Abstract
The investigation of technologies that can improve the sustainability of the air transport system requires not only the development of alternative fuel concepts and novel vehicle technologies but also the definition of appropriate assessment strategies. Regarding noise, the assessment should reflect the situation of communities living near airports, i.e., not only addressing sound levels but also accounting for the annoyance caused by aircraft noise. For this purpose, conventional A-weighted sound pressure level metrics provide initial but limited information as the level- and frequency-dependency of the human hearing is accounted for in a simplified manner. Ideally, subjective evaluations are required to adequately quantify the perceived short-term annoyance associated with aircraft noise. However, listening tests are time-consuming and not suitable to be applied during the conceptual aircraft design stage, where a large solution space needs to be explored. Aiming at bridging this gap, this work presents a methodology for the sound quality assessment of computational aircraft noise predictions, which is hereby conducted in terms of objective psychoacoustic metrics. The proposed methodology is applied to a novel medium-range vehicle with fan noise shielding architecture during take-off and landing procedures. The relevance of individual sound sources, i.e., airframe and engine noise contributions, and their dependencies on the aircraft architecture and flight procedures are assessed in terms of loudness, sharpness, and tonality. Moreover, the methodology is steered towards community noise assessment, where the impacts on short-term annoyance brought by the novel aircraft design are analysed. The assessment is based on the modified psychoacoustic annoyance, a metric that provides a quantitative description of human annoyance as a combination of different hearing sensations. The present work is understood as an essential step towards low-annoyance aircraft design.
Introduction
Standard aviation noise metrics, such as A-weighted sound pressure levels ($L_{p,A}$) or Effective Perceived Noise Level (EPNL), often fail to capture the full spectrum of human perception. Factors like the "sharpness" of high-frequency whines or the specific "tonality" of engine fans significantly influence community annoyance. While subjective listening tests provide the most accurate assessment, they are impractical during the conceptual design phase. This paper introduces an objective, automated framework to predict human annoyance using psychoacoustic algorithms applied to simulated noise data.
Methodology
The researchers developed the Sound Quality Analysis Tool (SQAT) and integrated it into a comprehensive simulation chain. This chain includes PrADO for preliminary aircraft design, SHADOW for calculating acoustic shielding effects, and PANAM for predicting total system noise reaching the ground.
The SQAT processes these simulations using four key psychoacoustic metrics:
- Zwicker’s Loudness (ISO 532-1): Measures perceived volume on a linear scale (Sones).
- Sharpness (DIN 45692): Quantifies high-frequency content.
- Aures’ Tonality: Identifies prominent tones against background noise.
- Modified Psychoacoustic Annoyance ($PA_{mod}$): A composite metric representing short-term human annoyance.
Comparative Study
The methodology was applied to compare two aircraft configurations:
- V-R (Reference): A conventional medium-range aircraft with under-wing engines.
- V-2 (Novel Design): A low-noise concept with engines mounted above the fuselage to shield the ground from fan noise.
Simulations covered standard approach (3° glide slope) and departure (full thrust) procedures.
Key Results and Insights
The study revealed that shielding significantly impacts perceived noise levels. The V-2 design was perceived as 30% quieter during approach and 48% quieter during departure compared to the reference. In terms of the $PA_{mod}$ metric, this resulted in an annoyance reduction of 10.1% for approach and 20.2% for departure.
Key observations include:
- Loudness as a Driver: Loudness is the primary contributor to the $PA_{mod}$ metric, suggesting that reducing perceived volume is the most effective way to lower annoyance.
- Lateral Trade-offs: While the V-2 is quieter directly under the flight path, it can be more annoying laterally due to higher thrust requirements and shifted noise directivity.
- Metric Robustness: A 94% correlation was found between $PA_{mod}$ and the industry-standard EPNL, validating the use of psychoacoustic metrics in design studies.
Conclusion
This framework bridges the gap between engineering simulations and human perception. By accounting for shielding and psychoacoustic factors early in the design process, engineers can better optimize for community impact. Future work will incorporate missing airframe tones and explore the trade-offs between external noise reduction and internal cabin comfort.
Summary updated