Solving the membership problem for certain subgroups of $SL_2(\mathbb{Z})$

Sandie Han, Ariane M. Masuda, Singh, Satyanand, Johann ThielarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper tackles the "membership problem" for specific matrix groups $G_{u,v}$ within $SL_2(\mathbb{Z})$, which are generated by matrices $L_u$ and $R_v$. They extend previous work by characterizing membership for $u+v > 4$ using continued fractions and compute the index of $G_{u,v}$ within itself, providing a complete picture for all $u,v \ge 1$.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The core problem is determining whether a given matrix $M = \begin{bmatrix} a & c \\ b & d \end{bmatrix}$ belongs to a specific matrix group $G_{u,v}$ generated by $L_u = \begin{bmatrix} 1 & 0 \\ u & 1 \end{bmatrix}$ and $R_v = \begin{bmatrix} 1 & v \\ 0 & 1 \end{bmatrix}$, where $u$ and $v$ are positive integers. This is known as the "membership problem." Previous work by the authors characterized membership for $u,v \ge 3$ by analyzing the continued fraction representation of the matrix entry $b/d$. This paper aims to extend this characterization to the broader case where $u+v > 4$. Additionally, it seeks to compute the index of $G_{u,v}$ within itself, denoted as $[G_{u,v} : G_{u,v}]$, which measures how many distinct cosets $G_{u,v}$ partitions itself into.

Methods

The paper heavily relies on the theory of continued fractions. The key idea is that membership in $G_{u,v}$ is intimately linked to the properties of the continued fraction expansion of the matrix entry $b/d$.

  • Continued Fraction Representations: The authors utilize both the standard and "short" continued fraction representations of rational numbers. The short representation is unique and has specific properties that are crucial for their analysis.
  • New Functions ($f_{u,v}$ and $g$): To handle the more general case of $u+v > 4$, the authors introduce new functions, $f_{u,v}$ and $g$, which are recursive and designed to manipulate continued fraction representations. These functions are analogous to functions used in prior work but are generalized to accommodate a wider range of $u$ and $v$.
  • Divisibility Properties: The core of the membership test lies in checking specific divisibility properties of the partial quotients in the continued fraction representation. The $(u,v)$-divisibility property requires that certain partial quotients are divisible by $u$ or $v$ depending on their position in the sequence.
  • Induction: Proofs are frequently established using strong induction on the length of the continued fraction representation.
  • Matrix Operations: Standard matrix operations and properties of $SL_2(\mathbb{Z})$ are used, particularly how multiplication by $L_u$ and $R_v$ affects continued fractions (as described in Lemma 6).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper deals with theoretical properties of matrix groups and continued fractions, not empirical data analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Continued Fractions as a "Fingerprint": The paper reinforces the idea that continued fraction expansions of matrix entries act as a unique "fingerprint" for membership in these matrix groups. Specific patterns in these expansions directly correspond to whether a matrix belongs to $G_{u,v}$.
  • The Role of "1"s: The elimination of "1"s in continued fraction representations is a critical step. The paper highlights how these "1"s encode sign changes in the alternating product representation of matrices in $G_{u,v}$. The new functions $f_{u,v}$ are designed to handle these "1"s more robustly than previous methods.
  • Generalization is Tricky: Extending results from $u,v \ge 3$ to $u+v > 4$ requires careful handling of cases, particularly when $u$ or $v$ is small (e.g., 1 or 2). The introduction of $f_{u,v}$ is a direct response to these complexities.
  • Index Calculation: The computation of the index $[G_{u,v} : G_{u,v}]$ provides a complete classification of these groups. The result that the index is finite if and only if $u+v \le 4$ is a significant structural insight.

Key Results

  • Membership Characterization for $u+v > 4$: The paper provides a characterization for matrices $M \in G_{u,v}$ when $u+v > 4$. This characterization is based on the $(u,v)$-divisibility property of the continued fraction representation of $b/d$ after applying the new function $f_{u,v}$.
  • Index Calculation: The paper determines the index of $G_{u,v}$ within itself:
  • $[G_{u,v} : G_{u,v}] = 1$ if $u+v \le 4$.
  • $[G_{u,v} : G_{u,v}] = \infty$ if $u+v > 4$. This result extends previous work and provides a complete understanding of the structure of these groups.

  • Correction of Previous Lemma: Lemma 2.3 in a previous paper [4] is corrected, which is important for the validity of subsequent results.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity of Functions: The newly defined functions $f_{u,v}$ are recursive and have many cases, making their direct implementation and analysis complex.
  • Specific Cases: While the paper covers $u+v > 4$, the behavior for small values of $u$ and $v$ (like $u=1, v=4$) still presents challenges, as illustrated in the example on page 19 where divisibility cannot be reached.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that further exploration of the relationship between continued fractions and matrix groups could lead to deeper structural understanding. The example on page 18 hints at the ongoing challenges in handling specific divisibility properties. The concluding remarks pose questions about whether Lemmas 1 and 2 are sufficient and if there are more general versions that could adjust components by larger values.

Summary updated

Abstract

For positive integers $u$ and $v$, let $L_u=\begin{bmatrix}1 & 0 \\u&1\end{bmatrix}$ and $R_v=\begin{bmatrix}1 & v \\ 0 & 1\end{bmatrix}$. Let $G_{u,v}$ be the group generated by $L_u$ and $R_v$. In a previous paper, the authors determined a characterization of matrices $M=\begin{bmatrix}a & c \\b&d\end{bmatrix}$ in $G_{u,v}$ when $u,v\geq 3$ in terms of the short continued fraction representation of $b/d$. We extend this result to the case where $u+v> 4$. Additionally, we compute $[\mathscr{G}_{u,v}\colon G_{u,v}]$ for $u,v\geq 1$, extending a result of Chorna, Geller, and Shpilrain.
BibTeX
@misc{han2021solving,
  author = {Sandie Han and Ariane M. Masuda and Singh, Satyanand and Johann Thiel},
  title = {{Solving the membership problem for certain subgroups of $SL\_2(\textbackslash\{\}mathbb\{Z\})$}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2110.02188},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2110.02188},
}

Loading related content...

Figure