Abstract
Soils are the largest terrestrial carbon store and soil respiration is the second-largest flux in ecosystem carbon cycling. Across China's temperate region, climatic changes and human activities have frequently caused the transformation of grasslands to woodlands. However, the effect of this transition on soil respiration and soil organic carbon (SOC) dynamics remains uncertain in this area. In this study, we measured in situ soil respiration and SOC storage over a two-year period (Jan. 2007-Dec. 2008) from five characteristic vegetation types in a forest-steppe ecotone of temperate China, including grassland (GR), shrubland (SH), as well as in evergreen coniferous (EC), deciduous coniferous (DC) and deciduous broadleaved forest (DB). Annual soil respiration increased by 3%, 6%, 14%, and 22% after the conversion from GR to EC, SH, DC, and DB, respectively. Despite higher soil respiration in woodlands, SOC storage and residence time increased in the upper 20 cm of soil. Our results suggest that shifts from grassland to woody plant dominance result in increased SOC storage, indicating that these areas are likely to accumulate and store increased amounts of organic carbon.
Introduction
Soils represent the largest terrestrial carbon reservoir on Earth, and soil respiration—the release of CO2 through microbial decomposition and root activity—is a critical flux in the global carbon cycle. In northern China, vast areas of grassland are transitioning into woodlands due to climate change and large-scale afforestation efforts like the "Green Great Wall." This study addresses the uncertainty regarding whether this transition makes the soil a net source or sink of carbon, quantifying both the carbon leaving the soil (respiration) and the carbon staying in it (storage) across a diverse forest-steppe ecotone.
Methods and Datasets
The researchers conducted a two-year field study (2007–2008) at the Saihanba Forestry Center in Hebei Province. They compared five vegetation types: Grassland (GR), Shrubland (SH), Evergreen Coniferous Forest (EC), Deciduous Coniferous Forest (DC), and Deciduous Broadleaved Forest (DB).
Key techniques included in situ soil respiration (SR) measurements using a Li-8100 automated system, soil sampling for organic carbon (SOC) and total nitrogen (STN), and microclimate monitoring of soil temperature and water content. Remote sensing data (NDVI) from MODIS satellites was used as a proxy for aboveground plant productivity.
Key Results and Carbon Dynamics
The study confirmed that higher respiration does not necessarily lead to lower carbon storage. While the Deciduous Broadleaved forest (DB) exhibited 22% higher annual soil respiration than the grassland, it stored nearly double the amount of soil organic carbon in the top 20 cm (~2800–2900 g m⁻² vs. ~1476 g m⁻² for GR).
Annual soil respiration increased relative to grasslands by 3% (EC), 6% (SH), 14% (DC), and 22% (DB). Microbial decomposition (heterotrophic respiration) was the dominant component, accounting for 76% to 95% of the total CO2 flux.
Environmental Drivers
Principal Component Analysis (PCA) revealed that soil temperature, moisture, nitrogen, and SOC together explained 83% of the environmental variation across the sites. While seasonal respiration is primarily driven by temperature, the differences in annual respiration between vegetation types were best explained by "substrate availability"—specifically the levels of SOC and nitrogen.
Carbon residence time was also found to increase in woodlands (up to 7.7 years in DC) compared to grasslands (3.4 years), suggesting that woody plants produce more stable organic matter. Additionally, grasslands in this region are more susceptible to wind erosion, which may further deplete their carbon stores compared to protected woodlands.
Limitations and Future Work
This study focused on the top 20 cm of soil; deeper horizons may respond differently over longer timescales. Future research should include direct in-situ partitioning of root versus microbial respiration and longitudinal studies following a single plot through successional stages. Finally, a complete Net Ecosystem Carbon Budget would be required to account for the significant carbon stored in aboveground tree biomass.
Summary updated