SPADE: Spectroscopic Photoacoustic Denoising using an Analytical and Data-free Enhancement Framework

Fangzhou Lin, Shang Gao, Yichuan Tang, Xihan Ma, Ryo Murakami, Ziming Zhang, John Obayemi, Winston (Wole) Oluwole Soboyejo, Haichong K. ZhangarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Spectroscopic photoacoustic (sPA) imaging provides critical functional information for medical diagnostics by identifying tissues based on their unique optical absorption spectra. However, its clinical utility is often limited by high noise levels and the lack of large-scale "ground truth" datasets required for traditional deep learning denoising. This paper presents SPADE (Spectroscopic Photoacoustic Denoising), a hybrid framework that achieves over 15 dB SNR improvement using a "zero-shot" approach. By combining analytical filtering with data-free deep learning, SPADE preserves spectral integrity without the need for pre-trained models, making it highly adaptable to diverse clinical environments.

Introduction

Spectroscopic photoacoustic (sPA) imaging is a non-invasive technique that uses laser pulses to generate ultrasound waves, allowing for the visualization of chromophores like hemoglobin and gold nanoparticles. Despite its potential, sPA suffers from low signal-to-noise ratios (SNR) due to electronic noise and acoustic interference. Traditional denoising often requires frame averaging, which compromises temporal resolution, or deep learning models that require massive amounts of labeled training data—a resource rarely available in clinical settings. SPADE addresses these challenges by learning to denoise directly from the noisy data itself.

The SPADE Framework

The SPADE framework operates in three distinct stages to maximize noise reduction while maintaining the spectral correlations necessary for accurate tissue identification.

The SPADE framework (a) integrates Spectral Domain Data Re-assembly (SSDR) with a hybrid denoising pipeline consisting of BM3D and Zero-Shot Noise2Noise (ZS-N2N). The SSDR process (b) re-organizes 3D sPA data into a 2D format that preserves spectral relationships.

1. Spectral Domain Data Re-assembly (SDDR)

To ensure the denoising algorithm accounts for spectral relationships, SPADE first reassembles the 3D data cube (spatial dimensions $H \times W$ and wavelength dimension $\lambda$) into a 2D pseudo-image. This process, termed SSDR, groups pixels from the same spatial location across different wavelengths. This re-assembly allows the subsequent filters to "see" and preserve the spectral signatures essential for unmixing.

2. Analytical Denoising (BM3D)

The framework utilizes a modified Block-Matching and 3D filtering (BM3D) algorithm as an initial stabilizer. BM3D is a classical analytical method that excels at reducing Gaussian noise. In SPADE, it provides a cleaner baseline for the learning-based stage, preventing the neural network from over-fitting to extreme noise artifacts.

3. Zero-Shot Noise2Noise (ZS-N2N)

The final stage is a "zero-shot" learning component. Unlike standard Noise2Noise models that require pairs of noisy images, ZS-N2N uses a single noisy frame. By applying specific convolution masks to downsample the image into pairs with independent noise but shared underlying signals, the network learns to predict and subtract noise in real-time for that specific dataset.

Experimental Validation and Results

The authors validated SPADE across four scenarios: numerical simulations, physical wire phantoms, ex vivo swine cardiac tissue, and in vivo mouse tumor models.

  • Performance: In simulations, SPADE achieved an SNR improvement of over 15 dB. In ex vivo studies, it reached an SNR of 43.05 dB, nearly matching the 43.22 dB achieved by averaging 64 frames, but requiring only a single frame.
  • Spectral Fidelity: A key metric in sPA is the spectral correlation coefficient ($R$). SPADE maintained $R > 0.8$ even under high-noise conditions, ensuring that the "color" of the tissue—and thus its functional identity—remained accurate.
  • Clinical Utility: In vivo tests on mice with prostate cancer showed that SPADE effectively eliminated false-positive signals from contrast agents, providing a clearer map of tumor boundaries compared to standalone analytical or learning-based methods.

Conclusion

SPADE represents a significant step toward practical, high-fidelity sPA imaging. By eliminating the dependency on pre-trained datasets, it offers a hardware-agnostic solution that can be deployed across different clinical settings. While current processing times (approx. 70 seconds per multi-wavelength image) are a hurdle for real-time applications, future optimizations for GPU acceleration and non-Gaussian noise handling promise to bring this "data-free" enhancement framework into the operating room.

Summary updated

Abstract

Spectroscopic photoacoustic (sPA) imaging uses multiple wavelengths to differentiate chromophores based on their unique optical absorption spectra. This technique has been widely applied in areas such as vascular mapping, tumor detection, and therapeutic monitoring. However, sPA imaging is highly susceptible to noise, leading to poor signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and compromised image quality. Traditional denoising techniques like frame averaging, though effective in improving SNR, can be impractical for dynamic imaging scenarios due to reduced frame rates. Advanced methods, including learning-based approaches and analytical algorithms, have demonstrated promise but often require extensive training data and parameter tuning, limiting their adaptability for real-time clinical use. In this work, we propose a sPA denoising using a tuning-free analytical and data-free enhancement (SPADE) framework for denoising sPA images. This framework integrates a data-free learning-based method with an efficient BM3D-based analytical approach while preserves spectral linearity, providing noise reduction and ensuring that functional information is maintained. The SPADE framework was validated through simulation, phantom, ex vivo, and in vivo experiments. Results demonstrated that SPADE improved SNR and preserved spectral information, outperforming conventional methods, especially in challenging imaging conditions. SPADE presents a promising solution for enhancing sPA imaging quality in clinical applications where noise reduction and spectral preservation are critical.
BibTeX
@misc{lin2024spade,
  author = {Fangzhou Lin and Shang Gao and Yichuan Tang and Xihan Ma and Ryo Murakami and Ziming Zhang and John Obayemi and Winston (Wole) Oluwole Soboyejo and Haichong K. Zhang},
  title = {{SPADE: Spectroscopic Photoacoustic Denoising using an Analytical and Data-free Enhancement Framework}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2412.12068},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.12068},
}
Figure