Sparsely Wiring Connectivity in the Upper Beta Band Characterizes the Brains of Top Swimming Athletes

Xinzhen Pei, Xiaoying Qi, Yuzhou Jiang, Xunzhang Shen, Anli Wang, Yang Cao, Chenglin Zhou, Yuguo YuFrontiers in Psychology 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

Elite swimmers exhibit a more "sparsely wired" brain network, particularly in the upper beta frequency band, which is associated with faster reaction times and higher accuracy in a complex eye-hand-foot coordination task. This suggests that long-term athletic training may optimize brain connectivity for energy efficiency, leading to superior performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The human brain is incredibly energy-intensive, with neural connections and activity consuming a significant portion of our metabolic resources. While we know that brains make trade-offs to balance energy cost and efficiency, it's unclear how intensive, long-term training, like that of elite athletes, might alter brain connectivity to achieve better performance with potentially lower energy expenditure. This study aims to investigate whether elite swimmers, who require highly coordinated movements, possess distinct brain connectivity patterns that reflect this energy cost-efficiency compared to non-athletes.

Methods

The researchers employed electroencephalography (EEG) to record brain activity from elite swimmers (ES) and a control group (CG) while they performed a complex reaction (CR) task. This task involved coordinating eye, hand, and foot responses to visual cues. Key methods included:

  • EEG Recording: 8-channel EEG was used to capture brain signals.
  • Phase Lag Index (PLI): This technique was central to analyzing functional connectivity. PLI measures phase synchronization between EEG signals, specifically designed to mitigate the issue of volume conduction (where signals from one area spread to others, creating artificial connections).
  • Network Wiring Connections (WNC): Calculated based on PLI values above a certain threshold, WNC represents the number of functional connections within specific frequency bands. This serves as a proxy for "wiring cost."
  • Mean Frequency (MF): Used as an indicator of "activity cost," reflecting the rate of neural electrical activity.
  • Upper Beta/Theta Ratio (UBTR): A measure of brain activation rate.
  • Alpha Blocking Rate: Assessed to monitor the stability of the experimental recording process and estimate wakefulness.
  • Eye Blink Analysis: Blink rate and interblink intervals were analyzed as potential indicators of cognitive control and attention.

Datasets

The study utilized data from two groups:

  • Elite Swimmers (ES): 21 master-level professional swimmers.
  • Control Group (CG): 23 age-matched college students with no specialized sports training.

The final analyzed sample consisted of 16 ES and 16 CG. No new benchmarks were introduced; the study focused on analyzing existing behavioral and EEG data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Energy-Efficient Brain Wiring: The core idea is that long-term training might lead to a more "economical" brain wiring, reducing the number of connections needed to achieve high performance. This "sparsely wired" brain could be more energy-efficient.
  • Upper Beta Band Specialization: The most striking differences in connectivity were observed in the upper beta frequency band (20-30 Hz). This band is often associated with sensorimotor integration and attention.
  • Stable Attention: Elite swimmers showed more stable and lower eye-blinking rates, suggesting better sustained attention and cognitive control during demanding tasks.
  • "Fingerprint" of Expertise: The study suggests that specific patterns of brain connectivity, particularly in the frontoparietal network, might serve as a "fingerprint" for elite athletes, reflecting their specialized cognitive and motor adaptations.

Key Results

  • Behavioral Performance: Elite swimmers significantly outperformed controls in the complex reaction task, demonstrating faster reaction times (15.85 ± 4.19 s vs. 19.06 ± 5.13 s) and higher accuracy (94.86% ± 2.51% vs. 87.79% ± 8.99%).
  • Connectivity Differences (Upper Beta Band): Elite swimmers showed significantly fewer and weaker connections in the upper beta frequency band between frontal and parietal regions compared to controls. This was consistent across different threshold settings for defining connections.
  • Connectivity Differences (Theta Band): Conversely, athletes showed stronger connectivity in the low theta frequency band (4-8 Hz) between the F3 and Cz/C4 sites.
  • Eye Blinking: Elite swimmers exhibited more stable and lower eye-blinking rates, with a more regular pattern, compared to controls who had higher and more variable blinking.
  • Training Correlation: Within the elite swimmer group, the number of wiring connections in the upper beta band was positively correlated with years of training.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited EEG Channels: The study used only 8 frontoparietal channels, meaning the brain activity and cost-efficiency of other brain regions could not be assessed.
  • Indirect Energy Measurement: Brain cost-efficiency was inferred from functional connectivity and mean frequency, rather than direct metabolic measurements (like blood oxygen or glucose). This might limit the quantitative accuracy.
  • Swimmer Subtypes: The elite swimmer group was diverse, with participants from 5 different swimming specialties. Comparing specific strokes or relating performance to competition results was not possible due to the small sample size within each specialty.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that these energy-efficient wiring patterns and stable blinking dynamics could potentially be used as biomarkers to identify athletes with high competitive potential. Further research could explore these findings in other sports and with more advanced neuroimaging techniques.

Summary updated

Abstract

Human brains are extremely energy costly in neural connections and activities. However, it is unknown what is the difference in the brain connectivity between top athletes with long-term professional trainings and age-matched controls. Here we ask whether long-term training can lower brain-wiring cost while have better performance. Since elite swimming requires athletes to move their arms and legs at different tempos in time with high coordination skills, we selected an eye-hand-foot complex reaction (CR) task to examine the relations between the task performance and the brain connections and activities, as well as to explore the energy cost-efficiency of top athletes. Twenty-one master-level professional swimmers and 23 age-matched non-professional swimmers as controls were recruited to perform the CR task with concurrent 8-channel EEG recordings. Reaction time and accuracy of the CR task were recorded. Topological network analysis of various frequency bands was performed using the phase lag index (PLI) technique to avoid volume conduction effects. The wiring number of connections and mean frequency were calculated to reflect the wiring and activity cost, respectively. Results showed that professional athletes demonstrated better eye-hand-foot coordination than controls when performing the CR task, indexing by faster reaction time and higher accuracy. Comparing to controls, athletes' brain demonstrated significantly less connections and weaker correlations in upper beta frequency band between the frontal and parietal regions, while demonstrated stronger connectivity in the low theta frequency band between sites of F3 and Cz/C4. Additionally, athletes showed highly stable and low eye-blinking rates across different reaction performance, while controls had high blinking frequency with high variance. Elite athletes' brain may be characterized with energy efficient sparsely wiring connections in support of superior motor performance and better cognitive performance in the eye-hand-foot complex reaction task.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pei2021sparsely,
  author = {Xinzhen Pei and Xiaoying Qi and Yuzhou Jiang and Xunzhang Shen and Anli Wang and Yang Cao and Chenglin Zhou and Yuguo Yu},
  title = {{Sparsely Wiring Connectivity in the Upper Beta Band Characterizes the Brains of Top Swimming Athletes}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2021.661632},
}
Figure