Solution structure and dynamics of a de novo designed three-helix bundle protein

Scott T.r. Walsh, Hong Cheng, James W. Bryson, Heinrich Röder, William F. DeGradoProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 1999 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have successfully designed and determined the 3D structure of a novel, complex protein (73 amino acids) from scratch, not based on any natural template. This "de novo" designed protein exhibits properties characteristic of naturally occurring proteins, paving the way for creating custom protein structures with predictable folds for various applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing proteins with specific, stable, and predictable three-dimensional structures from the ground up (de novo design) has been a long-standing challenge in biochemistry and biophysics. While smaller protein fragments and miniproteins have been successfully designed, creating larger, complex proteins with well-defined hydrophobic cores and stabilities comparable to natural proteins has been significantly more difficult. Many previous attempts resulted in proteins with "molten globule" conformations – structures that are dynamic and lack the tightly packed cores essential for native protein function. This paper addresses the gap in designing and structurally characterizing larger, complex de novo proteins that mimic the stability and structural integrity of natural proteins.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining protein design principles with advanced biophysical techniques.

  • De Novo Design: The protein, named α3D, was designed using a hierarchical approach. It started with a known antiparallel three-stranded coiled coil motif ("Coil-Ser"). The helices were shortened, N-terminal capping boxes were added to define loop trajectories, and electrostatic interactions were rearranged to favor a specific counterclockwise topology. Crucially, a genetic side-chain packing algorithm was used to optimize the hydrophobic core, repacking it with a diverse set of amino acids.
  • NMR Spectroscopy: To determine the solution structure and dynamics, isotopically enriched α3D was prepared. A suite of multidimensional NMR experiments (including HNCA, HN(CO)CA, HNCO, HN(CA)CO, HNCACB, CBCA(CO)NH, C(CO)NH, H(CCO)NH, and various NOE experiments) were performed. These experiments allowed for the assignment of all resonances and the collection of distance restraints (from NOEs) and dihedral angle restraints (from coupling constants).
  • Structure Calculation: The collected NMR restraints were used to calculate a family of 3D structures using dynamical simulated annealing with the X-PLOR program.
  • Hydrogen-Deuterium Exchange: To assess protein dynamics and stability, amide proton exchange rates with solvent deuterons in 2H2O were measured. This technique provides insights into the accessibility of amide protons and can reveal information about cooperative unfolding units and residual structure in partially unfolded states.
  • Thermodynamic Characterization: Standard techniques like thermal unfolding and guanidine hydrochloride denaturation were used to assess the protein's stability and folding cooperativity. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) was also employed.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The protein itself was synthesized or cloned and expressed for the study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Predictable Folding of Complex Structures: The study demonstrates that it's possible to design complex, multi-helix proteins with well-defined, predictable three-dimensional structures from scratch, moving beyond simpler miniproteins.
  • Native-like Properties from De Novo Design: α3D exhibits thermodynamic and spectroscopic properties (cooperative unfolding, well-dispersed NMR spectra, hydrogen exchange patterns) typical of native proteins, validating the design strategy.
  • Importance of Interfacial Electrostatics and Capping Motifs: The design highlights the crucial role of interfacial charged groups in stabilizing the desired topology and preventing alternative folds, along with capping boxes that define loop trajectories.
  • Flexibility in Side-Chain Packing: While hydrophobic core packing is essential for stability, the study suggests that precise prediction of every side-chain rotamer might not be necessary for successful de novo design, indicating some inherent flexibility in protein folding.
  • A Platform for Future Evolution: The stability of α3D, similar to natural proteins, makes it a robust framework for introducing new functions through directed evolution, as mutations are less likely to disrupt the overall fold.

Key Results

  • The NMR solution structure of the 73-residue three-helix bundle protein α3D was determined.
  • The structure showed a counterclockwise topology, matching the design, with an overall backbone RMSD of 1.9 Å compared to the initial design model.
  • The protein exhibited cooperative thermal unfolding with a melting temperature (Tm) between 80-95°C and a significant free energy change for unfolding.
  • Hydrogen-deuterium exchange experiments revealed that nine amide protons had protection factors consistent with the protein's global stability, with eight of these located within helices 2 and 3, suggesting these form a stable cooperative unit.
  • The hydrophobic core was generally well-packed, with most side chains adopting a single predominant rotamer.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Rotamer Prediction Accuracy: The authors note that more than half of the observed side-chain rotamers in α3D were not accurately predicted by the earlier repacking algorithm used in its design. This suggests that while packing is critical, the precise geometry of every side chain might not need to be perfectly specified in the initial design.
  • Loop Disorder: One of the loops in α3D was found to be largely disordered, which the authors suggest could be a site for future functional evolution.
  • Future Directions: The paper implies that further improvements in design algorithms, particularly those allowing for backbone flexibility, could lead to even more stable and well-ordered protein structures. The stability of α3D also positions it as an excellent starting point for evolving new functions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although de novo protein design is an important endeavor with implications for understanding protein folding, until now, structures have been determined for only a few 25- to 30-residue designed miniproteins. Here, the NMR solution structure of a complex 73-residue three-helix bundle protein, alpha3D, is reported. The structure of alpha3D was not based on any natural protein, and yet it shows thermodynamic and spectroscopic properties typical of native proteins. A variety of features contribute to its unique structure, including electrostatics, the packing of a diverse set of hydrophobic side chains, and a loop that incorporates common capping motifs. Thus, it is now possible to design a complex protein with a well defined and predictable three-dimensional structure.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{walsh1999solution,
  author = {Scott T.R. Walsh and Hong Cheng and James W. Bryson and Heinrich Röder and William F. DeGrado},
  title = {{Solution structure and dynamics of a <i>de novo</i> designed three-helix bundle protein}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.96.10.5486},
}
Figure