SOLID–SOLID INTERFACIAL DYNAMICS AND MODELLING

Wei Chen, L Yang, Lingling Cao, Xu SiWIT 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a paradigm shift in modeling solid-solid interfaces by explicitly incorporating "nondissipative dynamics"—physics typically associated with superfluids—into traditional mechanical models. By treating the interface as a "supersolid" at specific resonant moments, the researchers can accurately predict complex phenomena like pulse-like sliding and interfacial resonance without the prohibitive computational cost of extreme mesh refinement.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In engineering, the interface between two solids is where the action is: it dictates stiffness, thermal performance, and structural stability. However, traditional numerical methods like the Finite Element Method (FEM) and Boundary Element Method (BEM) often struggle to match experimental observations of interfacial damage and plastic deformation.

The standard "fix" has been brute force: increasing mesh density or shrinking time steps until the simulation converges. This is computationally expensive and often fails to capture the underlying physics of why interfaces "resonate" or produce unexpected acoustic emissions. The authors argue that the gap exists because current models ignore a fundamental thermodynamic state: the nondissipative (isentropic) motion that occurs during periodic oscillations.

Methods

The authors bridge the gap between classical solid mechanics and advanced thermodynamics. Their approach involves:

  1. Isentropic Theory: They introduce the concept of "excess entropy." They hypothesize that in any periodic motion, there are specific points in time where entropy is zero. At these moments, the solid transitions from a dissipative state to a nondissipative "supersolid" state.
  2. Governing Equations: They derive a set of wave equations for momentum and energy conservation specifically for this supersolid state. Interestingly, these equations are mathematically identical to those used to describe superfluids.
  3. Dirac Combs: To handle the sudden impulses and "trains of pulses" observed at interfaces, the authors use Dirac combs (a mathematical tool representing a series of impulses) to define the initial and boundary conditions for the resonant supersolid.
  4. Analytical Solution: They solve a one-dimensional spatiotemporal velocity field, resulting in a formula that can be integrated into existing FEM software to account for interfacial resonance.

Datasets

The paper does not use a large-scale digital dataset. Instead, it validates its mathematical model against high-fidelity experimental data from established literature (specifically the work of Coker, Rosakis, and others). The benchmark involves:

  • Material: Homalite-100 (a brittle polyester resin) plates.
  • Setup: Two identical plates subjected to impact loading from a steel projectile.
  • Measurement: Dynamic photoelasticity used to capture isochromatic fringe patterns (stress contours) at a staggering rate of 160 million frames per second.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Supersolid" Interface: The most striking idea is that a solid interface can behave like a superfluid under oscillatory loads. In this state, it has virtually no shear resistance, explaining why plates "slide" much more than classical friction models predict.
  • Resonance is Key: Interfacial phenomena aren't just about friction; they are about resonance. The interface acts as a resonator that generates sound and creates discontinuities in field variables.
  • Physics over Brute Force: Instead of just throwing more CPU power at a finer mesh, including the physics of nondissipative dynamics allows for high accuracy with much coarser, more efficient models.
  • Entropy Zero-Points: The realization that dissipative and nondissipative dynamics coexist in periodic motion provides a theoretical "switch" for when to apply different sets of governing equations.

Key Results

  • Velocity Jump: The model successfully predicted the dramatic "jump" in velocity at the interface. In the experimental case, a perturbation velocity of 3.096 m/s amplified to a maximum interfacial velocity of 120 m/s.
  • Pulse Train Matching: The calculated "pulse-like train" (a series of spatial and temporal velocity peaks) showed a very high degree of agreement with experimental measurements.
  • Asymmetry Captured: The model accounted for the asymmetric nature of interfacial pulses—where velocity in the positive axial direction is slightly higher than in the negative—a detail often lost in simplified simulations.

Limitations and Future Work

While the results are promising, the paper primarily focuses on a one-dimensional spatiotemporal derivation. Real-world engineering problems are 3D and involve complex surface topologies.

The authors suggest that the next step is to fully integrate these nondissipative formulas into the integration equations of standard BEM and FEM software. Future research could also explore how this "supersolid" behavior changes across different material pairings (e.g., metal-on-polymer) and under varying environmental conditions like extreme heat, where thermal "Kapitza conductance" becomes a factor.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2024solidsolid,
  author = {Wei Chen and L YANG and Lingling Cao and Xu Si},
  title = {{SOLID–SOLID INTERFACIAL DYNAMICS AND MODELLING}},
  booktitle = {WIT},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2495/be470081},
}
Figure