Spatial Accessibility Assessment of Prehospital EMS with a Focus on the Elderly Population: A Case Study in Ningbo, China

Huanhuan Zhu, Lin Pan, Yiji Li, Huiming Jin, Qian Wang, Xin Liu, Cong Wang, Peng Liao, Xinyang Jiang, Luo LiInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the spatial accessibility of prehospital Emergency Medical Services (EMS) for the elderly population in Ningbo, China. Using GIS, gravity models, and empirical Bayesian Kriging, it reveals significant spatial imbalances in access, with a clear gradient of decreasing accessibility from the city center outwards, highlighting critical areas for infrastructure improvement.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Globally, populations are aging rapidly, placing increasing demands on healthcare systems, particularly prehospital emergency services. The elderly often have more complex health needs and are more reliant on timely medical intervention. However, existing research on spatial accessibility often overlooks the specific needs of this demographic, and current EMS allocation strategies in China are often empirical rather than data-driven. This paper addresses the critical gap in understanding how well prehospital EMS can reach elderly populations, identifying disparities in access and providing a framework for more equitable resource allocation to ensure their quality of life.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage approach combining Geographic Information Systems (GIS) with established spatial analysis models.

  • Demand Point Definition: Instead of using administrative boundaries, the study area was divided into 1000x1000m grids. Emergency call locations for the elderly were mapped, and grids with call counts were transformed into "demand points" for more granular analysis.
  • Gravity Model: This model was used to quantify the spatial accessibility of prehospital EMS for each demand point. It considers the "supply" (number of ambulance bases) and "demand" (number of elderly calls) and the "distance impedance" (travel time/distance) between them. The model generates an "access score" for each point.
  • Empirical Bayesian Kriging (EBK): To understand the spatial equilibrium and identify clustering patterns of accessibility across the entire study area, EBK interpolation was used. This method smooths the accessibility scores and visualizes them as a continuous surface, revealing spatial trends and disparities.

Datasets

  • Elderly Population Data: Collected from the 7th National Census bulletins for Ningbo.
  • Emergency Call Data: Provided by the Ningbo Medical Emergency Center, covering the period from January 1, 2020, to December 31, 2020. This dataset included patient age, gender, call date, and precise pick-up addresses (longitude and latitude).
  • Ambulance Base Data: Also from the Ningbo Medical Emergency Center, including the location (longitude and latitude) and number of ambulances at each base.
  • Administration Boundary Data: Obtained from the Topographic Database of the National Fundamental Geographic Information System of China.
  • Road Network Data: Gathered from the Topographic Database of the National Fundamental Geographic Information System of China, used for calculating travel distances.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Elderly Demand is Significant: The study confirms that a substantial portion of prehospital EMS demand comes from the elderly, with over 37% of patients being 65 or older. This underscores the urgency of addressing their specific accessibility needs.
  • Beyond Administrative Boundaries: By using fine-grained "demand points" derived from actual emergency calls rather than broad administrative districts, the study offers a more accurate and nuanced picture of accessibility, revealing localized disparities.
  • Centralized Resources, Peripheral Gaps: The findings strongly suggest that ambulance bases are concentrated in the city's central areas, leading to a clear gradient of decreasing accessibility towards the southeast and southwest. This highlights a critical issue of resource distribution.
  • Imbalanced Access is the Norm: The average accessibility score is low (1.43), with nearly 70% of demand points scoring below 1, indicating a severe shortage of accessible ambulances for the elderly in many areas.

Key Results

  • Elderly Utilization Rate: The rate of ambulance service utilization by the elderly was 27.39 per 1000 elderly residents, significantly higher than for younger populations.
  • Seasonal and Daily Patterns: Ambulance use was highest in winter months (25.90%) and lowest in spring (22.38%). Daily call frequency peaked around midday.
  • Primary Health Concerns: The most common reasons for prehospital EMS calls among the elderly were trauma and intoxication (23.70%), followed by neurological and cardiovascular diseases.
  • Accessibility Scores: The mean accessibility score was 1.43. Approximately 67.84% of demand points had scores below 1, and only 2.02% scored above 10.
  • Spatial Gradient: Accessibility scores showed a clear central-outward decreasing trend, with the lowest scores in the southeast and southwest regions of Ningbo.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Incompleteness: The study acknowledges limitations due to potential incompleteness in the automatic recording of EMS information (age, gender, time, address) as it relied on manual confirmation by ambulance crews. This could introduce bias.
  • Retrospective Disease Classification: Missing disease category information was retrospectively classified based on patient complaints, which might have led to inconsistencies in the disease spectrum analysis.
  • On-site vs. In-hospital Data: The study did not document on-site treatment or subsequent in-hospital data, limiting a full understanding of EMS outcomes.

Future work could focus on integrating on-site treatment data and refining the disease classification. The authors suggest that their methodology and findings can serve as a benchmark for prehospital care capacity and inform policymakers in developing more efficient, aging-focused spatial accessibility plans. This includes optimizing dispatch management in resource-rich areas and potentially increasing ambulance bases or adding stations in underserved regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The spatial accessibility of prehospital EMS is particularly important for the elderly population's physiological functions. Due to the recent expansion of aging populations all over the globe, elderly people's spatial accessibility to prehospital EMS presents a serious challenge. An efficient strategy to address this issue involves using geographic information systems (GIS)-based tools to evaluate the spatial accessibility in conjunction with the spatial distribution of aging people, available road networks, and prehospital EMS facilities. This study employed gravity model and empirical Bayesian Kriging (EBK) interpolation analysis to evaluate the elderly's spatial access to prehospital EMS in Ningbo, China. In our study, we aimed to solve the following specific research questions: In the study area, "what are the characteristics of the prehospital EMS demand of the elderly?" "Do the elderly have equal and convenient spatial access to prehospital EMS?" and "How can we satisfy the prehospital EMS demand of an aging population, improve their spatial access to prehospital EMS, and then ensure their quality of life?" The results showed that 37.44% of patients admitted to prehospital EMS in 2020 were 65 years and older. The rate of utilization of ambulance services by the elderly was 27.39 per 1000 elderly residents. Ambulance use by the elderly was the highest in the winter months and the lowest in the spring months (25.90% vs. 22.38%). As for the disease spectrum, the main disease was found to be trauma and intoxication (23.70%). The mean accessibility score was only 1.43 and nearly 70% of demand points had scored lower than 1. The elderly's spatial accessibility to prehospital EMS had a central-outward gradient decreasing trend from the central region to the southeast and southwest of the study area. Our proposed methodology and its spatial equilibrium results could be taken as a benchmark of prehospital care capacity and help inform authorities' efforts to develop efficient, aging-focused spatial accessibility plans.
BibTeX
@article{zhu2021spatial,
  author = {Huanhuan Zhu and Lin Pan and Yiji Li and Huiming Jin and Qian Wang and Xin Liu and Cong Wang and Peng Liao and Xinyang Jiang and Luo Li},
  title = {{Spatial Accessibility Assessment of Prehospital EMS with a Focus on the Elderly Population: A Case Study in Ningbo, China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph18199964},
}
Figure