Source Structure and Molecular Gas Properties from High-resolution CO Imaging of SPT-selected Dusty Star-forming Galaxies

Chenxing Dong, Justin Spilker, Anthony H. Gonzalez, Y. Apostolovski, Manuel Aravena, M. Béthermin, S. C. Chapman, Chian-Chou Chen, Christopher C. Hayward, Yashar Hezaveh, Katrina C. Litke, Jingzhe Ma, Daniel P. Marrone, Warren R. Morningstar, Kedar A. Phadke, C. Reuter, Sreevani Jarugula, A. A. Stark, J. D. Vieira, A. WeißThe Astrophysical Journal 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses high-resolution ALMA observations of lensed dusty star-forming galaxies (DSFGs) to study the structure and kinematics of their molecular gas. They find that the molecular gas emission is generally more extended than the dust continuum, and that differential magnification due to gravitational lensing can significantly bias estimates of the interstellar medium's physical properties if not properly accounted for.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dusty star-forming galaxies (DSFGs) are crucial for understanding star formation in the early universe, but their obscured nature makes them challenging to study. Molecular gas, primarily traced by carbon monoxide (CO) emission, is the fuel for star formation. However, understanding the distribution and physical conditions of this gas requires high spatial resolution. Gravitational lensing offers a way to achieve such resolution by magnifying distant galaxies. This paper addresses the challenge of accurately interpreting CO observations of these lensed DSFGs, specifically investigating how the spatial distribution of CO emission compares to dust continuum emission and how gravitational lensing's differential magnification affects our understanding of the molecular gas properties.

Methods

The authors employ a visibility-based lens modeling technique using the visilens code. This method analyzes the raw interferometric data (visibilities) rather than reconstructed images, which helps to avoid correlated noise and better account for calibration errors. They model both the foreground lensing galaxy (using Singular Isothermal Ellipsoids) and the background source (using Sérsic profiles). For the background sources, they fit multiple Sérsic profiles to represent different components, such as dust continuum and CO emission at various velocities.

A key aspect of their analysis is the use of high-J CO lines (Jup = 6, 7, 8) observed with ALMA, which are brighter and more accessible at high redshifts than lower-J lines. They also incorporate lower-J CO data from other instruments for comparison. To study the physical conditions of the interstellar medium, they apply Large Velocity Gradient (LVG) radiative transfer modeling, using both apparent (lensed) and intrinsic (de-lensed) CO line ratios.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of ALMA Cycle 2 observations of five strongly lensed DSFGs at redshifts between 2.7 and 5.7. These galaxies were initially discovered by the South Pole Telescope (SPT) survey. The ALMA observations provide high-resolution (0.2"-0.4") data for high-J CO lines and dust continuum. The study also utilizes lower-resolution CO data from ALMA (Cycle 0) and the Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA) for comparison and to build a more complete CO ladder.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CO is more extended than dust: A consistent finding is that the region emitting CO emission is generally larger than the region emitting dust continuum, even for high-J CO lines. This suggests that the warmer, denser gas traced by high-J CO is more widespread than the regions of peak star formation traced by dust.
  • Differential magnification is significant: Gravitational lensing does not magnify all parts of a galaxy equally. The authors demonstrate that the magnification factor can vary by 20-50% across the CO line profile, between dust and CO emission, and between different CO transitions. This is a crucial point for interpreting observations.
  • Lensing biases physical property estimates: If differential magnification is not accounted for, it can lead to biased estimates of the molecular gas properties (e.g., temperature, density) when using LVG modeling. The magnitude of this bias is galaxy-dependent and not always predictable.
  • High-J CO lines are valuable but require careful modeling: While high-J CO lines are crucial for studying high-redshift galaxies, their interpretation is complicated by lensing effects. Understanding the source structure and magnification is essential for accurate physical parameter derivation.

Key Results

  • Good lens models were successfully fitted to four out of the five observed galaxies.
  • Three of the four well-modeled galaxies show clear velocity gradients, with two likely representing rotating disks.
  • The CO emission region is found to be less concentrated than the dust continuum emission for all studied galaxies.
  • Differential magnification was observed to be as high as a factor of 2, but typically around 30%, across line profiles and between different tracers.
  • LVG modeling showed that for SPT0346-52, the number of CO lines used had a greater impact on parameter constraints than differential magnification. However, for SPT2147-50, differential magnification significantly affected the inferred gas density.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that a simple SIE mass model was insufficient for one galaxy (SPT2134-50), suggesting the need for more complex lens or source models. They also note that while their study highlights the importance of differential magnification, determining the optimal strategy for future observations (e.g., number of lines vs. resolution) remains an open question. They suggest that observing two CO lines with widely separated Jup values is an efficient method to assess the impact of differential magnification. Future work should involve more detailed lens modeling with a larger number of CO transitions to better constrain the physical properties of these galaxies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We present Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) observations of high- J CO lines ( J up = 6, 7, 8) and associated dust continuum toward five strongly lensed, dusty, star-forming galaxies at redshift z = 2.7–5.7. These galaxies, discovered in the South Pole Telescope survey, are observed at 0.″2–0.″4 resolution with ALMA. Our high-resolution imaging coupled with the lensing magnification provides a measurement of the structure and kinematics of molecular gas in the background galaxies with spatial resolutions down to kiloparsec scales. We derive visibility-based lens models for each galaxy, accurately reproducing observations of four of the galaxies. Of these four targets, three show clear velocity gradients, of which two are likely rotating disks. We find that the reconstructed region of CO emission is less concentrated than the region emitting dust continuum even for the moderate-excitation CO lines, similar to what has been seen in the literature for lower-excitation transitions. We find that the lensing magnification of a given source can vary by 20%–50% across the line profile, between the continuum and line, and between different CO transitions. We apply Large Velocity Gradient modeling using apparent and intrinsic line ratios between lower- J and high- J CO lines. Ignoring these magnification variations can bias the estimate of physical properties of interstellar medium of the galaxies. The magnitude of the bias varies from galaxy to galaxy and is not necessarily predictable without high-resolution observations.
BibTeX
@article{dong2019source,
  author = {Chenxing Dong and Justin Spilker and Anthony H. Gonzalez and Y. Apostolovski and Manuel Aravena and M. Béthermin and S. C. Chapman and Chian-Chou Chen and Christopher C. Hayward and Yashar Hezaveh and Katrina C. Litke and Jingzhe Ma and Daniel P. Marrone and Warren R. Morningstar and Kedar A. Phadke and C. Reuter and Sreevani Jarugula and A. A. Stark and J. D. Vieira and A. Weiß},
  title = {{Source Structure and Molecular Gas Properties from High-resolution CO Imaging of SPT-selected Dusty Star-forming Galaxies}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ab02fe},
}
Figure