to measure the liquid argon purity in the TPC using muons crossing both drift volumes of ProtoDUNE-SP. For extended periods on the timescale of weeks, the drift electron lifetime was measured to be above 30 ms using both systems. A particular focus will be placed on the measured purity of argon as a function of position in the detector.
BibTeX
@article{abud2025spatial,
  author = {Adam Abed Abud and A. Abed Abud and R. Acciarri and Luiz Paulo Accorsi and M. A. Acero and M. R. Adames and G. Adamov and M. Adamowski and C. Adriano and F. Akbar and F. Alemanno and Nimmy Sarah Alex and K. K. Allison and M. Alrashed and T. Alexander and R. Alvarez and Tiago Alves and Adil Aman and Hamza Amar and P. Amedo and J. Anderson and D. A. Andrade and C Andreopoulos and M. Andreotti and M.P. Andrews and F. Andrianala and S. Andringa and Fleuri Anjarazafy and S. Ansarifard and Dragan Antić and M. Antoniassi and Alfredo Aranda and L. Arellano and E. Arrieta Díaz and M. A. Arroyave and Maria Arteropons and J. Asaadi and M. V. Ascencio and A. Ashkenazi and D. Asner and L. Asquith and E. T. Atkin and D. Auguste and A. Aurisano and V. Aushev and D. Autiero and Daniel Ávila Gómez and M. Azam and F. Azfar and H.O. Back and J.J. Back and Y. Bae and I. Bagaturia and L. Bagby and D. Baigarashev and S. Balasubramanian and Anna Balboni and Pierre Baldi and W. Baldini and Jacobo Baldonedo and B. Baller and Bindu A. Bambah and F. Barão and Daniel Barbu and Gabriela Barenboim and Pablo Barham Alzás and Gareth J. Barker and W. Barkhouse and G. Barr and A. Barros and N. Barros and D. Barrow and J. Barrow and A. Basharina-Freshville and A. Bashyal and V. Basque and Marco Bassani and D. N. Basu and C. Batchelor and L. Bathe-Peters and James Battat and Federico Battisti and J. J. Bautista and F. Bay and J. L. L. Bazo Alba and J. F. Beacom and E. Bechetoille and B. Behera and E. Belchior Batista Das Chagas and Ben Bell and G. Bell and L. Bellantoni and G. Bellettini and V. Bellini and O. Beltramello and A. Belyaev and C. Benitez Montiel and Doug Benjamin and F. Neves and J. Berger},
  title = {{Spatial and temporal evaluations of the liquid argon purity in ProtoDUNE-SP}},
  journal = {Journal of Instrumentation},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1088/1748-0221/20/09/p09008},
}
Figure