Sparse parallel independent component analysis and its application to identify linked genomic and gray matter alterations underlying working memory impairment in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder

Kuaikuai Duan, Jiayu Chen, Vince D. Calhoun, Wenhao Jiang, Kelly Rootes-Murdy, Gido Schoenmacker, Rogers F. Silva, Barbara Franke, Jan K. Buitelaar, Martine Hoogman, Jaap Oosterlaan, Pieter J. Hoekstra, Dirk J. Heslenfeld, Catharina A. Hartman, Emma Sprooten, Alejandro Arias Vásquez, Jessica A. Turner, Jingyu LiubioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "sparse parallel independent component analysis" (spICA), a novel method for integrating brain imaging and genetic data to uncover subtle links between genes and brain structure. spICA improves upon existing techniques by better handling the high dimensionality and sparsity of genetic data, leading to more accurate identification of brain-gene associations relevant to conditions like ADHD.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Psychiatric disorders are complex, with both genetic and brain structural/functional components. Linking specific genetic variations to brain alterations is challenging due to the small effect sizes of most genetic variants and the massive scale of genomic data. Traditional methods like parallel independent component analysis (pICA) struggle to disentangle true genetic signals from background noise in high-dimensional genetic datasets. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a more robust data fusion technique that can effectively identify subtle, yet significant, imaging-genomic associations.

Methods

The core contribution is the development of sparse parallel independent component analysis (spICA). This method builds upon pICA by incorporating a sparsity constraint on the estimated components. This sparsity is achieved through a nonlinear Hoyer projection, applied iteratively to the estimated components. This process aims to enhance true signals (like genetic associations with brain regions) while suppressing noise and background genetic variations. The method also includes an iterative reconstruction step to propagate the sparsity enhancements. Simulations were used to compare spICA against pICA, evaluating accuracy in detecting associations and recovering component maps.

Datasets

The study utilized two main datasets:

  • Discovery Dataset: 341 unrelated European Caucasian adults (127 controls, 167 ADHD cases, 47 unaffected siblings) from the NeuroIMAGE and IMPACT-NL projects. This dataset included structural MRI (sMRI) data and Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) array data.
  • Replication Dataset: 461 European Caucasian adolescents (144 controls, 129 unaffected siblings, 188 ADHD cases) from the NeuroIMAGE project. This dataset also included sMRI and SNP data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sparsity is Key for Genetic Data: The high dimensionality of SNP data means that many SNPs have little to no relevance to a specific brain trait. spICA's ability to enforce sparsity is crucial for isolating the few relevant genetic signals.
  • Nonlinear Transformations Unlock New Solutions: The nonlinear Hoyer projection in spICA allows it to find solutions that linear methods like pICA might miss, potentially revealing more complex relationships.
  • ADHD and Frontal Cortex Link: The study identified a specific SNP component associated with gray matter volume (GMV) in the superior and middle frontal gyri, regions known to be involved in working memory.
  • Age and Family Matter: The identified association was stronger in adults and older adolescents, and particularly pronounced in individuals from ADHD families (cases and siblings) compared to controls, suggesting a potential genetic predisposition.
  • Genes of Interest: The associated SNPs point to genes involved in long non-coding RNAs, as well as MEF2C, CADM2, and CADPS2, which are known to play roles in neuronal function and cognitive processes relevant to ADHD.

Key Results

  • Improved Detection: spICA demonstrated improved accuracy in detecting sMRI-SNP associations and recovering component spatial maps compared to pICA in simulations, especially under weak association settings.
  • Significant Discovery: spICA identified one significant SNP component associated with GMV in the superior/middle frontal regions in adults.
  • Replication: This association was successfully replicated in adolescents, though with a smaller effect size.
  • ADHD Family Specificity: The association was significantly stronger in subjects from ADHD families (cases and siblings) than in controls.
  • Age-Related Strength: The association was stronger in adults and older adolescents than in younger individuals.
  • Working Memory Link: The identified GMV component was associated with working memory deficits in both adult and adolescent ADHD cohorts.
  • Gene Identification: The associated SNPs highlight genes with known roles in neuronal substrates relevant to high-level cognition and ADHD.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Potential Overestimation: The authors acknowledge that spICA might overestimate associations, and they implemented several steps (adaptive step sizes, replication dataset) to mitigate this.
  • Dataset Overlap: Some participants from the NeuroIMAGE project were also included in the ADHD GWAS used for SNP selection, though the authors note that the GWAS data was only used for selection, not for the spICA analysis itself, to minimize inflation.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests that spICA can be a powerful tool for future imaging-genomic studies, particularly for complex disorders with small effect sizes. The identified genes and brain regions provide a foundation for further investigation into the biological mechanisms underlying ADHD and working memory. The spICA code is made available for broader use.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Most psychiatric disorders are highly heritable and associated with altered brain structural and functional patterns. Data fusion analyses on brain imaging and genetics, one of which is parallel independent component analysis (pICA), enable the link of genomic factors to brain patterns. Due to the small to modest effect sizes of common genetic variants in psychiatric disorders, it is usually challenging to reliably separate disorder-related genetic factors from the rest of the genome with the typical size of clinical samples. To alleviate this problem, we propose sparse parallel independent component analysis (spICA) to leverage the sparsity of individual genomic sources. The sparsity is enforced by performing Hoyer projection on the estimated independent sources. Simulation results demonstrate that the proposed spICA yields improved detection of independent sources and imaging-genomic associations compared to pICA. We applied spICA to gray matter volume (GMV) and single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) data of 341 unrelated adults, including 127 controls, 167 attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) cases, and 47 unaffected siblings. We identified one SNP source significantly and positively associated with a GMV source in superior/middle frontal regions. This association was replicated with a smaller effect size in 317 adolescents from ADHD families, including 188 individuals with ADHD and 129 unaffected siblings. The association was found to be more significant in ADHD families than controls, and stronger in adults and older adolescents than younger ones. The identified GMV source in superior/middle frontal regions was not correlated with head motion parameters and its loadings (expression levels) were reduced in adolescent (but not adult) individuals with ADHD. This GMV source was associated with working memory deficits in both adult and adolescent individuals with ADHD. The identified SNP component highlights SNPs in genes encoding long non-coding RNAs and SNPs in genes MEF2C, CADM2, and CADPS2, which have known functions relevant for modulating neuronal substrates underlying high-level cognition in ADHD.
BibTeX
@misc{duan2020sparse,
  author = {Kuaikuai Duan and Jiayu Chen and Vince D. Calhoun and Wenhao Jiang and Kelly Rootes-Murdy and Gido Schoenmacker and Rogers F. Silva and Barbara Franke and Jan K. Buitelaar and Martine Hoogman and Jaap Oosterlaan and Pieter J. Hoekstra and Dirk J. Heslenfeld and Catharina A. Hartman and Emma Sprooten and Alejandro Arias Vásquez and Jessica A. Turner and Jingyu Liu},
  title = {{Sparse parallel independent component analysis and its application to identify linked genomic and gray matter alterations underlying working memory impairment in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.07.11.198622},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure