Sources, transport and deposition of iron in the global atmosphere

Rong Wang, Yves Balkanski, Oliviér Boucher, Laurent Bopp, Adrian Chappell, Philippe Ciais, Didier Hauglustaine, Josep Peñuelas, Shu Tao2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides a comprehensive global inventory of iron (Fe) emissions from both combustion and mineral dust sources, revealing that combustion sources contribute significantly more soluble Fe to the atmosphere than previously thought. This improved understanding is crucial for accurately modeling oceanic productivity and the biological carbon pump.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Iron is a critical nutrient that limits phytoplankton growth in large parts of the global ocean, directly influencing the ocean's capacity to absorb atmospheric CO2. While mineral dust has long been recognized as a major source of atmospheric iron, the role of combustion sources (fossil fuels, biomass burning) has been less understood and often underestimated in biogeochemical models. This lack of clarity hinders accurate predictions of oceanic primary productivity and the carbon cycle, especially concerning the impact of human activities. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by developing a detailed global emission inventory for iron from both combustion and mineral sources, and evaluating its impact on atmospheric iron concentrations and deposition.

Methods

The authors employed a mass-balance method to estimate Fe emissions from combustion sources. This involved accounting for the Fe content in various fuels and how Fe partitions during combustion, considering particle size distribution and emission control technologies. They also utilized the latest soil mineralogical database to estimate Fe emissions from mineral dust. These newly compiled emission inventories were then integrated into a global 3-D transport model (LMDz-INCA) to simulate atmospheric Fe concentrations and deposition. Model outputs were rigorously compared against a large dataset of 825 surface aerosol measurements and 30 deposition stations worldwide.

Datasets

  • Fuel Fe content and combustion data: Derived from various sources, including the World Coal Quality Inventory, and specific studies on different fuel types (coal, petroleum, biofuel, biomass).
  • Soil mineralogical database: The latest available global dataset (Journet et al., 2014) was used to estimate mineral dust Fe emissions.
  • Atmospheric transport model: LMDz-INCA global chemistry-aerosol-climate model.
  • Observational data:
    • 529 surface aerosol Fe concentration measurements compiled from various peer-reviewed studies (Mahowald et al., 2009; Sholkovitz et al., 2012) and collected by the authors.
  • 296 Atlantic Ocean Fe concentration measurements from cruise data (Baker et al., 2013).
  • 30 stations measuring Fe deposition.
  • Long-term monitoring station data from Bermuda and Barbados (Arimoto et al., 1992, 1995, 2003).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Combustion's Significant Contribution: The study reveals that combustion sources contribute a substantial amount of atmospheric iron, particularly soluble iron, which is more bioavailable to marine organisms. This challenges the long-held view that mineral dust is the overwhelmingly dominant source.
  • Temporal Trends Matter: Combustion emissions, especially from motor vehicles, have shown a notable increase in fine and medium particles since 2000, altering the temporal dynamics of atmospheric iron input.
  • Mineralogy Refines Dust Estimates: Using a detailed mineralogical database for dust sources led to regional variations in Fe emission estimates, improving model simulations even in dust-dominated areas.
  • Solubility Amplifies Impact: The higher solubility of iron from combustion sources means their contribution to soluble Fe deposition is disproportionately larger than their contribution to total Fe deposition, with significant implications for oceanic ecosystems.

Key Results

  • Global Combustion Fe Emissions: Averaged 5.1 Tg yr⁻¹ for 1960–2007, with 2%, 33%, and 65% emitted in PM₁, PM₁₋₁₀, and PM>₁₀ respectively.
  • Global Mineral Dust Fe Emissions: Averaged 41.0 Tg yr⁻¹ for 2000–2011.
  • Model Performance: The global transport model generally predicted observed Fe concentrations well, with deviations within a factor of two at most stations. Agreement was particularly good at stations dominated by combustion sources (deviation within a factor of 1.5).
  • Oceanic Deposition: An estimated total Fe deposition sink of 8.4 Tg yr⁻¹ over global oceans, with 6.6% originating from combustion sources.
  • Soluble Fe Deposition: Combustion sources contribute an estimated 75% to the total deposition of soluble Fe over the oceans, a significantly higher figure than previous estimates.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dust Emission Uncertainties: The study acknowledges high uncertainty in dust emissions, particularly in the Southern Hemisphere, which warrants further investigation.
  • Fe Solubility Complexity: The estimation of soluble Fe deposition is highly dependent on prescribed Fe solubilities, which themselves have large uncertainties. More measurements of Fe solubility at various sources and in open oceans are needed.
  • Iron and Steel Industry: The paper notes that emissions from the iron and steel industry might be more important than previously thought, but their method could not be applied to estimate these specific emissions due to a lack of sufficient data. Measurements are urgently needed to constrain iron content from these sectors.
  • Chemical/Photochemical Factors: The study did not account for the influence of chemical, physical, or photochemical factors on Fe solubility. Future work could incorporate these aspects.

Summary updated

Abstract

Atmospheric deposition of iron (Fe) plays an important role in controlling oceanic primary productivity. However, the sources of Fe in the atmosphere are not well understood. In particular, the combustion sources of Fe and their deposition over oceans are not accounted for in current biogeochemical models of the carbon cycle. Here we used a mass-balance method to estimate the emissions of Fe from the combustion of fossil fuels and biomass by accounting for the Fe contents in fuel and the partitioning of Fe during combustion. The emissions of Fe attached to aerosols from combustion sources were estimated by particle size, and their uncertainties were quantified by a Monte Carlo simulation. The emissions of Fe from mineral sources were estimated using the latest soil mineralogical database to date. As a result, the total Fe emissions from combustion averaged for 1960–2007 were estimated to be 5.1 Tg yr−1 (90% confidence of 2.2 to 11.5). Of these emissions, 2, 33 and 65% were emitted in particles <1 μm (PM1), 1–10 μm (PM1−10), and >10 μm (PM>10), respectively, compared to total Fe emissions from mineral sources of 41.0 Tg yr−1. For combustion sources, different temporal trends were found in fine and medium-to-coarse particles, with a notable increase in Fe emissions in PM1 and PM1−10 since 2000 due to a rapid increase from motor vehicles. These emissions have been introduced in a global 3-D transport model run at a spatial resolution of of 0.94° latitude by 1.28° longitude to evaluate our estimation of Fe emissions. The modelled Fe concentrations were compared to measurements at 825 sampling stations. The deviation between modelled and observed Fe concentrations attached to aerosols at the surface was within a factor of two at most sampling stations, and the deviation was within a factor of 1.5 at sampling stations dominated by combustion sources. We analyzed the relative contribution of combustion sources to total Fe concentrations over different regions of the world. The new mineralogical database led to a modest improvement in the simulation relative to station data even in dust dominated regions, but could provide useful information on the chemical forms of Fe in dust for coupling with ocean biota models. We estimated a total Fe deposition sink of 8.4 Tg yr−1 over global oceans, 6.6% of which originated from the combustion sources. The higher than previously estimated combustion-related Fe emissions implies a larger atmospheric input of soluble Fe over the northern Atlantic and northern Pacific Oceans, which is expected to enhance the biological carbon pump in those regions.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2015sources,
  author = {Rong Wang and Yves Balkanski and Oliviér Boucher and Laurent Bopp and Adrian Chappell and Philippe Ciais and Didier Hauglustaine and Josep Peñuelas and Shu Tao},
  title = {{Sources, transport and deposition of iron in the global atmosphere}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.5194/acpd-15-7645-2015},
}
Figure