Source-Load Coordinated Low-Carbon Economic Dispatch of Electric-Gas Integrated Energy System Based on Carbon Emission Flow Theory

Jieran Feng, Junpei Nan, Chao Wang, Ke Sun, Xu Deng, Hao ZhouEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel two-stage optimization model for electric-gas integrated energy systems (IES) that coordinates energy supply and demand to minimize carbon emissions. By leveraging Carbon Emission Flow (CEF) theory and a Shapley value-based carbon trading mechanism, the model effectively guides demand response to reduce peak loads, increase renewable energy consumption, and lower overall carbon footprint.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing demand for energy, coupled with the urgent need to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions, presents a significant challenge for modern energy systems. Integrated Energy Systems (IESs), which combine electricity, gas, and other energy forms, offer a promising avenue for low-carbon development. However, effectively dispatching these complex systems to minimize carbon emissions while ensuring economic efficiency and accommodating renewable energy sources remains a complex problem. Specifically, the authors highlight the need to better understand and incentivize the demand side's role in carbon reduction, moving beyond price-based demand response to a system that directly addresses carbon responsibility.

Methods

The core of this research is a two-stage economic dispatch model:

  • Stage 1: Economic Dispatch with Carbon Emission Flow (CEF) Theory: This stage focuses on minimizing the energy supply cost. Crucially, it uses the CEF theory to accurately allocate the carbon emission responsibility from the supply side (generators, grid losses) to the demand side (energy hubs).
  • Stage 2: Low-Carbon Demand Response Optimization: This stage aims to minimize the load-side carbon trading cost. It employs a Shapley value-based method to establish a ladder-type carbon trading mechanism. This mechanism assigns different carbon prices based on an energy hub's carbon emission responsibility, incentivizing users to shift their demand.

The model iteratively optimizes these two stages until a stable solution is reached.

Datasets

The authors utilized a modified IEEE 39-bus power system integrated with a Belgian 20-node natural gas system for their simulations. This combined system serves as a benchmark for evaluating the proposed model's effectiveness.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Carbon Emission Flow (CEF) Theory is Key: The paper emphasizes that accurately attributing carbon emissions to the demand side is crucial for effective carbon reduction strategies. CEF theory provides a robust framework for this.
  • Shapley Value for Fair Carbon Allocation: Using the Shapley value method ensures a fair distribution of carbon emission responsibility among different energy hubs, forming the basis for an equitable carbon trading system.
  • Ladder-Type Carbon Pricing Drives Demand Response: The proposed ladder-type carbon price mechanism, with increasing prices for higher carbon responsibility, effectively incentivizes users to shift their energy consumption away from high-carbon periods, leading to peak shaving and valley filling.
  • Demand-Side DR is Crucial for Renewables: The model demonstrates that by strategically shifting demand, IESs can better absorb intermittent renewable energy sources like wind power, improving their utilization.

Key Results

  • Reduced Peak-to-Valley Load Difference: The model effectively smoothed out demand curves, reducing the difference between peak and off-peak loads.
  • Enhanced Wind Power Consumption: The model significantly increased the utilization of wind power, with consumption rates reaching 93.0% in a scenario with high wind penetration.
  • Reduced Carbon Emissions and Trading Costs: The proposed two-stage model achieved substantial reductions in both system carbon emissions (up to 6.2% in a wind-heavy scenario) and load-side carbon trading costs (up to 21.7%).
  • Stable Carbon Reduction with Increasing Renewables: Even as wind power penetration increased from 20% to 80%, the carbon reduction effectiveness of the model remained largely stable, indicating its robustness.
  • Superiority over Existing Methods: The proposed method demonstrated significantly better carbon reduction (281.8% and 203.7%) and wind power consumption (178.3% and 135.3%) compared to two other prominent carbon reduction strategies.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Simplified Load Classification: The current model treats all loads uniformly. Future work could differentiate between important, shiftable, and adjustable loads for more nuanced demand response.
  • No Energy Storage or Distributed Renewables: The study did not explicitly consider the impact of load-side energy storage or distributed renewable energy sources.
  • DC Power Flow Assumption: The power system model used DC power flow, which simplifies reactive power effects.

Future research directions suggested include incorporating load-side energy storage, distributed renewable energy, and more detailed load type classifications to further enhance the low-carbon demand response capabilities of IESs.

Summary updated

Abstract

The development of emerging technologies has enhanced the demand response (DR) capability of conventional loads. To study the effect of DR on the reduction in carbon emissions in an integrated energy system (IES), a two-stage low-carbon economic dispatch model based on the carbon emission flow (CEF) theory was proposed in this study. In the first stage, the energy supply cost was taken as the objective function for economic dispatch, and the actual carbon emissions of each energy hub (EH) were calculated based on the CEF theory. In the second stage, a low-carbon DR optimization was performed with the objective function of the load-side carbon trading cost. Then, based on the modified IEEE 39-bus power system/Belgian 20-node natural gas system, MATLAB/Gurobi was used for the simulation analysis in three scenarios. The results showed that the proposed model could effectively promote the system to reduce the load peak-to-valley difference, enhance the ability to consume wind power, and reduce the carbon emissions and carbon trading cost. Furthermore, as the wind power penetration rate increased from 20% to 80%, the carbon reduction effect basically remained stable. Therefore, with the growth of renewable energy, the proposed model can still effectively reduce carbon emissions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{feng2022source,
  author = {Jieran Feng and Junpei Nan and Chao Wang and Ke Sun and Xu Deng and Hao Zhou},
  title = {{Source-Load Coordinated Low-Carbon Economic Dispatch of Electric-Gas Integrated Energy System Based on Carbon Emission Flow Theory}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15103641},
}
Figure